Jodha Akbar 11th May 2015..18 minutes in DEK + my views..Post Upd Pg-1 - Page 5

Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by neesha19


Dear Abhay,
Thnks for your update and for your views as well. The episode was bearable but I did not get one thing..Why was Jo demanding  so much wealth...? What was the point in doing so?   There was no valid reason shown for this. Just to show how much she respected Hamida ..? It seemed so vague .

I liked Jodha yelling at Jalal today.  Good he deserved it.. Never thinks twice before humiliating Jo in public ..for whatever reasons.. You are right Abhay.  We wanted to see a strong MEH and a strong Akbar.. Tedha Akbar is also fine but  he should not take Jo for granted always.. What if she had gone to extreme and  had consumed poison or tried to commit suicide . How come he thinks she  will take all in her stride and he  has the confidence also that she loves him so much .. she will  forgive him anyways.. This Shah Iran track was mixed with Saas bahu drama.. and it lost all the glitter.. It was all lost somewhere..  

What  more we we get to watch now?? I just hope..its not a repeat of Ben track.. How I would hate it... 


Neesha,
I think she was trying to create some sort of problem / obstacle so that Jalal can not give divorce to her so easily. Perhaps, this was the reason.


"Upcoming track is good".  <- Let us see, how much truth is there in this bit.

Edited by history_geek - 8 years ago
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by history_geek




Neesha,
I think she was trying to create some sort of problem / obstacle so that Jalal can not give divorce to her so easily. Perhaps, this was the reason.



Neesha Abhay, i think, Jodha was doing so, when all jewellery +wealth will finish, then she will say, More, or then Begums will put jewellery, or wealth, or when HB will give her some she will stop,;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;showing, Her love was not so small, as a daughter, as a Daughter -in Law, she only wants MUM, or Mother In Law, some, thing,  which will be more precious for her. Her realtionship, with HB too much big, but cause of respect she needs her, Nishani.

( as in Tradition, we store some things for our Elders, or relgious places )



Edited by ayushimehra - 8 years ago
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by history_geek



Views:


For Point number..1

I am thinking about the Creative brain which made this track ?
Is this supposed to be a method to teach something to anyone ?

Like i said initially, in this track i did not like Jodha because her character lacked conviction. CV's had shown her succumbing under pressure , it was ok.
But i wanted to see some trials on her part..
She can succumb, i understand she is human, but i wanted to see, some INTELLIGENT move from her, before converting... Anyways, lets leave that, we discussed a lot about that.

Similarly what Jalal did now was not acceptable..
I do not agree that, JUST for TEACHING a lesson to his mother, you give the shock of DIVORCE to your wife...


For Point number..2

I want to know how many husbands agree with their wife, and become a "MURGA" ?
I have understood many kochey-koo scenes till now in JA, but today...what was that ?

Today it was such a BLOW when i saw Jalal speaking such things.

More than that, i did not like,
the expressions on Akbar's face, which depicted a helpless person, who was utterly confused, and was "ready to cry"..

How many husbands do like that. I Want to know. I want to meet the writerS now, who penned such dialogues. This is NR but still the CV's are using the name of someone who is not fit to be treated like this.

Anyways, i know, many might have enjoyed the "AkDha" scenes today as well, the episode was COMPLETELY about Jodha AND Akbar. Good chemistry is another thing, but i do not agree with this treatment..



After a long time, our opinions were similar Abhay. This is what I had written about the episode yesterday elsewhere.

"The most tasteless track this one - Jodha succumbing  to pressure  inspite  of  knowing  what is right and wrong. Is this the  kind  of  resilience and perseverance  you expect  from the queen mother of Hindustan?

Will any king/ emperor  create a public divorce  drama to mend his mom-wife relationship? Isn't  it ridiculously scandalous? What paigham will reach the  awaam? That talaaq threat is wajib? Wish this Jalal's  court had press and magazines.

And murga/gadha was the last straw.

And the worst let down  was Rajat. Why did he have  to  look  so bewildered  and pathetic saying  sorry. There was no tease, no softness, no pain at having hurt her badly. Instead he looked like a circus clown. If the script has stripped Akbar of 90% of his greatness and magnificence Rajat's  expressions  these days are stripping him of the remaining  10. Ravi Bhatia's expressions  were a notch better today as he expressed  realisation of his Dad's tedapan and joy and relief at the  impact and smile at the humour, all these in fleeting  seconds while Rajat was looking  ridiculous  trying  to  pacify his wife who was nowhere near queenly either."

Also, how could Jalal be sure that Hamida would place her ear rings and Jodha would utter senti dialogs that would change HB's heart? Infact what made HB place her earrings? Was the treasury empty with those titbits on the table?
Edited by Sandhya.A - 8 years ago
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by Sandhya.A



After a long time, our opinions were similar Abhay. This is what I had written about the episode yesterday elsewhere.

"The most tasteless track this one - Jodha succumbing  to pressure  inspite  of  knowing  what is right and wrong. Is this the  kind  of  resilience and perseverance  you expect  from the queen mother of Hindustan?

Will any king/ emperor  create a public divorce  drama to mend his mom-wife relationship? Isn't  it ridiculously scandalous? What paigham will reach the  awaam? That talaaq threat is wajib? Wish this Jalal's  court had press and magazines.

And murga/gadha was the last straw.

And the worst let down  was Rajat. Why did he have  to  look  so bewildered  and pathetic saying  sorry. There was no tease, no softness, no pain at having hurt her badly. Instead he looked like a circus clown. If the script has stripped Akbar of 90% of his greatness and magnificence Rajat's  expressions  these days are stripping him of the remaining  10. Ravi Bhatia's expressions  were a notch better today as he expressed  realisation of his Dad's tedapan and joy and relief at the  impact and smile at the humour, all these in fleeting  seconds while Rajat was looking  ridiculous  trying  to  pacify his wife who was nowhere near queenly either."

Also, how could Jalal be sure that Hamida would place her ear rings and Jodha would utter senti dialogs that would change HB's heart? Infact what made HB place her earrings? Was the treasury empty with those titbits on the table?

You re right Sandhya..Today Ravi Bhatia's expressions were good.. He really seemed relieved when he realises Jalal was just acting. Even Daniels      expressions were good when he sees Jodha and Hmida hugging.. Jalal was like.. OK .. I can handle Jodha.. after all she loves me. where can she go..?? 
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by ayushimehra



Neesha Abhay, i think, Jodha was doing so, when all jewellery +wealth will finish, then she will say, More, or then Begums will put jewellery, or wealth, or when HB will give her some she will stop,;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;showing, Her love was not so small, as a daughter, as a Daughter -in Law, she only wants MUM, or Mother In Law, some, thing,  which will be more precious for her. Her realtionship, with HB too much big, but cause of respect she needs her, Nishani.

( as in Tradition, we store some things for our Elders, or relgious places )




OMG .. bahut door ki soch thi Jo ki... 
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by vinitaj27


Hey abhay
I love reading ur updates the info u provide and the views u give regardless of whether i agree with them or not. I think we all are old enough to accept that everyone is entitled to their opinion and just coz it is not same as urs doesnt mean it is wrong. The amount of effort u put into ur research n posts is unbelievable and ur posts r the only ones keeping this forum alive so dont listen to those u put u down just coz u were brave enough to put ur views forth. I hope u dont let these people discourage u. They r not worth it.


Vini,
It's a matter of opinion. Different opinions are bound to arise when we watch an episode. This is the thing we all should understand, like you said.

BTW, I am leaving just now, for some place.
If possible for you, make update as you did yesterday.
I won't be able to see JA, today, at least.

Edited by history_geek - 8 years ago
Posted: 8 years ago
@Abhay :
           Everyone has the right to express their own views about the episode , n this is y we come to the forum or any social networking websites 😳 So we must care only for those who get it in positive way n not the other way around !!!


@ neesha : nice post 😊 ... Everyone has their own qualms on this track , n this is mainly bcz of the vague execution of the track which had so much scope to have presented well with strong Jalal& Jodha together But CVS , love to torture Jo n make her a weeping queen than MEH 😑

Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by Suganya.S


@Abhay :
           Everyone has the right to express their own views about the episode , n this is y we come to the forum or any social networking websites 😳 So we must care only for those who get it in positive way n not the other way around !!!


@ neesha : nice post 😊 ... Everyone has their own qualms on this track , n this is mainly bcz of the vague execution of the track which had so much scope to have presented well with strong Jalal& Jodha together But CVS , love to torture Jo n make her a weeping queen than MEH 😑


thanks .Exactly. THEY love to torture Jo and in turn torture us as we cant see Jo crying always...The irony of it is that even when Jalal hated Jo he publicly humiliated Jo and even now when he loves her, he never leaves a chance to publicly humiliate her ..and then says sorry ..
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by ayushimehra



Neesha Abhay, i think, Jodha was doing so, when all jewellery +wealth will finish, then she will say, More, or then Begums will put jewellery, or wealth, or when HB will give her some she will stop,;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;showing, Her love was not so small, as a daughter, as a Daughter -in Law, she only wants MUM, or Mother In Law, some, thing,  which will be more precious for her. Her realtionship, with HB too much big, but cause of respect she needs her, Nishani.

( as in Tradition, we store some things for our Elders, or relgious places )




Awesome thoughts, as usual Ayushi πŸ˜Š.
πŸ‘ πŸ‘ πŸ€—
It is precisely out of  this affection, love and respect she has for Hamida Begum that Jodha even overlooked the promise that she had made to the Sheshahah, against her own inner conscience. She put the exalted position of the mother above religious sentiments, above the aawam and took the decision to convert, knowing very well that she would upset Jalal.

 At that particular moment when Mariam Makani fell ill and refused food afterwards, Jodha felt that the purpose of the war, the promise she made to Jalal would be defeated, should something drastic happen to Hamida Begum. That decision would have been a tough one to make. I sometimes wonder what if Hamida Begum had died due to the 'bhook hartal' had Jodha not said 'yes' to her stubborn demands. How would Jalal have reacted?How would we as an audience have reacted?
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by Charu.S



Awesome thoughts, as usual Ayushi πŸ˜Š.
πŸ‘ πŸ‘ πŸ€—
It is precisely out of  this affection, love and respect she has for Hamida Begum that Jodha even overlooked the promise that she had made to the Sheshahah, against her own inner conscience. She put the exalted position of the mother above religious sentiments, above the aawam and took the decision to convert, knowing very well that she would upset Jalal.

 At that particular moment when Mariam Makani fell ill and refused food afterwards, Jodha felt that the purpose of the war, the promise she made to Jalal would be defeated, should something drastic happen to Hamida Begum. That decision would have been a tough one to make. I sometimes wonder what if Hamida Begum had died due to the 'bhook hartal' had Jodha not said 'yes' to her stubborn demands. How would Jalal have reacted?How would we as an audience have reacted?


Charu well said, Agree CV not showed jodha in MEH,  or not  strong, or she went against Jalal, because HB put circumstances in front of her typical, GB +Ruk how many time teased.

Realy sometime i feel, how much jodha suffered in 16 cen, things were not easy for her at that time, Jalal broadness +strongness, showed a path to jodha, but way she own have traveledπŸ‘

But if we see practically feamals have to taken desesion, sometime, acc to Time Demands.

If HB had died, then All will be again  criticise Jodha, then all says  Because HB is her Mother In law,so she is doing this.if her Own Mother this situation, she soon accepts, What she wants,;;;;;;;;;;;;;everyone forgets, Jodha once not talk with MV. that situation Jodha now forgave jalal but if HB dies, Jalal not forgive Jodha, if forgives takes a more time.

But Jodha create space so easily, or Jalal +point is he knows how to use that place. so couple, bonding becomes healthy soon.

or as a women its a True reality, realtionship blance with Inlaws not a easy Job. Or we can say everyrealtion is tough to blance.

Actually problem is writers also.





Edited by ayushimehra - 8 years ago

Related Topics

doc-text Topics pencil Author stackexchange Replies eye Views clock Last Post Reply
Jodha Akbar FF: Shahzada of Her Dreams Chapter 47 Updated 29/12/2023

pencil Swissgerman   stackexchange 1040   eye 275642

Swissgerman 1040 275642 1 months ago Ritshem
Jodha Akbar FF Who loves Him Most Chapter 78 updated on 26/10/2022

pencil Swissgerman   stackexchange 391   eye 65802

Swissgerman 391 65802 a day ago 23ashi
Watching jodha akbar again!

pencil sharmacatty   stackexchange 57   eye 3702

sharmacatty 57 3702 15 days ago ritujajadhav
HIRA AUR AKBAR KI PREM KAHANI

pencil msbhattacharya   stackexchange 183   eye 46830

msbhattacharya 183 46830 20 days ago Saiyaa

Topic Info

20 Participants 52 Replies 6004Views

Topic started by history_geek

Last replied by Charu.S

loader
loader
up-open TOP