Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai

India-Forums

   
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai

True kartik is wrong, but naksh and kirti are the most selfish couple! (Page 3)

Ajscinesonadar Goldie
Ajscinesonadar
Ajscinesonadar

Joined: 04 January 2011
Posts: 2345

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 10:45am | IP Logged
Originally posted by AnyaRSingh

How i see it is that...people often react before thinking
Kartik had many chances to tell them the truth yet he hid it...and it even seems like he wouldnt have ever opened his mouth about it if he had a choice

he was seen been normal with naira kissing hugging her being normal with her

This troubled me like hell because i kept thinking even for a second how can he forget what he has done 

Old kartik would never hurt someone especially with lies... 

but then it made me think losing naira...and dealing with her illness has changed him...

It has made him selfish in a sense he has lived two years in misery without her but he somehow survived knowing she still existed and there was a chance of getting her back 

But her death or just not having her in his life again...makes him put her above everything...

Is it selfish i dont know...
I feel he is a victim of circumstances as well... 
because he had to deal with so much keerti's accident both labors the death of his own baby...his fear of losing naira... ALL on his own...

plus that nutty loop nurse whispering in his ear...

I dont blame keesh for their reaction as they would feel betrayed by him in any circumstances its their child...humans are very protective of their kids...

but at the same time i dont hate and want to see kartik slapped and trampled on because on some level i understand him and his pain...

Losing naira on top of all this will be the cherry on the cake...
for this poor guy if he has a mental breakdown i will kind of understand it


If the people here state the points this way , I would agree but here I have seen  people going against kartik due to strong hatred for kaira.

Hence this post basically out of curiosity to know how people gonna  react here.

I'm not defending kartik. But I don't naksh and kirti are matured.

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Viren4everCaptiveFreedomsigrid

Baby-nas Groupbie
Baby-nas
Baby-nas

Joined: 07 November 2016
Posts: 137

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 10:46am | IP Logged
Wow keesh are being termed selfish because they reacted the same way anyone else would in their place karthik is lucky he got just slaps because what he did was crime. By the way if naksh had what karthik did he would be crucified by the same fans who are making excuses for karthik

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

Chika_pika_rikaFari_15intruderfastTeluguAmmayiSwetha-Sai

Ajscinesonadar Goldie
Ajscinesonadar
Ajscinesonadar

Joined: 04 January 2011
Posts: 2345

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 10:48am | IP Logged
Originally posted by RapChick101



Well I say if being right is selfish then hell yeah they should be selfish.

Because for one second if I were in their shoes (lord forbid) I would smack the living daylights off Kartik's face for putting the new born at that spot and myself at worst. And no matter how many Nairas and their weak-ass healths came in the way.

Selfish isn't a bad thing.
Stealing any day is so we all know who stands where.

Stealing is wrong doing no denying dude...
How many times  would say not defending kartik.


The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

sigrid

Isolophiliac Senior Member
Isolophiliac
Isolophiliac

Joined: 23 June 2017
Posts: 318

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 11:23am | IP Logged
So true!! Keesh are so selfish and Kartik is so amazing as a brother that he hated just the thought of swapping the babies and putting his sister and brother in law and his wife's family through such mental trauma.. so nice of Kartik..and everything that's happening to keesh is just a bad dream..

How nice it would have been if that was true..but since it is not and Kartik did swap the babies knowing his sister is in coma and his wife's brother woke up from a serious accident... he had the guts to actually do this heinous crime knowing keesh has already lost their first baby and what it meant to them. After all of that he did, I don't feel an ounce of sympathy for him..his guilt, he deserved that and brought that upon himself because he stripped someone of their only hope while that someone was his sister.
The thought of saving Naira was noble and I would have understood him if he took Naksh into confidence before doing this or even after or even told him during this time. But he did not.
He just enhanced everyone's suffering...knowing it was all to end one day..

Now why keesh reacted like that...
Getting to know that your baby that you are mourning for from last one month was alive and right in front of your eyes is just so devastating...

And getting to know all this from someone else, they wouldn't have been able to believe that someone from their own family could have been so selfish.. from their pov, Kartik was never going to tell the truth to anyone because if he wanted to, he had plenty of time..

And calling naira "kisi aur... she is kisi aur in this context... a mother child's bond is different from anyone else in the world..during the first few months, your baby feels you, he starts knowing the world through his mother before his other senses are fully developed...when a mother breastfeeds her child, it's just special.. no one would want to share this experience regarding their baby with anyone else, even if she is your blood sister... mom baby bond is just too special... and Keerti stands stripped from everything..
And for a father as well, the tiny life becomes your world..and the feelings for your own child and your siblings is world apart...


And going by your pov.. Naira was so damn selfish yesterday.. when Rukmini suggested giving Kirti the baby just for few days till she's okay to handle the truth...
Naira and everyone else would have known that it's her baby.. it was just a pretence but she couldn't even do that.. she visibly clutched the baby to her heart frightened by that simple thought... Kirti didn't even have that...
though here I understand Naira's pov, she feels for her baby, it's not a doll that you can just hand over to someone.. it's her blood according to her...

Keesh's anger is just temporary..they might forget this month, living with their baby it might just become a bad memory, though being able to forget kartik's betrayal is going to be difficult..they will remember that this memory was inflicted upon them by him...

I want to feel bad for Kartik because for whom he did everything, she stands the loneliest today.. without any fault of hers, she will have to give the baby to Kirti since it's rightfully hers..
Also she never saw her first born, she'll never be able to touch her, feel her, look at her eyes, her tiny hands...
The baby she kept in herself for 7 months, whom she talked to, had moments with, fought tooth and nail for having that baby... she will never get her back like keesh lost the first month of their baby...
Poor girl stands stripped of everything because of Kartik and theirs no sympathy for him...

And lastly, saying Kartik did this because he was left alone.. really!! though I agree both the families are really dumb to leave him alone there.. anything could have happened and he's just some 20 something years old... he's no mature, haven't dealt with such critical situations... but blaming them for his crime is wrong.. he only holds the blame for doing all this.. he was wrong that day and every day that followed when he couldn't tell keesh or naira the truth...

The following 6 member(s) liked the above post:

Aayushi15NeerajaGirishTwisterfryFari_15meshmeshSwetha-Sai

CaptiveFreedom IF-Dazzler
CaptiveFreedom
CaptiveFreedom

Joined: 08 October 2014
Posts: 2568

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 11:29am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Fari_15

I get you like Kaira, I like them as well and watch the show for them, however, there is a difference in supporting your characters and idolising them.
One question, would you have said the same thing had Keesh been in place of Kaira? Would you have expected Kartik to not slap Naksh after finding out his baby, who he thought was dead for almost a month, had been taken away from him at its birth?
Do you even understand what losing a baby is? I don't understand how are people claiming what Kartik did is right just because he did it for Naira? Does Keesh's love for their baby mean nothing to you guys just because they are not the main leads.
And what did you expect from Keesh?
Naksh:
- his wife was in coma
- was told his baby djed
- he hugged Kartik minutes after Kartik had found out about the death of his own baby and gone though the same emotions, yet Kartik continued lying to him
- he left his wife in the hospital, put on a smile and came to celebrate the baby's chatti just so his sister isn't sad
- he stood there like a guest in his baby's naming ceremony while Kartik sat in the poja, named his baby, and presented the baby as his to the world.
Keerti:
- had a miscarriage
- days before her delivery, got into an accident
- coma
- got told her baby girl died a day later after she had woken up
- had to mourn for the loss of her baby for 11 days while Kartik continued to lie on everyone's face
But omg, Kartik doesn't deserve to he slapped because he's the hero and Keesh are just sidey's who shouldn't have emotions. Keerti shouldn't react to the fact that her very own brother gave her baby to his wife because the said wife got her married years before.
After finding out their baby, who they were mourning for for almost a month, they should have made sure Naira wasn't traumatised by the beating her husband was gonna get. Whatever you said makes complete sense to me Clap

Role reverse the situation...would never want Kartik to slap Naksh...never ever...I didn't support the idea of Manish slapping Swarna...for me even if Kartik reacted same way and slapped Naksh while facing similar situation it would be wrong...also CVs could have never ever made Kartik slap Naksh whatever the situation is!...I'm 101% sure...similarly they would never ever made Naira broke her relationship with Naksh after facing similar situation as Keerti...,the immature, impulsive Kaira won't have reacted same way...they might have given their baby to Keerti until she recovers completely...I don't expect understanding mature Keesh to react same way as Kaira...but they could have listened to him once...


Edited by CaptiveFreedom - 07 February 2019 at 12:08pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Ajscinesonadarkala_09sigrid

Ajscinesonadar Goldie
Ajscinesonadar
Ajscinesonadar

Joined: 04 January 2011
Posts: 2345

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 11:32am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Isolophiliac

So true!! Keesh are so selfish and Kartik is so amazing as a brother that he hated just the thought of swapping the babies and putting his sister and brother in law and his wife's family through such mental trauma.. so nice of Kartik..and everything that's happening to keesh is just a bad dream..

How nice it would have been if that was true..but since it is not and Kartik did swap the babies knowing his sister is in coma and his wife's brother woke up from a serious accident... he had the guts to actually do this heinous crime knowing keesh has already lost their first baby and what it meant to them. After all of that he did, I don't feel an ounce of sympathy for him..his guilt, he deserved that and brought that upon himself because he stripped someone of their only hope while that someone was his sister.
The thought of saving Naira was noble and I would have understood him if he took Naksh into confidence before doing this or even after or even told him during this time. But he did not.
He just enhanced everyone's suffering...knowing it was all to end one day..

Now why keesh reacted like that...
Getting to know that your baby that you are mourning for from last one month was alive and right in front of your eyes is just so devastating...

And getting to know all this from someone else, they wouldn't have been able to believe that someone from their own family could have been so selfish.. from their pov, Kartik was never going to tell the truth to anyone because if he wanted to, he had plenty of time..

And calling naira "kisi aur... she is kisi aur in this context... a mother child's bond is different from anyone else in the world..during the first few months, your baby feels you, he starts knowing the world through his mother before his other senses are fully developed...when a mother breastfeeds her child, it's just special.. no one would want to share this experience regarding their baby with anyone else, even if she is your blood sister... mom baby bond is just too special... and Keerti stands stripped from everything..
And for a father as well, the tiny life becomes your world..and the feelings for your own child and your siblings is world apart...


And going by your pov.. Naira was so damn selfish yesterday.. when Rukmini suggested giving Kirti the baby just for few days till she's okay to handle the truth...
Naira and everyone else would have known that it's her baby.. it was just a pretence but she couldn't even do that.. she visibly clutched the baby to her heart frightened by that simple thought... Kirti didn't even have that...
though here I understand Naira's pov, she feels for her baby, it's not a doll that you can just hand over to someone.. it's her blood according to her...

Keesh's anger is just temporary..they might forget this month, living with their baby it might just become a bad memory, though being able to forget kartik's betrayal is going to be difficult..they will remember that this memory was inflicted upon them by him...

I want to feel bad for Kartik because for whom he did everything, she stands the loneliest today.. without any fault of hers, she will have to give the baby to Kirti since it's rightfully hers..
Also she never saw her first born, she'll never be able to touch her, feel her, look at her eyes, her tiny hands...
The baby she kept in herself for 7 months, whom she talked to, had moments with, fought tooth and nail for having that baby... she will never get her back like keesh lost the first month of their baby...
Poor girl stands stripped of everything because of Kartik and theirs no sympathy for him...

And lastly, saying Kartik did this because he was left alone.. really!! though I agree both the families are really dumb to leave him alone there.. anything could have happened and he's just some 20 something years old... he's no mature, haven't dealt with such critical situations... but blaming them for his crime is wrong.. he only holds the blame for doing all this.. he was wrong that day and every day that followed when he couldn't tell keesh or naira the truth...


I said it kartik is wrong not denying it. Im concerned about naira here,  how much ever people back fire at me Il still say kirti and Naksh are selfish. 
Kirti even forgot naira''s name btw she became someone else for her. That's irked me for sure. 




The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

sigridkala_09

Ajscinesonadar Goldie
Ajscinesonadar
Ajscinesonadar

Joined: 04 January 2011
Posts: 2345

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 11:35am | IP Logged
Originally posted by CaptiveFreedom


Reverse the situation...would never want Kartik to slap Naksh...never ever...I didn't support the idea of Manish slapping Swarna...for me even if Kartik reacted same way and slapped Naksh while facing similar situation it would be wrong...also CVs could have never ever made Kartik slap Naksh whatever the situation is!...I'm 101% sure...similarly they would never ever made Naira broke her relationship with Naksh after facing similar situation as Keerti...,the immature, impulsive Kaira won't have reacted same way...they might have given their baby to Keerti until she recovers completely...I don't expect understanding mature Keesh to react same way as Kaira...but they could have listened to him once...

Lol, you really thing people here would get it what we exactly trying to say. Except Anya girl others comment evidently clear they won't get it.

Having said kartik is wrong, people trying claim this post as glorifying him whereas here main concern is naira not kartik's wrong doing.

Again  saying Kartik is wrong,  but Naksh should have considered naira..
And naira is no one to  kirti now thats for sure irked me.

Well, I believe tomorrow's  epi is not a dream


Edited by Ajscinesonadar - 07 February 2019 at 12:26pm

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

CaptiveFreedomsigrid

CaptiveFreedom IF-Dazzler
CaptiveFreedom
CaptiveFreedom

Joined: 08 October 2014
Posts: 2568

Posted: 07 February 2019 at 11:44am | IP Logged
Originally posted by Ajscinesonadar


Lol, you really thing people here would get it what we exactly trying to say. Except Anya girl others comment evidently clear they won't get it.

Having said kartik is wrong, people trying claim this post as glorifying him whereas here main concern is naira not kartik wrong doing.

Even if we don't consider about Naira...or her reaction...Naksh slapping him without even listening to him once is wrong...if it was a human's reaction than what Kartik did that time after losing his baby was also an impulsive action of a pressurized human being...though Kartik faltered in carrying that lie forward for long time...he wasn't planning to tell truth to Naira ever till that nurse talked about fake papers...

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Ajscinesonadarsigrid

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
NAKSH NAKSH NAKSH [L]

2 3

Author: NoMoreAFAN   Replies: 22   Views: 2208

NoMoreAFAN 22 2208 20 February 2016 at 9:42am by vim916
Naksh Naksh Naksh <3

2

Author: -Maryam   Replies: 14   Views: 4111

-Maryam 14 4111 06 November 2013 at 8:02am by swatikhanna
Naksh naksh naksh

2

Author: Kripa-banka   Replies: 10   Views: 3304

Kripa-banka 10 3304 06 September 2013 at 11:38pm by -Maryam
YRKKH:WU Naksh Naksh & Naksh

2

Author: .Mohabbatein.   Replies: 11   Views: 5127

.Mohabbatein. 11 5127 10 August 2012 at 7:55am by .Mohabbatein.
Naksh Naksh and only Naksh

2 3 4

Author: Ooolalala   Replies: 26   Views: 6548

Ooolalala 26 6548 16 January 2012 at 11:42am by maha_femir4ever

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index