Posted: 14 May 2011 at 8:31pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by chocolover89
So I actually saw the episode and the limelight. The limelight gives more of a perspective from Jai's POV which makes things a little less biased.
First thing: Jai was wrong. After the performance, he should not have spoken to Shiamak like that--that was very wrong on his part. Sadly Jai has major communication problems..like Geeta said for Siddesh, jab bolte ho to khata bolte ho and people misunderstand. Jai has the same issue basically. Like he said in the limelight--I don't have attitude or arrogance, I just don't know how to talk. I sincerely hope Jai will work on this unappealing quality of his because he has the talent without a doubt. It's a dog eat dog world out there and the ability to communicate well and politely takes you very far. He has never been reprimanded this badly before so something tells me he will work at this.
It takes a lot of guts to apologize after making a huge mistake. He clearly felt very bad because he had let down himself, the judges, his team, and the audience.
But at the same time, I really don't think he was the only person wrong today--yea he was the most wrong probably but not the only one.
Geeta should have been a little more compassionate about the song problem. I can say 100% without a doubt if it was Siddesh or anybody from her gang instead of Jai, she would have been nicer about the song problem. Didn't she tell Max and Manik in Doubles to stop dancing and tell them immediately that the song was wrong ? Shiamak and Remo handled it better and also, I think really made Jai feel wrong--more than Geeta managed to.
Amrita and Kruti need to control as well. They looked ready to attack someone.
Siddhesh...right first time and don't know what he was talking about the second time at all.
Btw, now that I finally saw it, I don't think Atul was traumatized or anything. He simply felt bad for his dance teacher who was crying on stage and getting yelled at.
I also really liked how Amar and Parvez and Manish consoled Jai and made the atmosphere better.
All said and done..it's over. It shouldn't have happened. In Parvez's and Remo's words, forget about it and move on.
@Bold Word. Geeta overreacted soo much! She should have been calm and composed like Remo and Shiamak were. There was no need for soo much overacting. Other judges gave their opinion as well, but none of them were screaming like her.Also, I was sooo surprised to see Kruti and Amrita jumping and screaming like that.