A protective mother - Page 4

Both the ladies were wrong...

Anandi had no right to promise Ratan without consulting Ganga-Jagya.If writers show that Anandi has no idea about Mannu not knowing his father then it will be a blunder.She saw Shiv's condition when he got to know the truth and if I am not wrong she was hiding it from him as she was not sure and also because she didn't want to hurt him.But then Shiv got the hint and she had to reveal.So same is Mannu's condition.Mannu is in an age where he is neither a baby nor an adult so its very risky yet she confidently promised and then casually said what one should do for a dying person.Is the whole thing so easy!You can do whatever u think is right but there is the risk of Mannu getting to know the truth.The dialogues were absurd and went over my head.

And then Ganga.She has turned into one complete different personality,anyways nothing new.She bashed Jagya for wanting to save Mannu from future heartbreaks.Though Ratan raped her,beat her,almost killed her and one should never forgive the rapist,murderer but before leap she already forgave him and said she will bring Mannu to meet him.But now all of a sudden she hates him!Says she will not think much about a dying person!Are u serious.She was all OK with them and now she says doesn't want to give into their behkawa!Ya,we understand people changes and turns into one different person like Sriti turned into Sargun and Sargun turned into Aasiya.

And the most awaited part of the century Anandi vs Ganga happens.Thanks cvs.

But then I am glad that the writers yet didn't choose a side.They showed both right and both wrong but the sad part is that Ganga not ready to fulfil the wish of the person who saved Mannu is not at all good.That is not what she used to be.

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

It is a dying man's wish. But this dying man did horrible things to his wife. Thats why I dont have sympathy for such people.

How come mannu did not see his birth certificate? How come no one in the village or mannu's friends raised this topic?

How come mannu did not compare his parents wedding day and his birth date and asked why he was born before their wedding?

Ratan's crime was equivalent to Basant's.

Originally posted by: leavesandwaves

Actually I do not want ratan's wish to be fulfilled. He was such a disgusting person who made ganga's life hell. Now he knows his son mannu has a good life. If he really loves his son, he will not want to upset mannu's life by past revelations.

Not all bad persons the same.

Here the question is not Ratan but how people are regarding Ratan.

Originally posted by: Sunna_Deewani

 

 

He is not a bad person now. Even if he was its not wrong if he wants to meet his son. Ganga was OK with that earlier. So why shouldn't he meet? Anyway truth can come out even later too. Why not now?


I suddenly remember Satyakam movie. Heroine gets raped by a bad guy. She escapes from there and marries Dharmendra's character. She has a kid as the result of that rape. Dharmendra and the bad guy both get admitted in the same hospital and both in death bed. The bad guy wants to meet his son as last wish. Heroine refuses. But there the boy is already informed that Dharmendra is not the real father.

 

 

Originally posted by: Aashima.

[

@bold but here Mannu has no such person to tell him about his parentage.

If suddenly someone from the villagers taunts him about not being BH's heir or Not being Jagya's Bio Son then it will be wierd as nobody complains till all these 11 years.

The only two scenarios to let Mannu know about his real father are ...Singhs still have the custody papers with them & Mannu discovers it. <<well he can also finds out divorce papers as well & connect the dots>> 

OR

He will overhear some convo between BH's members.

In any case...His mother has less chances to hide the truth from him for a long time. It will be better if she agrees to the last-meeting while putting a condition of Non-revelation of RS's identity to Mannu as he is dying anyways<<assuming that RS's last wish is only to meet Mannu in-person & not to hear "bapusa" for him from his side>>. This way She will have better chances to save the situation for herself & Mannu than refusing for meeting right away.(IMO)

Edited by Sunna_Deewani - 8 years ago

I think for once ganga ds should meet ratan to find out truth that whether ratan really change person or not , ds and ganga has not seen health condition of ratan that is why ganga ds does not belive ratan .if both ganga and ds have doubt on ratan then they can take police with them while going to meet r ratan


and whatever ratan do past bad deed for that he get double punishment by god as well as from court .

Originally posted by: Sunna_Deewani

 

Why hide his identity? Then no purpose for this track na. If truth is not revealed now then again bomb will be waiting to be blown again. But sometimes I think its possible that they hide it even now. Maybe future drama ke liye drag karden CVs!