Anyways, I'm just going to post my views here.
To put it in simple English, I thought Jai made a mistake by saying that and interrupting the performance. But he felt sincerely sorry for it. So forgive the guy.
About the whole Atul crying thing, it is upsetting to hear. However, if you always expect your teacher to be perfect, an event like this causes you to know that not everyone is perfect. Don't call Jai a bad influence for that, though. Atul seems sensitive, and so he cried upon seeing Jai do this. If I was him, then I wouldn't have cried at all. But that's me, and everyone's personality varies.
Coming to Geeta. She was right about the whole disrespect thing, but she went a little overboard with it. She continued to yell at him after he began to cry. Remo and Shimak stayed with their comments and did not say more after that.
However, I don't agree with the conclusion at all. They should not have equalized the score. I am a Jalwa fan more than a Josh, but I thought that Alisha was definitely better than Vandana today, and I am a HUGE Vandana fan. It wasn't fair for Alisha's efforts to all go in drain. This didn't really help Jai, but ruined Josh's efforts for this week.
Now to Amar. Don't get me wrong, I absolutely LOVE Amar, ever since Season 2. But he did do steps and random things during Jai's solo. I'm not sure if that was part of the choreography or intentional. Keep this in mind, in the limelight, other contestants said that Amar was getting into Jai's performance, Jai nor Amar themselves said this, I think (my memory is bad 😆.) I liked the fact that Amar attempted to console Jai while he was crying.
Amrita and Kruti- I love both of them, but their comments/reactions to the interruption were unnecessary. Amrita's comments were not needed and just made the atmosphere even worse. I was disappointed in that.
Punit and Parvez- for all who say the limelight, I loved what both said. Punit didn't talk about Amar and Jai, he talked about the judges, although he was indirectly talking about Jai. But Parvez said the correct thing: forget about it.
I'm going with Parvez's words, just leave the issue right here and don't make it more than it actually is.
Edited by dmgmjht4ever - 12 years ago
comment:
p_commentcount