Mahabharat

India-Forums

   
Mahabharat
Mahabharat

My opinion on THE INSULTS.

.Karna IF-Rockerz
.Karna
.Karna

Joined: 20 March 2016
Posts: 7828

Posted: 06 May 2017 at 4:58am | IP Logged
There are many conflicts on the issue wether Karna's revenge to insult Draupadi was right or wrong , and here i just want to share my opinion.
vese to personally  me ,dono hi incident ( swayamvar aur dyut sabha) ko galat manta hoon. Jo hua vo sahi nhi tha . 
,
log kehte hain ki vo Draupadi ka decision tha usme insult kya tha .

before commenting on this , i would like to share a story with you .

ek baar , ek black woman ,newspaper pe job vacancy ke invitation ko padh ke vahan jane ki sochti hai .
us job ke liye vo bilkul perfect thi . usko pura viswas tha . 
vahan interview se pehle ek exam clear karna hota tha , jo ek tarah se namumkin tha , jitne bhi highly qualified log aye ,unme se koi bhi vo exam clear nhi kar paya. par vo black lady kar payi .
interview ke liye age gayi to company ke selector ne use mana kar diya just because vo ek woman thi uper black .
vahan bhethe sabhi log hasne lage uspe , vo sab jo exam bhi clear nhi kar paye . 
kuch comments sunaye de rhe the 
" ye black log aab hum white logo se competion karne lage hain! " 
" in ladkiyon ko samjh nhi ata ki inki asli jagah Kitchen me hai, yahan nhi " 
" ab to laurat log bhi mardo ki jagah lena chahti hain" 

ye sunte hi vo vapas apne jagah chali gayi .

.
.
.
.NOW , i want to ask , kya yeh koi insult thi? isme kya galat tha ? 

company ko koi black woman nhi chahiye thi , vo apne company ke malik hai , unko jo insaan sahi nhi laga usne use mana kar diya .
aur vo ladky ko bura kyu laga , vo use insult kyu samjhti hai , kya vo black nhi hai , kya vo ek woman nhi hai , jab hai , aur usne accept bhi kar rakha tha to use ye apni identity ek insult kyu lagi ?


hope samjh me aa gayi hogi  ki , vo swayamvar Karn ki insult kyu thi . 
aur co relate karne ki kosis karna , jo scene us ladki ke sath hue hain vo actually modified version hai jo karn ke sath hua tha .

now , think about this , . us black lady ko nikalte hi , ye elaan kiya jaye , ki ab duniya me koi bhi insaan ake is job ki vacancy le sakta hai , irrespective of cast , gender and color . tab us balck lady ko kesa lagega , kya vo abhi bhi ise apni insult na mane. hmm


one more thing , Draupadi ne to pehle hi arjun k apna husband maan liya tha , par fir bhi swayamvar rakha . Dont you think so ki ye to vahan aye hue sabhi kings ki insult hai . 
think it like this ,  tum ek company ki job ki vacancy ke liye jaa rahe ho , par us company ne pehle hi decide kar liya hai ki vo kis ko as an empolyee choose karegi ,  then wont you feel cheated . Wont it be your insult.  Kya ye galat nhi hai . Amba ne bhi pehel se hi apna husband chun rakha tha , fir bhi swayamvaar ka dhong rachaya . 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

par kabhi kabhi log fir bhi nhi mante , aur kehte jo hua vo galat nhi tha , to fir me unki soch ko inherit kar leta , fir me manta ki haan , jo swayamvar me hua , vo itna bhi galat nhi tha ...but ..but ...jo dyut sabha me hua , me usko bi galat man ne inkaar kar deta . Situation ke hisab se apne aap ko dhaal leta hoo kya karu .

so , kya hua kya tha . 
Karn ne kaha ki ek slave royal things nhi pehnta , aur usne pandava aur druapadi ko vo sab nikalne ko kahe . 

pandava ne bina kuch kahe apne saare jewelries, mukat ,earings , sab nikal ke rakh diye , fir slave ka form le liya. 
par draupadi adi rhi . usne vo sab sacrifice karne se mana kar diya . 

bas itna hi hua tha , log pata nhi kyu samjhte hain ki uske dresses nikalne ko kahe , esa kisi bhi book me nhi likha .

hota kya tha , us samay to koi upper body pe kuch pehnta bhi nhi tha , just ek kapda lower body ko dhaka karta tha , jo simple sa hota tha . to undress ki to baat bhi nhi aa sakti .

original mahabharat ek poem ke form me likhi gayi thi . usme metaphors use kiye gaye the . 
par aaj ke translator kuch galat hi samjh gaye .

vo jeweleries , royal hone ki nishani hoti thi . aur ye to sab jante hain ki us samay women ke liye uski jeweries hi uski izzat hoti thi ( kyunki kapde to us time hote hi nhi the) ...aur ek kul vadhu ke sath ho to vo ek insult hi hai .

to ved vyas kehna chahte the ki jis tarah se dushashan un jewleries ko nikal raha tha , vo esa lag raha tha jese mano , draupadi ka vastr haran ho raha ho . 

basically , draupadi ka vastrharan to hua hi nhi tha , ye misunderstanding hai. 
us time me esi chhoti soch nhi hoti thi . ye aaj ke time ko dekh ke change kiya gaya hain . agar koi bhi sanskrit ka knowledgeable ho to us original poem ko padh ke dekh le . itna sabko samjh aata hai .

jo bhi ho , karn politically right tha , ki ek slave ko vo jewleries pehn ne ki izzat nhi hai .

dusri badi baat , Unchaste kehna...ek to logo ko pata nhi hai ki unchaste aur wh**e me difference hai .. google pe search karlo

to me keh raha tha , draupadi ko usne unchaste kaha tha jo morally right tha . yes , koi bhi ja ke puranas , vedas , ya upnishad khol ke padh le . usme likha hai ki ek woman ke 3 man ke se jyada se physical relation use unchaste sabit kar deta hai . 

vese draupadi , yagyeseni thi, use vardaan mila tha ki vo whole life chaste rahegi . 
but ,...but ..but ...Karna never believed on birth rights , he believes on deeds , aur draupadi ki deeds karn ko chaste bilkul nhi lagte hai .( vese dusro ko bhi nhi lagte hunge , par kisi ke pas guts nhi hunge ki hastinapur ki kul vadhu ko muh pe bol sake , karn me tha , agar vahi draupadi kisi low caste poor family se hoti , aur 5 husband hote , tab to har koi yahi boli uspe barsata , itna to mante hi hunge aap sab ) . 

basically me kehna chahta hoon , jese swayamvar me draupadi ka decision tha vo , vese hi dyut sabha me , ye karn ka opinion tha , and hume sikhaya gaya hai ki dusro ke decisions aur opinions ki respect karni chahiye . 
vese bhi sabko to pata tha na , draupadi ko boon hai , vo hamesha chaste rahegi , to draupadi ko kya farak padta hai ki koi bhi uske bare me kya opinion rakhta hai . 

to finally , Karn bhi galat nhi tha iss scene me . usko right to speech tha , usne use kar liya . 

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

vese dyaan se soche to vo dusri vali baat  sach hai par , thodi ...ah ...kadvi si lag rhi hogi 

isiliye to me personally , pehle vali theory accept karta  hoon, khamkha log mujhe dusri vali theory accept karane me lag jate hainErmm



P.S - I am really sorry agar koi offend huya ho to  . me hurt karne ke intention se nhi keh raha tha ye sab , mujhe bas logic lagane me maza ata hai ...jo mene laga diya Smile

koi criticize karna chahta hai , you are most welcome , i am always open for you Wink


joota , chappal , tamatar , everything is acceptable here LOL


Edited by .Karna - 06 May 2017 at 5:10am

  • Page 1 of 1

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Mahabharat Written Update: 22/03/14 -Shishupal insults Krishna

2

Author: Bhavaani   Replies: 10   Views: 2614

Bhavaani 10 2614 23 March 2014 at 1:32am by Surish

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index