Posted: 17 May 2011 at 2:41pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by ankit_nyc
Originally posted by MrManagement
Originally posted by Mihirism
Obviously...DID 2 is way ahead of DID 1 in all ways
At the end, truth, team effort and humility always wins
This is a competition and one team had to win I don't know why your bring "truth" in all your posts.Your post make it seem that no one in DID 1 was truthful or had any humility. I think both teams were good and Josh deserved to win as much as Jalwa did. In the last six weeks Josh won 3 while jalwa only won twice if you included the finale. Josh might have won last week also becasue they were ahead by four points before the takkar. So also don't get how is DID2 ahead of DID in all ways
if the judges had not equaled the scores there is no way DID 2 could have won
I congratulate DID 2 for their victory, but there victory does not prove they are better than DID 1, if they would have won most of the weeks they I would admit they were the better team but as you can see that is not the case.
ummm how do you have Josh winning 3 weeks? So you're saying Zee execs who pump millions of dollars in these shows can't do their math correctly?
How could Josh have won last week? They lost? Going by your logic, Jalwa could have won the weeks they lost too? Jalwa beat Josh fair and square...
Why shouldn't the judges equalize the score? Jai broke a rule, one can't stop in the middle of the performance no matter what, that's a rule...why should Jai get consideration for that?
He broke a rule...
Jalwa is the better team in this competition as proven by the results...
If you don't think so, go set up another competition for them to compete in, but until then the facts are the one show that they competed head to head in, DID 2 outperformed DID 1...
No amount of excuse making will change that...
Truth, Humility, and most importantely Talent won in the long run...
Go Team Jalwa
Week 1: DID 1 won
Week 2: DID 2 won
Week 3: DID 1 won (not a tie if you go by the math)*
Week 4: DID 1 won again
Week 5: no where declared but up to the finale takkar Josh was leading by 4 points
Week 6: DID 2 won
*Josh should have won, manish did the math wrong. I think it has been
mentioned by some of the members before but if you add up the scores
josh should have won by one point. Here is my elementary style
Before Shiamak made the point change:
Score before the takkar: 121
plus puneet score of 18 (9 from both judges)
After Shiamak made the point change:
he gave puneet a 8 instead of a 9.
so subtract one point from 139-1= final score of 138
Before shiamak mad the point change
score before the takkar:122
plus mayuresh score of 16 (8 from both judges)
total score of 138
After shiamak made the point change
gave mayuresh 9 instead of 8 so add one point to the total socre
138+1= 139 for the final score.
Therefore, JOSH got 139 points and Jalwa got 138 so how is that a TIE?
Unless I am missing something josh is leading
I am not making excuse i am just stating the facts. Even if you don't include week 3 and considered it as a tie, that means that by the end of 6 weeks both Josh and Jalwa score was at Tie two wins each, but if you do include week 3 then josh won the most of the times that they completed with Jalwa.
Edited by MrManagement - 17 May 2011 at 2:43pm