Posted: 17 September 2011 at 9:16am | IP Logged
Originally posted by MadameX
MJ, you're missing my point. Other female actresses act like other characters because that's their defined role. Suhana is a completely different character from all those other characters because of how the CVs have directed and characterized her as. If CVs wanted Suhana to be like ardarsh bahus with mahaan acting, even Ragini could essay that role but she doesn't choose to when signing on shows. She preferred roles with minimal rhona dhona and quite unlike other characters usually portrayed. Directors were also able to see Suhana in her during casting as well. But the thing is, what if there's another actress who can portray Suhana just as well if not better? We haven't given a chance to this unknown being if she exists and have already written her off as being impossible to do the role of Suhana. Of course this actress's portrayal of Suhana may be a bit different but what matters most is that the character can touch our hearts and convey the desired message clearly.
Look at Disha's situation. Disha 1 (aka Pooja) couldn't properly convey certain things really well that instantly should touch the viewers' hearts when it should have but Disha 2 did it instantly. The character Disha is the same but the actresses have changed. Directors saw Disha in first actress but when second actress came along as mere replacement, she was the better choice for audience. Because we saw two sides of the coin, we can judge better. But in Suhana/Ragini's situation, we haven't seen the other side of the coin so why pass on a judgement that only Ragini is capable of bringing out the character of Suhana really well? Maybe she is but how do we know without seeing it first?
* Muahhh * RU , Hai Kahi nazar naa lage !!!! I agree with 10000000000000 ...00 % . I bet If someone tries to find the actress , They will b able to fine ONE .
Now Now , It depends on so many factors . Like rest of the cast . Even If V don't change them then just adding the new actor . Each actor has their own flavor , New actor will bring new flavor . If U r going to look for OLD FLAVOR then U will only disappoint Ur self . As for Sheema Di's example , Remember not only Actor was different but whole cast , writers , directors Everything changed . So when Everything changed doesn't it mean it will have a new taste !!!!!
Since It is not about " Is It All Her Fault " Q . any more Ragini Fans r saying it's scripts Fault , Others r saying It everyone else fault including Ragini then This debate is not necessary .
Acting is not something U can learn . Either U have it or not . It has no language , region , or anything else for that matter . It is a Job like any other . I have seen people complain about their Job as they have to do sometimes this lousy jobs which they prefer not to . Other option for that is Get fired . But Ragini can not hide behind Lousy Scripts . Ragini is unhappy Leave but she has not right to give Off performance in the name of Writers . I m saying it is her fault but Giving OFF SCENES is her liability . Learn from it . When there is a serious scene going on , Fellow actor is saying her lines , & either during or end of the her lines Ragini gives happy Facial Expression is not something I can look past easily .
Besides It is not " THE RAGINI SHOW " This is Family show so is part of the TEAM , She represents the End Face of Product SUHANA . If she gives wrong kind of expressions , then it affects the Product . I get it there is script but Also in acting there is thing called Under acting . so she can certainly tone it down a notch . I m not talking about the scenes where she has lousy lines . Even when she has OK lines she gives weird Expressions !!!! That's it for me .
Ru , Plz keep writing like this ... I love ur sensible side , hope don't have to tell U about how much I like ur other side right !!