Originally posted by ~*sindhu*~
True, thats why I don't blame anybody. It has always been circumstances and the winchesters have blamed themselves because they couldn't protect them and they died because they were involved with them. But if I have to ever pick up a case where the Winchesters should be blamed it will be for Kevin cause he never wanted this life. He never wanted to be in the middle of all this. Destiny or not if someone said they don't want anything to do with and the Winchesters thought better and dragged him in then yes they are to be blamed for not being able to protect that guy. I still won't blame them for it because like you said Gadreel betraying them was not something Dean was counting on.
But how do I do the same with Charlie when she herself wanted to protect Dean. I don't find Sam responsible for asking for her help. She was family and he asked for her help just like he would have asked for help from Bobby or Cas.I see it like that . If she would have stayed with Cas then she would have been safe all along . I would blame crappy writing though.
Charlie never wanted to see the Winchesters again too, remember? But she kept running into them time and time again and then chose to be a hunter because she felt that was her true calling. Yeah, she died to protect Dean because she considered him a brother. In the same way, Kevin never wanted to be in either but got in because he was destined to. He too then began to make peace with his own fate as he was to be a prophet. While Charlie died helping Sam to save Dean, Kevin died helping Dean to save Sam. Sam failed to protect Charlie just as bad as Dean failed to protect Kevin.
So, if I feel Sam is responsible for Charlie's death to an extent, I also believe Dean is responsible for Kevin's death to an extent. If I blame, I blame both or nobody. No clean chit given to either of them. However, lets keep in mind that Dean killed that Styne boy for no reason at all. It was going way, way too far. 😳 And don't tell me, its the Mark. Its not the Mark, its Dean and he's still human but just someone whose lost his marbles and for me, that's not a reason enough for justification.
Edited by .annihilation. - 8 years ago