Posted: 13 May 2011 at 2:22pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by Tannistha
hey bindu, cool to see u r online too.
yes it was a relief not to see same ol girl boy duo and finally something we longed to see
Jalwa act me too felt remo went emotionally overboard( though i am happy they got that marks). You know when its live and u give ur judgement then and there, one judges process of thinking influences the other, like induction effect, plus geeta was here, and she was pro season2 right from beginning. btw josh got 21 in the round not 27, jalwa lead by 9 marks
regarding the duos, hm , all the judges have something special for avneet, she often scores more than she deserves coz of that, call that pretty face effect, there isnt much we can do about it, maybe if we were on judges seat we would have done the same, i need to rewatch the epi, i think they both got same marks. i was quite satisfied with both the female duos, although i wished vrushali and avneet did a classical combo, or semi classical maybe
TBH, except for a few wow moments, Jai and atul didnt do anything special, two very special moments were the leap at the beginning and the leap of faith later, jay messed up a bit with the props and i need to rewatch these scores too, coz i think they got 26,9,9,8 break up.
and tell me about the takkar, seriously, guys stop trting this kid like he is God's gift, he is not, he has much to learn and u r only impeding his willingness to learn and his perception of truth, both were quite average today, neither pervez deserved 28 no prince deserved 31, and 11 out of 10, rilli, geeta!!!
i guess we have to be happy that overall the performances were amazing and just forget the scoring
btw: highlight today; geeta Ma's act
and binding attraction of the show: Manish Paul's one liners
Yep you are right. For the group act Josh got 21. That was my bad. Typo See my problem is we are comparing duos here. Then, the scores should reflect the comparison right?? Which is why I was upset with the way they scored Ammu-Vaishu less than Vrushali-Avneet. Well, they were pretty good too. Ammu-Vaishu should have got atleast same scores but they ended up with 9,9 and 9. Vrushali-Avneet got 10,10 and 9. Just not fair ya for me. With Jai and Atul, they got 8s across the board. Although it wasnt their best, I dint think it was an 8 performance. But may be it was just me here. It was one after the other that pissed me off with the way they scored today. But I guess there was no consistency in fair scoring happening in DKS so far. Most of us couldn't agree with the way they were giving scores. So like you said enjoy the performances and ignore their marks And Prince and Pravez, I am getting furious with that whole thing. So, I better let that go
Master Geeta, although isn't a great judge, she is a wonderful dancer. She has an unbelievable grace in her dance and she dances amazingly. I have always said that from DID-1. It doesn't take much to recognize a brilliant dancer, which she is. I have always loved her performances. That I will not take away from her. She is a great dancer. PERIOD!
Manish was at his best. I just love love that guy. What an asset to DKD he is
Edited by luv2dance - 13 May 2011 at 2:50pm