Originally posted by -Arsal-
Originally posted by hermione82
Honestly Piku nothing like FF at all
Its genuinely good movie with lot of heart
The actresses name you have mentioned have their own strength and weaknesses. It difficult to say who is better than whom in terms of acting specially when none of these women are jack of all trades(nobody really is except a few Meryl Streep or Sridevi here and there) ..
Also there's one movie which defines an actress like DP had cocktail, PC has Barfi, Kangana has Queen, Anu has NH10 and Vidya has multiple Kahani, Dirty picture, Isqiya.. Can you compare Barfi with Kahani or BBB or Piku? I cant...
For me Vidya is better actor than anyone else in the list but she is not a mainstream actress now.
Barfi is the most difficult character played by any female actor in recent time but PC is inconsistent for me. In mary com she was good in parts but sometimes she was PC not mary com.
Kangana emotes very well and does comedy and drama with elan. But she has the most pathetic dialog delivery of the lot.
Anu was too good in N10 and BBB. She is very natural in drama. But after watching Piku I would put DP and Anu in the same bracket at per terms of acting. Natural doesnt mean you have to be bubbly, if someone portrays a restrained character effortlessly that can be natural too and DP has done the same thing in Piku...
So over all for me, Vidya> DP, Anu>PC>Kangana
I am sorry but Deepika is nowhere near the ones I mentioned. Add Kareena to the list as well.Priyanka.
Barfi, Fashion, Aatiraaz, Mary Kom.Vidya.
Paa, Kahani, TDP, Ishqiya. Very good in SKSE too (the script sucked)Kareena.
Omkara, JWM, EMUET and Talaash.Kagana.
Fashion, Queen, Tanu Weds Manu, Woh Lamhe.
Name one performance of Deepika's that comes even close to the ones above?? Her best which is Karthik Calling Karthik fails spectacularly to match up to the performances other have pulled above. Even though I liked her in it, the only time in career I admit. She has no standout performance to match these above, same is the case with Anushka though, I will give you that.
Coming to Ansuhka. Yes she inst in the above leagues as well of now, but with PK, NH10 and BV( it is looking fantastic and Anushka is pawing Ranbir in the trailers) she might just end up there. Have you seen NH10; it was a thriller with elements of action involved and see pulled it off extremely well.
As for your ratings;
There is noway, no freaking way that DP is beating PC and Kagana when it comes to acting. Be it in any genre.
And actually Deepika is the one whose dialogue delivery is the worst. Kangana can get out of hands in some movies but she is bang on most of the times. See Fashion, Queen, TWM to get my point.
I am surprised that you added EMUET, Tanu Weds Manu and Woh Lamhe in the same list as others. Deepika's had cocktail where she stole the show from everyone and now i can proudly add piku to the list.