Posted: 19 May 2015 at 6:35am | IP Logged
Originally posted by panchaali
Originally posted by Brishti_Sarkar
Originally posted by panchaali
After reading this post I am just thinking why I cared to read it
It again made me
people those who say Bhagat Singh and Khudiram Bose are terrorist open in a forum (debate forum)
they surely are not worthy of any debate...and does not match my taste at all...
You prove nothing except for the fact that you have no explanation...
And regarding debate forum. that and this has no match.. That may be wrong but here I am saying with citation and basically you have nothing to say so u cook up a reply "U are not worth debating with" ..
Those who say Bhagat Singh and Khudiram Bose were terrorist
they will surely think Karna was a Vibhishan
my taste and thought process will never match with people like these..
students of 10th and 12th also won't say such nonsense...
why would I waste my time and energy on them !!!!
they are not worthy of understanding any logic or explanation...
Still if you really want to know who was Vibhishan and who Karna was read Madhsudan Dutta's Meghnad Vadh Kavya and Rabindra Nath Tagore's Karna Kunit Sambad... [well these are included in Madhaymik and Higher Secondary Bengali syllabus. At least it were in my time; year 2002-2004] you can find these pieces across the web too...
I knew this was coming
You know what? I am that much educated. So yes, I have read both the pieces you informed me about. And I have studied in a school also. Bangali barite jonmechhi toh, tai Dadu thakuma etuku amake nijei porte sikhiyeche. Class 10 er jonno opekhha korte hoyni. although I had ICSE board.
By the way, these are works of fiction by poets. I think there is a book called Mahabharat, considering you have read it and you know much much more about it than I do or ever will be, I actually take that as the source when I talk about its characters and not Karna Kunti Sangbad or Meghnath VAdh Kavya. Maybe I am wrong. Just saying.
And I better not say anything about literature or Tagore or Madhusudan Dutta as then you people will misunderstand what I want to say and accuse me of Tagore bashing. Haha. Still since its my bad I cannot stay without replying to anything debatable (I consider you worth debating with).
Just few points.
a) A poem cannot be used to prove the point of view of the writer. I am not saying Tagore hated Karna but you can neither say he loved nor hated until you show me a serious article where he says so. I can say Sunil Gangopadhyay loves Karna as I have read his article where he clearly says Karna is my favourite character.
b) Even if Tagore, Bankim, Sharat Chandra LOVED Karna (which you cannot prove just like by picking up Tagore's Gandharir Abedon or Arjun Chitrangada I cannot say read that to know who Arjun was..read that to know ultimate about Dury or Gandhari.) I do not have to agree with Tagore or Madhusudan Dutta.
I am not that illiterate by the way. I have somehow managed to study and go deep into theories. Maybe I am not worth it. Surely I am not. But worth is seldom taken into account, Karna is the proof...