Posted: 11 May 2015 at 2:05pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by DiyaRathore
"Is it bcaz he is playing ishu's ex,?
Is it bcaz he came in the absence of Raman?
Is it bcaz he replaced the original actor?? "
First things first, this is just your wild assumptions. Sorry to say, I find it very silly.
Let's look at why:
Anurag aka Param tried to rape Ishita.
Param also has come in absence of Raman to fill his void.
The original actor acted just a mere 1-2 min scene, no one remembers him as Subbu after AT's inclusion.
first two points, no one had "unjustifed" criticism/bashing against
Param that he tried to rape Ishita or just a few days ago came to fill
Raman's void. In fact eveyone praised his acting last year and in
Raman's absence, when he made a come back , everyone was so elated. So
it is ONLY related to acting.
example can be counted as Mani who stood in between Ishita and Raman.
He created lots of havoc in IshRa's life as a couple, his character and
the track focusing him both were poorly sketched and executed. Yet
viewers had criticized the character Mani but not the actor. Sumeet
Sachdev wasn't very great, he was average but as far as my memory is
concerned, I never saw anyone saying he couldn't act. So what went wrong
Well, the answer is simple, Amit Tandon can't
act. He is not a newbie, had acted in multiple daily soaps before but he
was never termed as a "great actor". In fact his first show Kaisa Ye
Pyar, he wasn't very good at acting, he was okayish. He was often
criticized for his acting because the protagonist was as good as Iqbal
Khan. For that reason, later he was turned into a negative character
from the parallel lead. Since then he was never really praised for his
Now when it comes to YHM, he's gone worse. He is
in YHM for almost a month now but his acting is degrading day by day. If
anyone watches his acting tonight, he/she will have to accept it was
pure crap and it is NOT for the first time. This guy hardly moves his
facial muscle to give an expression.
"Its started frm his very beginning scene where he expressed Subbu's tragic and guilty state thru his eyes itself.." Really?
It may be ur POV and I respect that.But I clearly remember that scene
where I saw Raman was aptly expressive portraying tragedy and pain where
Subbu was just bland, totally off. Even at that time many forum members
said that Subbu was just pretending, that's why proper emotions from
his side was missing.
Gautam's case is very different. I believe
if he acts as a pure negative character like Adi again, he will go
wrong again. Because pure evil Adi was an unrealistic character in the
first place and it's not easy for a 12 year old boy to portray such
multiple shaded shady character. Now Adi no longer portrays such
unrealistic evil character, so his acting turns out to be very fine.
In case of Amit, it's nothing like that. He just can't enact some simple
scenes. If you want I can give you detailed analysis of his acting on
such mundane scenes which an average actor should easily pull off.
Sadly, he failed numerous times. And, today's episode proved that he
missed the train now.
Bang on. I wanted to witre something too but you've covered it all.