Balika Vadhu

India-Forums

   
Balika Vadhu
Balika Vadhu

this is not the first time for anandi (Page 6)

_Manahil_ Senior Member
_Manahil_
_Manahil_

Joined: 23 September 2014
Posts: 297

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 12:06pm | IP Logged
@stephi yes i can understand Hindi but still i have been mislead so many times on this forum 
I have not seen this serial from start I am regular viewer only after Sargun Mehta's entry so i have less knowledge about what happened before 

and i am being mislead here with posts like  Jagya got his hospital and property share because of Anandi Then i read other's arguing it was Dadisaa who showed  mirror to Bhairon and Sumi to accept jagya Your son has returned to you fully  It was Bhairon's suggestion to give him hospital 

when i read old WUs Anandi did nothing in this  Dadisaa showed mirror to Bhairon and Sumi and they went and accepted their son back 

Bhairon suggested to give Jagya hospital and Lal Singh agreed to it He is more capable doctor than him and will handle it better 

so when where Anandi did anything in this ? 

The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

Jaya-VDreamer_Stephitiny15

tiny15 IF-Stunnerz
tiny15
tiny15

Joined: 09 September 2007
Posts: 33368

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 12:10pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by Stephi

Originally posted by _Manahil_

I hope mods come back soon and take a serious note on these misleading posts Each time trying to mislead people i have not seen the episode and read posts here and was confused when watched the episode This Jagya agrees with Anandi's POV Anandi and Jagya are a team Dadisaa leader of this team hilarious 
Jagya said he wanted to tell Mannu about his past before too Jagya i suppose if people have watched serial was always in favor of Mannu knowing about this 5 years ago which FB was shown in that he was saying same thing when Anandi ji did not even thought to deliver these lectures in her  dreams but Jagya said Ganga is being adamant He said its better for Mannu Ganga herself tells him all this instead he comes to know from any other person 

He can tell himself but he did not do that from such a long time because Ganga is not agreeing He prefers ganga tells this and even right now he did not agree to send Mannu to Ratan or did he ? no Ganga's feelings are his priority and even his son's best interest  Jagya thinks Mannu has right to know about his past but only from his mother  Ganga is the best person to do this and its so clear had he met Ratan Singh himself he would have helped Ratan too but not given promise to him without Ganga's approval , her free will just like he did not tell Mannu from such a long time about his past 

and Jagya never said Anandi did absolutely right work to make a decision here and Ganga is wrong ?




I guess you understand Hindi, so you can  make your own conclusions based only on viewing the episode. I watch the episode, but I do not understand HindiLOLCry, so I  mainly depend on WU and IF. And again, I'm certainly not the only one with this problem. So when I watch the episode and then  read some  post ''closed-door meeting'', ''A &J are a  team, Dadisa's  leader of this team,what conclusion I can draw from it Confused
stephi u cud see in JaGan AT. there sumtimes  we give WU of the scene or discuss it.i"ll try 2 give WU of atleast BH.but it will b not regular till 22nd as my theres wedding of my bro so r busy & i won't b able 2 watch epis regularly.
btw u can also google search BV updates on telly updates site.they r updated till 10 PM.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Stephi

_Manahil_ Senior Member
_Manahil_
_Manahil_

Joined: 23 September 2014
Posts: 297

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 12:13pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by libsrocks

Originally posted by Shinya


Well, I dont think she made any mistake this time.

Imagine a man in his deathbed, crying before you with joined hands and requesting you to fulfull his last wish which was to meet his son.

Which woman with a heart would say "sorry, I cant fulfill your wish or Sorry I have to take his mother's permission "?

The only thought that would come to your mind at that moment was, okay, I promise I will help you. 

That scene was so emotional that Anandi had to promise him. It was not the time to think of anyone's 'adhikar'. If jagya was in her place, he too would have done the same.

Anandi could have argued with ganga in support of Ratan and say he also a right to see his son. But she apologised. 

I dont feel anandi made a mistake at all.

did you even notice whom have you compared: jagya and anandi
jagya happens to be mannu's legal father and anandi is mannu's relative (just by name, not even blood)!
jagya gets the right to make decisions and anandi doesn't.
so true Jagya is Mannu's father and Anandi is relative by name only .Anandi made a decision without asking parents at all not even Jagya then how she is right ? 
Jagya would have done same Not without taking Ganga for granted here He pretty clearly said today Mannu deserves to know about his past but from his mother Thats why he did not himself tell him from 5 years because Ganga is adamant no  Jagya would have tried to help Ratan too and wants but not without taking Ganga into confidence despite as a father he has all rights to decide about Mannu

and Anandi she did not ask from Jagya and Ganga  and made a decision  and she is defended as right here Wow


Edited by _Manahil_ - 04 May 2015 at 12:14pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Dreamer_Stephitiny15

anshurg5 IF-Sizzlerz
anshurg5
anshurg5

Joined: 26 October 2012
Posts: 13398

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 12:16pm | IP Logged

    Letting once meet a son from his dying father and giving that son permanently to him are too different things.  
   It is already said here almost by every one that giving promise regarding meeting with Mannu without consulting with his parents was wrong of Anandi. But she did the same which she had done herself in the similar circumstances. In this she has forgotten that everyone can not be Anandi , how much they might pretend about that. 

  Denying a dying father his last wish of meeting with his son was not only wrong but shows how selfish a woman can be. She had no qualm taking that 'rakshas ' help when she needed it but now when the same rakshas just wanst to once see his son , she can not oblige him. 

     Ratan Singh was still a rakshas when he made a legal deal with G in lieu of saving his own son. If he had not  his heart changed he could have legally keep Mannu with him then it would have Ganga who would have been begging from Ratan Singh to meet her son. But Ratan Singh understood wrongness of his path and surrendered his claims in favour of G and even did not choose to meet his son for a long time. Even now if he wanted, could not he come unannounced in BH and meet his son while G was away in the hospital or even if she was at home how she could have then prevented Ratan from calling Mannu? But he choose to only beg to get a chance to meet him .
    Is this not sufficient to tell G that he is not an rakshas any more? 
   
  Btw suppose if Anandi did not do anything to make her promise fulfill, Ratan singh dies without meeting Mannu , will J and G can live on peacefully after that?  And one day Mannu comes to know that his biological father who once saved his life, wanted to meet him before dying but his mother did not let him meet with his father then will he be able to forgive his mother for it? Will not a big storm uproot many lives in BH then?  
       Go Anandi go ! Do something now otherwise many ppl will repent and will not have a chance to correct themselves. 

The following 6 member(s) liked the above post:

jayashree.g_Jaya_rdjhaAakanksha_7RTeeaparnauma

Dreamer_ IF-Rockerz
Dreamer_
Dreamer_

Joined: 25 March 2011
Posts: 5524

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 12:35pm | IP Logged
Jagya agreed to Anandi's POVShockedmmm i did not see where he said Don't worry Anandi i will help Ratan Singh and i am just packing off Mannu to him LOL

All he said he agrees with this Mannu needs to know about his past  and i think he is not following Anandi's POV here This POV has been his always when Anandi did not even dreamt about it  and that he would helped Ratan Singh too its so obvious 

but he did not tell Mannu himself from such a long time because Ganga is not agreeing and he is not  taking Ganga for granted here He does not think he can  alone make decision himself here 

Even right now he did not send Mannu to Ratan Singh He can but he wants  Mannu to know about his past from  his mother and thumbs up to him for his wisdom 

Yes Ganga is ideally the best person to do so Him being step father if he will say that to Mannu it will hurt Mannu more Ganga  can make Mannu understand better but since Ganga is not agreeing so Jagya is not taking a one sided decision 


and i think after hearing from him Anandi ji went to convince Ganga ? No ? yes she did 

Jagya would have done same had he met Ratan ?

 Well Jagya has moral , ethical , legal rights to take decisions about Mannu yet he cleared he would not have done this without Ganga's agreement From past 5 years he did not tell Mannu about  this he could but he did not Ganga should agree and here too he would not have given any promise to  Ratan without taking Ganga into confidence because he could take Mannu to Ratan but he still said Mannu must know about this about this  from his mother

Jagya knows sensitivity of this matter and taking rightful steps He is too a very good human but he is concerned for everyone  but Anandi ji a third person without talking to Jagya and Ganga gave promise to Ratan ? Her humanity was over flowing from her that she did not bother to think about  Mannu's parents and gave promise to Ratan Singh and she was never sure she could fulfill that then why giving promises ?





Edited by kikyo - 04 May 2015 at 1:27pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Jaya-VStephitiny15

Stephi IF-Sizzlerz
Stephi
Stephi

Joined: 12 August 2012
Posts: 10977

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 12:40pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by tiny15

Originally posted by Stephi

Originally posted by _Manahil_

I hope mods come back soon and take a serious note on these misleading posts Each time trying to mislead people i have not seen the episode and read posts here and was confused when watched the episode This Jagya agrees with Anandi's POV Anandi and Jagya are a team Dadisaa leader of this team hilarious 
Jagya said he wanted to tell Mannu about his past before too Jagya i suppose if people have watched serial was always in favor of Mannu knowing about this 5 years ago which FB was shown in that he was saying same thing when Anandi ji did not even thought to deliver these lectures in her  dreams but Jagya said Ganga is being adamant He said its better for Mannu Ganga herself tells him all this instead he comes to know from any other person 

He can tell himself but he did not do that from such a long time because Ganga is not agreeing He prefers ganga tells this and even right now he did not agree to send Mannu to Ratan or did he ? no Ganga's feelings are his priority and even his son's best interest  Jagya thinks Mannu has right to know about his past but only from his mother  Ganga is the best person to do this and its so clear had he met Ratan Singh himself he would have helped Ratan too but not given promise to him without Ganga's approval , her free will just like he did not tell Mannu from such a long time about his past 

and Jagya never said Anandi did absolutely right work to make a decision here and Ganga is wrong ?




I guess you understand Hindi, so you can  make your own conclusions based only on viewing the episode. I watch the episode, but I do not understand HindiLOLCry, so I  mainly depend on WU and IF. And again, I'm certainly not the only one with this problem. So when I watch the episode and then  read some  post ''closed-door meeting'', ''A &J are a  team, Dadisa's  leader of this team,what conclusion I can draw from it Confused
stephi u cud see in JaGan AT. there sumtimes  we give WU of the scene or discuss it.i"ll try 2 give WU of atleast BH.but it will b not regular till 22nd as my theres wedding of my bro so r busy & i won't b able 2 watch epis regularly.
btw u can also google search BV updates on telly updates site.they r updated till 10 PM.


Thanks tiny Hug  I   will  do that .  I love kikyo and mahi12's  WUs very much but sometimes I have problem due to the time difference  and I'm eager to find out as soon as possible.LOL

All the best to your broStar

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

tiny15

Stephi IF-Sizzlerz
Stephi
Stephi

Joined: 12 August 2012
Posts: 10977

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 12:46pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by _Manahil_

@stephi yes i can understand Hindi but still i have been mislead so many times on this forum 
I have not seen this serial from start I am regular viewer only after Sargun Mehta's entry so i have less knowledge about what happened before 

and i am being mislead here with posts like  Jagya got his hospital and property share because of Anandi Then i read other's arguing it was Dadisaa who showed  mirror to Bhairon and Sumi to accept jagya Your son has returned to you fully  It was Bhairon's suggestion to give him hospital 

when i read old WUs Anandi did nothing in this  Dadisaa showed mirror to Bhairon and Sumi and they went and accepted their son back 

Bhairon suggested to give Jagya hospital and Lal Singh agreed to it He is more capable doctor than him and will handle it better 

so when where Anandi did anything in this ? 


So you  know  perfectly well what I'm talking about. .SmileD'oh

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

tiny15

mahi12 IF-Dazzler
mahi12
mahi12

Joined: 22 July 2011
Posts: 3349

Posted: 04 May 2015 at 2:46pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by Stephi


for you stephi
Anandi was telling  Jagya Dadisaa  when Ratan told her he honestly fulfilled the promise of staying away from Mannu then i realized he is speaking the truth From so many years he did not try to interfere in Mannus life and tried to know about him  That means he is fulfilling the promise of not interfering in Mannu's life but still Mannu is part of his life  His mother said he always talked about him Always remember him i have felt seeing him if he tries to repent for his ill deeds million times his soul will never be at peace in this birth

Jagya said after hearing this  if i think from Ratan's POV then what you are saying is right but Mannu ? We all know Mannu does not know about this truth at all and i don't know how Mannu will react to this when he will come to know about this truth i am trying to convince Ganga from many years that she herself  tells Mannu about this truth  Tell him about who is real father  , tell him about Ratan singh so that Mannu won't get shocked hearing from any other person but Ganga does not wish to She does not want Mannu to know anything about Ratan Singh 

Dadisaa tells them that now you both are thinking so much so think what step we have to take now Find such solution which is with agreement of all 


Edited by mahi12 - 04 May 2015 at 4:32pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

BeautifulSoul_Stephitiny15

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Nayi Anandi ki jagah pe purani Anandi?

Author: Teeya   Replies: 1   Views: 3993

Teeya 1 3993 14 May 2013 at 9:15pm by Sahan
ANANDI J. SINGH & ANANDI S. SHEKHAR

2

Author: libsrocks   Replies: 11   Views: 5290

libsrocks 11 5290 03 March 2013 at 2:58pm by Tenak
WU 5/11(Ruthi Anandi-CS in anandi manao abhiyan:D)

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Author: khusi_*   Replies: 69   Views: 23444

khusi_* 69 23444 06 November 2012 at 4:18am by gun_k
Ashima vs Anandi/ Gauri vs Anandi

2 3 4

Author: Tuttifrutti   Replies: 24   Views: 7631

Tuttifrutti 24 7631 16 August 2012 at 8:40pm by nitha
choti anandi aur badi anandi on sitaare zameen par

Author: alice1234   Replies: 0   Views: 2214

alice1234 0 2214 29 July 2012 at 9:10am by alice1234

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Balika Vadhu Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index