Why did DD lie???

Yesterday everything was clear but I have 1 doubt.. Why did DD lie to Roshni that her father is dead??😕😲 What difference could it have been made if she told her that he left them or are divorced? It was OK that she hid it when Roshni was small, but I really felt she could have told Roshni this story when she was 18 or 19yrs.. By that time I'm sure Roshni would have been capable of understanding things..😕 She would have been having the same heartbreak then knowing the truth, which she is having now😕

And it could have made a lot of difference in their lives.. If DD had told this truth at the right time, I'm sure Roshni's respect for DD must have been increased manifold and Maa - Beti relation wouldn't have gone sour, it could have been resolved even before Sid😕

Moreover, the biggest benefit would have been that Roshni woudn't have had the notion 'That all rich people are bad and middle class people are good' This would have prevented Sid from pretending to be middle class and the entire story of Roshni's life could have been different..If the truth was known, most probably Roshni would have been hating middle class people, so rich Sid would have been welcome.. Even DD would have been happy with rich Jamai😊

 DD could have told this story  atleast when Roshni was going to marry a middle class Sid, rather than trying to stop the wedding by switching the groom and doing stupid things to stop the wedding.. I think if DD told Roshni why she hated middle class people, I'm sure Roshni would have reconsidered her decision (Could have even backed off from the marriage like when DD faked heart attack, then may be Sid could have revealed that he is not middle class but is rich😉)

So, the entire story of JR rests on this single lie of DD😛 If it was not for this lie, Jamai wouldn't have to patch up maa - beti  and Sid wouldn't be the ghar jamai and the entire story would have been something else😉 What do u guys think??
Edited by zoopassion - 8 years ago

true but it DD and Roshni never had a ruff relationship, then she would not have been upset at the airport and Sid would not have tried to cheer her up, hence them meeting for the first time

How can DD open up the facts that she herself wanted to forget those bitterness & pain in her life? Won't it again hurt her as well as her whole family?

Originally posted by: zoopassion

Why did DD lie to Roshni that her father is dead??

May be that time she didn't had any option other than telling he is dead...😕

What difference could it have been made if she told her that he left them or are divorced? 

In DD pov he is still gud na if she told like this then roshni would have hated her dad na... And roshni notion may be like this "that all the boys are bad, I won't marry anyone in the future"😕😃

If DD had told this truth at the right time, I'm sure Roshni's respect for DD must have been increased manifold 

Once she told he is dead so there is no need to say the truth to roshni abt his dad, and she may felt he won't return anytime...🤢 even if she said truth to her, roshni ll get heart broken na so she didn't said anything until roshni demands her to say the truth...😕

Moreover, the biggest benefit would have been that Roshni woudn't have had the notion 'That all rich people are bad and middle class people are good' 

This is the main concept in jr for roshni to marry sid... If they didn't married then nothing happnd in their lives..even sid won't bring shiv to them then roshni won't asked abt shiv to DD...😆

I think if DD told Roshni why she hated middle class people, I'm sure Roshni would have reconsidered her decision (Could have even backed off from the marriage like when DD faked heart attack, then may be Sid could have revealed that he is not middle class but is rich😉)

 

If she said truth to roshni, I'm sure roshni would have thing DD wants to stop their marriage...😉

So, the entire story of JR rests on this single lie of DD😛 If it was not for this lie, Jamai wouldn't have to patch up maa - beti  and Sid wouldn't be the ghar jamai and the entire story would have been something else😉

If DD didn't lied then roshni won't married sid and if sid didn't lied then he won't been as dd's jamai...and if they both didn't lied then we won't have been watch this show...😆 Of course we watching this show only for concept and Dur-sidni na...😳