Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon

India-Forums

   
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon

Expectations and Disappointments- By an IPKKND fan (Page 4)

tanthya IF-Addictz
tanthya
tanthya

Joined: 24 July 2009
Posts: 52575

Posted: 23 December 2011 at 5:02am | IP Logged
Originally posted by incandescent

Right from the very first promo, IPKKND promised to be an intense love-hate story with a mature and sensible handling. The leads were meant to be two strong-willed individuals with a very distinct view towards life. It was meant to be there journey of life and togetherness, where they cross several hurdles to find true love in each other.


The leads are still strong willed , Fari.. but  now  more layers have been added to the initial 2-3 traits ..It still is their journey  and they are traveling ..

Somewhere down the line, something went very wrong. The makers could not strike a balance between the love story, drama and comedy. It's like watching a different show every day. One day it is intense emotional roller coaster and the next day it is ludicrous comedy.

If we watch the show carefully ..it has always followed a pattern..   Humor leading to twist  leading to intense, emotional scenes  .. The CV's have consistently maintained this and I do appreciate them for this  cux I for one cannot watch the sustained MD , intense or comedy scenes ..but as U said .. They did veer off-course but they have begun to come on track  now ..so lets give them some time .


To give the audience a taste of all the flavors, it is necessary to have a blend of romance, drama, comedy. It's just like the perfect recipe. All the ingredients should in the right proportion. If one ingredient is added more than the right proportion, it overpowers all other flavors leaving an unwanted taste.

Agreed  and sometimes the CV's have got the proportion wrong but  they did correct it soon too


I am not complaining about the comedy. Neither do I want to watch high voltage drama or a sappy story. All the elements should be there but the transition from one to the other should be smooth. Lately it has become too bumpy and erratic.

it could be  bec we suddenly had to deal with 3-4 tracks instead of 1-2  ..and the since each track is at different level.. the emotions are not the same ..come to think of it..it would have looked ludicrous had the same emotion permeated all the tracks !!


And where has the intense love story between the leads disappeared? The drama is the there, the comedy is there but where is the chemistry between the lead characters? I do not expect unnecessary Rabba ve moments. But didn't the leads develop feelings for each other? I only know that. Why don't I see it?

 I am not blaming Sarun here. I am blaming the screenplay.


I would not be convinced if we get any love story now   as both of them have consciously decided to withdraw ..it will take time for the spark to ignite and CV's  IMO are already kindling the  tinder

The family drama is there, the plotting by the antagonist is there, the sensitive handling of a break-up is there but where is the love in this love story?

As for the characterizations, something went off here too.

When the show began to air, all of us fell in love with the rich, arrogant and brooding (anti) hero Arnav and the charming, vivacious and fun loving Khushi.

Arnav Singh Raizada is a loving, caring, and sensitive for his loved ones. Those are his qualities which are hidden to the world. For the world He is ASR. ASR is cold, calculative, arrogant snob for the world. Now those are his character flaws and part of the story is on how he redeems himself. Other than those non-desirable traits, ASR is a sharp, cautious, restrained man with a worldly knowledge. The basic theme of his redemption is that he should lose his arrogance and snobbishness but not his attitude.

ASR has mellowed down a little but not too much yet. I am not saying that his character has been played with. I am worried whether the makers mellow him down too much. Arnav traits should be brought forward but some of the ASR traits (the desirable ones) should be there. ASR should not lose his attitude.


Amen to that and also his intelligence should be maintained

I am complaining about Khushi a lot lately. Khushi is honest, vibrant, idealistic, sincere, caring, upholds values, and is full of life, fun loving and chirpy. Her child like innocence sets her apart. But what happened to her Lucknow tehzeeb? Khushi was not the one to be unnecessarily rude and scream and shout without provocation.

I genuinely love many of her antics. I loved it when she sneakily got that model to take the measurements, I loved it when she smartly recorded the dictation, I loved it when she poured mango juice on the shoes but later innocently admitted that she did it because she didn't find orange juice. I loved it when she cutely burped while her mouth was filled with samosas. I loved it when she added something in ASR's juice to remove the jadoo tona. I loved it when she pulled off a drama in that dhaba. I loved it when she danced on the bed with La.

But I dislike it when she when unnecessarily screams and shouts. I dislike when she is unnecessarily rude to a guest. When did she lose her decorum?

I am not asking her to lose her characteristics but I am only expecting her to maintain them. Is that too much to ask for?


When u hold a specimen under a microscope  { Many members have  said/complained that I do microscopic  reading rather  a polite way of saying I write extremely long Post Wink] .. U get a totally different structure  of the specimen.. Same thing is happening here.. Khushi is under the microscope now therefore her previous traits will be exaggerated, new traits will come into display ..

I am not giving up on the show. The show still has a lot of good things too keep me hooked. I just wish the makers would concentrate more on these details.

The forum is on fire since yesterday because a lot of people disliked the episode and  Khushi's antics.

I also made a post because I was very annoyed after watching the epi. It made no sense at all. 

Not just Khushi's antics, how come ASR doesn't know how to read Hindi?  Didn't he read that fake suicide note which was written in HIndi? 

Some of our forum members misunderstood it as bashing. I don't think it was bashing at all. I guess everyone was just angry because after tuesday's emotional episode,our expectations were raised and  yesterday's episode looked like nothing but a filler with meaningless comedy. it did nothing good for the show.


Ur last para has the answer  to most of the Question's..


Please leave your comments. 


 




Thank You  for giving me the link ...

 It was a pleasure to reply, Fari Smile

edit ;

I M in Arnav's phavrit Red Big smile


Edited by tanthya - 23 December 2011 at 5:18am

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

premparbatincandescent

incandescent IF-Sizzlerz
incandescent
incandescent

Joined: 10 September 2011
Posts: 19865

Posted: 23 December 2011 at 5:31am | IP Logged
Originally posted by tanthya

Originally posted by incandescent

Right from the very first promo, IPKKND promised to be an intense love-hate story with a mature and sensible handling. The leads were meant to be two strong-willed individuals with a very distinct view towards life. It was meant to be there journey of life and togetherness, where they cross several hurdles to find true love in each other.


The leads are still strong willed , Fari.. but  now  more layers have been added to the initial 2-3 traits ..It still is their journey  and they are traveling ..

Somewhere down the line, something went very wrong. The makers could not strike a balance between the love story, drama and comedy. It's like watching a different show every day. One day it is intense emotional roller coaster and the next day it is ludicrous comedy.

If we watch the show carefully ..it has always followed a pattern..   Humor leading to twist  leading to intense, emotional scenes  .. The CV's have consistently maintained this and I do appreciate them for this  cux I for one cannot watch the sustained MD , intense or comedy scenes ..but as U said .. They did veer off-course but they have begun to come on track  now ..so lets give them some time .


To give the audience a taste of all the flavors, it is necessary to have a blend of romance, drama, comedy. It's just like the perfect recipe. All the ingredients should in the right proportion. If one ingredient is added more than the right proportion, it overpowers all other flavors leaving an unwanted taste.

Agreed  and sometimes the CV's have got the proportion wrong but  they did correct it soon too


I am not complaining about the comedy. Neither do I want to watch high voltage drama or a sappy story. All the elements should be there but the transition from one to the other should be smooth. Lately it has become too bumpy and erratic.

it could be  bec we suddenly had to deal with 3-4 tracks instead of 1-2  ..and the since each track is at different level.. the emotions are not the same ..come to think of it..it would have looked ludicrous had the same emotion permeated all the tracks !!


And where has the intense love story between the leads disappeared? The drama is the there, the comedy is there but where is the chemistry between the lead characters? I do not expect unnecessary Rabba ve moments. But didn't the leads develop feelings for each other? I only know that. Why don't I see it?

 I am not blaming Sarun here. I am blaming the screenplay.


I would not be convinced if we get any love story now   as both of them have consciously decided to withdraw ..it will take time for the spark to ignite and CV's  IMO are already kindling the  tinder

The family drama is there, the plotting by the antagonist is there, the sensitive handling of a break-up is there but where is the love in this love story?

As for the characterizations, something went off here too.

When the show began to air, all of us fell in love with the rich, arrogant and brooding (anti) hero Arnav and the charming, vivacious and fun loving Khushi.

Arnav Singh Raizada is a loving, caring, and sensitive for his loved ones. Those are his qualities which are hidden to the world. For the world He is ASR. ASR is cold, calculative, arrogant snob for the world. Now those are his character flaws and part of the story is on how he redeems himself. Other than those non-desirable traits, ASR is a sharp, cautious, restrained man with a worldly knowledge. The basic theme of his redemption is that he should lose his arrogance and snobbishness but not his attitude.

ASR has mellowed down a little but not too much yet. I am not saying that his character has been played with. I am worried whether the makers mellow him down too much. Arnav traits should be brought forward but some of the ASR traits (the desirable ones) should be there. ASR should not lose his attitude.


Amen to that and also his intelligence should be maintained

I am complaining about Khushi a lot lately. Khushi is honest, vibrant, idealistic, sincere, caring, upholds values, and is full of life, fun loving and chirpy. Her child like innocence sets her apart. But what happened to her Lucknow tehzeeb? Khushi was not the one to be unnecessarily rude and scream and shout without provocation.

I genuinely love many of her antics. I loved it when she sneakily got that model to take the measurements, I loved it when she smartly recorded the dictation, I loved it when she poured mango juice on the shoes but later innocently admitted that she did it because she didn't find orange juice. I loved it when she cutely burped while her mouth was filled with samosas. I loved it when she added something in ASR's juice to remove the jadoo tona. I loved it when she pulled off a drama in that dhaba. I loved it when she danced on the bed with La.

But I dislike it when she when unnecessarily screams and shouts. I dislike when she is unnecessarily rude to a guest. When did she lose her decorum?

I am not asking her to lose her characteristics but I am only expecting her to maintain them. Is that too much to ask for?


When u hold a specimen under a microscope  { Many members have  said/complained that I do microscopic  reading rather  a polite way of saying I write extremely long Post Wink] .. U get a totally different structure  of the specimen.. Same thing is happening here.. Khushi is under the microscope now therefore her previous traits will be exaggerated, new traits will come into display ..

I am not giving up on the show. The show still has a lot of good things too keep me hooked. I just wish the makers would concentrate more on these details.

The forum is on fire since yesterday because a lot of people disliked the episode and  Khushi's antics.

I also made a post because I was very annoyed after watching the epi. It made no sense at all. 

Not just Khushi's antics, how come ASR doesn't know how to read Hindi?  Didn't he read that fake suicide note which was written in HIndi? 

Some of our forum members misunderstood it as bashing. I don't think it was bashing at all. I guess everyone was just angry because after tuesday's emotional episode,our expectations were raised and  yesterday's episode looked like nothing but a filler with meaningless comedy. it did nothing good for the show.


Ur last para has the answer  to most of the Question's..


Please leave your comments. 


 




Thank You  for giving me the link ...

 It was a pleasure to reply, Fari Smile

edit ;

I M in Arnav's phavrit Red Big smile

thanks so much Sathya. I appreciate your POV. Embarrassed

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

tanthya

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Expectations from tonit's epi

Author: soapoperafan   Replies: 8   Views: 1164

soapoperafan 8 1164 06 December 2011 at 12:12am by smitar
Expectations crashed...

2

Author: preetijaiswal19   Replies: 13   Views: 2289

preetijaiswal19 13 2289 15 November 2011 at 10:56am by SK_Love
expectations...

Author: -kri-   Replies: 9   Views: 1635

-kri- 9 1635 24 October 2011 at 12:27pm by -kri-
UNEXPECTED EXPECTATIONS

2

Author: sri7   Replies: 12   Views: 1964

sri7 12 1964 15 October 2011 at 2:36am by ..-IronyDied-..
Amazing episodes - Beyond our expectations

Author: reemg   Replies: 0   Views: 954

reemg 0 954 07 October 2011 at 1:42pm by reemg

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index