Chaand Chupa Badal Mein

Is it Responsibility issue or Obssessiveness - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

3763

Users

24

Likes

164

Frequent Posters

UZIS thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago

i think nivi is blaming herself too much for dd's death n just to overcome that guilt feeling she is subconsciously giving too much attention to baby.yeah she has becom too obsessive with the child.

she is also subconsciously trying to prove to the world that her love for the child is no different frm her real mother's.this is well illustrated by the scene in which nivi was talking to child.
 
Raj, i tried myself not to include too many psychological terms (yeah subconsciousness is a psychological term). But Freud's theory does explain her state of mind really well.
samin6 thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 4 Thumbnail Commentator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
The first few weeks of a baby at home for any child is hectic for mother. I think Raj you do not have a new baby at house. For the first few weeks to months you have to be really cruel to expect the mother do anything for you. May be they show this not in TV but a baby needs constant attention, takes ages to sleep and once asleep gets awake easily. Being a mother is not a piece of cake and all mothers will agree that for the first few months they were not even able to sleep because you have to be careful for each and every breath the baby is havinng because the baby cannot move their head when they have breathing difficulty. Try that for one night with any one around you for 24 hours. It is not obsession, it is what each and every mother including your have done for ages.  On top you want them to make tea for you. You have to be joking.
 On HLs version of the baby not getting breast milk, I would want to tell her there is more to being a mother then breast feeding.
NiViren-Raj thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by: Niv-RenBOND

i think nivi is blaming herself too much for dd's death n just to overcome that guilt feeling she is subconsciously giving too much attention to baby.yeah she has becom too obsessive with the child.

she is also subconsciously trying to prove to the world that her love for the child is no different frm her real mother's.this is well illustrated by the scene in which nivi was talking to child.
 
Raj, i tried myself not to include too many psychological terms (yeah subconsciousness is a psychological term). But Freud's theory does explain her state of mind really well.



Km .. u studying psychology would understand what Nivi is going through... this would not have happened if DD's death was natural and Nivi would not have anything to do with it...
UZIS thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by: Raj_Luv_NiViren



Km .. u studying psychology would understand what Nivi is going through... this would not have happened if DD's death was natural and Nivi would not have anything to do with it...

yeah i do
i found ,what they show today particularly b/w nivi n baby, quite realistic.
 
as far as viren's insecurity (or may be jealousy for not getting enough attention) is concerned, i do find it realistic to an extent (please dont tak it otherwise.i knw it hurts when it comes to our viren but u cant deny the realistic n bitter aspects of life)
 
see viren was being shown jealous to sid (reasons were valid for him for being so n really strong to mak him lik that).n i fully blame the family for making him so in his childhood.but this jealousy n insecurity may com again n in different forms.its really difficult to overcome such negative feelings.such feelings may subside for the time being n as long as circumstances r favourable but they may erupt again n again if circumstances go against his/her favour.
dyhardfan thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
Well said Raj di... Hope this bring NivRen closer and they come out stronger from this.
anjubala thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Raj, a very nice post and lot to discuss. I wanted to take a break but your post kind of forced me to write. :)
To me what Nivi is doing is what any new mom will do. Yes, she is not a biological mom but the circumstances have made her a mom. This happens to moms who adopt baby too... A baby and specifically new born baby needs constant support and attention. For a new mom it is mix of responsibility and obsession - to make sure that each and every little demand of her baby is getting fulfilled as baby has no other way to tell his or her needs. We all moms go through the same. The thin line between responsibility and obsession gets merged and it becomes difficult to differentiate between the two. And as this experience is new so it takes more effort from mom's side to understand what each and every cry of baby means. So to expect so much from her is not nice but it is a fact that regardless of a female is a new mom or not, world and husband expects her to be the same as she was before the baby. It takes few months to adjust to the new schedule, new life, new environment and that is why in my Friday's post I said the same. Viren will have to be little more patient with Nivi and help her and support her with the changed role. He is not the dad but Nivi is trying to be mom.. That is the difference. Once Nivi understands how to handle little baby and she gets used to her timings of feeding, changing her, bath time, sleep time..things will come back to routine. That is how GOD has made females. It is just this initial phase of adjustment wherein Viren will have to be with her instead of giving up on Nivi.
And for Nivi I will say once more that she needs to take help from family members in raising Dweeta. Alone she cannot do it. It should be a team work. Even if Divya was alive, she would have needed help from Sid, VD, YD etc... And there is more than mom's milk to bring up a baby. And HL needs to understand that. Love and care is also important for proper growth of baby.
NiViren-Raj thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by: Niv-RenBOND

yeah i do
i found ,what they show today particularly b/w nivi n baby, quite realistic.
 
as far as viren's insecurity (or may be jealousy for not getting enough attention) is concerned, i do find it realistic to an extent (please dont tak it otherwise.i knw it hurts when it comes to our viren but u cant deny the realistic n bitter aspects of life)
 
see viren was being shown jealous to sid (reasons were valid for him for being so n really strong to mak him lik that).n i fully blame the family for making him so in his childhood.but this jealousy n insecurity may com again n in different forms.its really difficult to overcome such negative feelings.such feelings may subside for the time being n as long as circumstances r favourable but they may erupt again n again if circumstances go against his/her favour.



yes KM... i really dont want Viren to go into it again...his insecurity i can understand...but dont him to go into negativity again...this time want nivi to realize...
anjubala thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by: Niv-RenBOND

yeah i do
i found ,what they show today particularly b/w nivi n baby, quite realistic.
 
as far as viren's insecurity (or may be jealousy for not getting enough attention) is concerned, i do find it realistic to an extent (please dont tak it otherwise.i knw it hurts when it comes to our viren but u cant deny the realistic n bitter aspects of life)
 
see viren was being shown jealous to sid (reasons were valid for him for being so n really strong to mak him lik that).n i fully blame the family for making him so in his childhood.but this jealousy n insecurity may com again n in different forms.its really difficult to overcome such negative feelings.such feelings may subside for the time being n as long as circumstances r favourable but they may erupt again n again if circumstances go against his/her favour.

 
Very well said and it is very true in case of Viren. His insecurities have never been handled properly and he has never got any closure.. This is bound to happen.
NiViren-Raj thumbnail
Anniversary 13 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by: anjubala

Raj, a very nice post and lot to discuss. I wanted to take a break but your post kind of forced me to write. :)

To me what Nivi is doing is what any new mom will do. Yes, she is not a biological mom but the circumstances have made her a mom. This happens to moms who adopt baby too... A baby and specifically new born baby needs constant support and attention. For a new mom it is mix of responsibility and obsession - to make sure that each and every little demand of her baby is getting fulfilled as baby has no other way to tell his or her needs. We all moms go through the same. The thin line between responsibility and obsession gets merged and it becomes difficult to differentiate between the two. And as this experience is new so it takes more effort from mom's side to understand what each and every cry of baby means. So to expect so much from her is not nice but it is a fact that regardless of a female is a new mom or not, world and husband expects her to be the same as she was before the baby. It takes few months to adjust to the new schedule, new life, new environment and that is why in my Friday's post I said the same. Viren will have to be little more patient with Nivi and help her and support her with the changed role. He is not the dad but Nivi is trying to be mom.. That is the difference. Once Nivi understands how to handle little baby and she gets used to her timings of feeding, changing her, bath time, sleep time..things will come back to routine. That is how GOD has made females. It is just this initial phase of adjustment wherein Viren will have to be with her instead of giving up on Nivi.
And for Nivi I will say once more that she needs to take help from family members in raising Dweeta. Alone she cannot do it. It should be a team work. Even if Divya was alive, she would have needed help from Sid, VD, YD etc... And there is more than mom's milk to bring up a baby. And HL needs to understand that. Love and care is also important for proper growth of baby.



Anju .. i agree with what u said...but here i felt little more obsession or say more involvement than normal with the baby cause Nivi also has the guilt part involved which show in her talk to the baby...when Sid took the baby Nivi's look and Viren had to tell her that Sid is the father...Viren talking to Nivi but Nivi's eyes were on Dwita...the precap she tell Viren he must have done something to the baby, why would Viren do anything to make Dwita cry...i can undersatnd insecurity on Viren's part but do not want CT's to exaggerate this as am tired of always CT's targeting Viren...Nivi is a new mom but her involvement also has added  guilt and repentance subconciously...
Edited by Raj_Luv_NiViren - 12 years ago
anjubala thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
Originally posted by: Raj_Luv_NiViren



Anju .. i agree with what u said...but here i felt little more obsession or say more involvement than normal with the baby cause Nivi also has the guilt part involved which show in her talk to the baby...when Sid took the baby Nivi's look and iren had to tell her that Sid is the father...Viren talking to Nivi but Nivi's eyes were on Dwita...the precap she tell Viren he must have done something to the baby, why would Viren do anything to make Dwita cry...i can undersatnd insecurity on Viren's part but do not want CT's to exaggerate this as am tired of always CT's targeting Viren...Nivi is a new mom but her involvement also has added  guilt and repentance subconciously...

 
Yes Raj that is why I am saying it will take more on Viren's side to take Nivi out of this involvement due to guilt, repentance, love for a motherless child etc.. Nivi is not seeing this wrong as she is the one giving all love to Dweeta as she herelf is a motherless child. So it is a mix of all. If Viren becomes insecure and comes in CC's talks then it will just complicate matters. will not resolve the issue, will rather increase the problem. Nahin to sabke expectations pura karte karte Nivi paagal ho jayegi.. She needs a break from this..