Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai

India-Forums

   
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai

Did it or did it not make the cut? (Page 2)

Madhavi_Di Goldie
Madhavi_Di
Madhavi_Di

Joined: 19 January 2010
Posts: 1547

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:17pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by FLGators

Originally posted by madhaviben

Originally posted by FLGators

Originally posted by madhaviben

Sari  liked  every  thing  you  said  and  the  last  line  MC  is  sensitive subject  but  i  always  like  all  your  post  while  you  make  it  so lighter  that  any one  will  take  it  positive  as  person  like  me  . i  will  comment  on  this  too  .  rec

Thanks MB... dar lagtha hai commenting on such a sensitive issue; don't know who is reading & how people perceive it. Bus kisiko bura na lage...Smile

Sarita  i  like  the  part  too  that  it  was  not  dramatic  like  other  show. and  best  was  karan  and  hina  both  did  the  justic  to  the  episode.i  realy  want  to  see  that  they  show  the  impcat  on  naksh  after  the  MC  rathere  them  showing  ronadhona  of  rajashri  and  g3Dead.  the  felling  of  naksh  will be  so  imp  at  this  stage  and  i  want  to  see  every  aspect  that  then  went  and  how  they  will come  out  of  that  and  become  strong  to  take  any  step  to  come  forword  and  try  to  erase  the  past . it is  not  easy  while  akashar  dont  work  . some  time it  help  if  you  go  out  of  your  shell  and  do  some  other  thing  will  make  you  stornger  and  you  want  feel  that  pain  that  much. pain  will  be  there  it  remain   until  she  will  have  onther  littel  angel  in  her  hand. but  atlest  they  have  to  become  stronger  and  move  forverd  in  life. i  would  love  to  see  how  they  show  all  this . by  the  way  thanks  for  the  reserch on  the  MC. LOL

Google has become my life, sach mein bhagwan ko bhi itna yaad nahi karthi jitna google ko...LOL Absolute life saver, seriously!

Dramatic tho kal hoga, mirch masala ke saathLOL Probably we will see a new high point when it comes to rona dhona. Abhi tak they have not shown death in YR, this is the first. Tho be braveSmile Rajsri probably won't come until thur but G3 aur BM pakayenge kal. BM ko acting bhi nahi aathi...LOL G3 hopefully will be more concerned about bahu than Munna. Although Munna needs her bahu needs her support more.

yes  now  bahu  need  her  . birthday  per  jo  besan  ki  chikki  khayi  thi  voh  yad  karke  G3  will  help bahuLOL. bahu  ne  jo  maka  jaap  kiya  hai  uska  phal  mangne  ka  vakte  aagaya  hai.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

_vinita_

pvlaks IF-Sizzlerz
pvlaks
pvlaks

Joined: 10 December 2010
Posts: 11467

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:19pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by FLGators

Much was made of the MC track. Now that I saw it, I am forced to believe it. Tried & Tested method adopted by CV's rather than follow their creative minds...Sleepy Of course out of the box idea thaConfused Had me googling for most of the afternoon...ROFL Ab MC ka koyi bhi question pucho, jawab hai mere paas...LOL

If I do not dwell on the technicalities, separate the absurdities, watch it as solely a fictional drama the episode was tastefully done. This was how I watched the locker room track & this is how I am viewing this current track. High points included -
  • Miscarriage wasn't sensationalized; no vamp to push Akshara down the stairs or accidental fall like someone pointed out. Indeed hatke but the concept of MC wasn't hatke. Kudos to Dimri & co for what it's worthClap
  • The actors did a wonderful jobClap Both Karan & Hina had the right emotions. He was completely broken but yet restrained on the forefront & she had the perfect emotions for a new concerned mom; the right amount of anxiety and innocence. Bholapan is Akshara's forte & she sounded so naive, totally clueless of the happenings. Very well portrayed by both, the two have really graduated to a new level although not enough to open an acting  school...ROFL

Now coming to the technicalities; Like in the locker room case, missed/silent miscarriage is quite rare(1%of 25%), probably even rarer in younger women like Akshi. I am convinced of this after pouring through dozens of articles, haven't researched as much for my thesisLOL Bahut faaltu time tha aaj, put to good use...ROFL I am going to accept that Akshara falls in the 1% category just like I bought the locker room theory.


Moving on; what was the purpose of hiding it from Akshara? Naithik as a  husband was thinking of the emotional aspect, rightfully soClap Lekin Dr ne usse aise kaise jaane diya is the million dollar question only Dimri can answer...Confused Why would you want to wait for nature to take it's course since the baby's fate is already sealed? Isn't it the Dr's job to perform the D&C & then maybe counsel the patient if need be? Shouldn't preventive care be the mantra to prevent any infection that could hurt future possibilities? Agar balgopal ne chaaha tho Akshara bahut jald mama banegi aur Naitik papa & we will all be there to witness the momentous
occasion...
Day Dreaming


Wow, 2 rare occurrences in 2 weeks? Not impossible, happens. Like the man who  was
struck by lightning 4 times & survived(http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/08/15/earlyshow/living/main778521.shtml ). This too I am sure is possible but only the ardent followers of YR will buy this theory for long & the ones like me who watch more for the friends on this forum...Hug ...the ones in it for the long haul...Smile

PS: I understand MC is a sensitive subject for a lot of us; if any of this is OT, forgive me. It wasn't intentional, JMO. Take it with a grain of salt...LOL

Sarita  Clap  i  loved  ur comments   always...but  i  cant express  like this  so  beautifully  as u r  doing..i  agreed  with  u ...Dr  cant  discharge  akshi  so  soon  with  out  doing  D&C whatever  it is ...akshi  itni  bhuddu  bhi  tho  nahi  hai  na...usko  pata nahi  chala...see  meri  choti  behen  ki  bhi  mc  ha  gayi  thi  60days  mein  hi...lekin  usko  pata chala  tha..wash room  hoke  ane ke  baad  usne  kaha  ki  kuch  tho nikal  gaya...tho  definitely  akshi  ko  bhi  pata  chalna  chahiye  na...only  cvs  can  answer   u  r  right LOL

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

--Sari--

--Sari-- IF-Rockerz
--Sari--
--Sari--

Joined: 19 December 2005
Posts: 7611

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:21pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by madhaviben


yes  now  bahu  need  her  . birthday  per  jo  besan  ki  chikki  khayi  thi  voh  yad  karke  G3  will  help bahuLOL. bahu  ne  jo  maka  jaap  kiya  hai  uska  phal  mangne  ka  vakte  aagaya  hai.

hope so too...misunderstandings na ho, bus. The whole thing about Akshara not knowing is to create dramaOuch Pata nahi ab kitne din rona dekhna padegaCry They don't have anything happening at the Maheswari's other than some gossiping women who can't mind their business... Rashmi track is going nowhere. Rona dhona sab kuch hai lagtha hai...Ouch

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Madhavi_Di

Madhavi_Di Goldie
Madhavi_Di
Madhavi_Di

Joined: 19 January 2010
Posts: 1547

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:38pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by FLGators

Originally posted by madhaviben


yes  now  bahu  need  her  . birthday  per  jo  besan  ki  chikki  khayi  thi  voh  yad  karke  G3  will  help bahuLOL. bahu  ne  jo  maka  jaap  kiya  hai  uska  phal  mangne  ka  vakte  aagaya  hai.

hope so too...misunderstandings na ho, bus. The whole thing about Akshara not knowing is to create dramaOuch Pata nahi ab kitne din rona dekhna padegaCry They don't have anything happening at the Maheswari's other than some gossiping women who can't mind their business... Rashmi track is going nowhere. Rona dhona sab kuch hai lagtha hai...Ouch

tum  rona  dhona  ki  baat  karrahi  ho  i  was  thinking  that  now  Rashmi  ki  shadi  mai  maa  akshara  se  gulabo  giri  na  karvane  lage  that  she  is  now  preg  anymore  fir  aaram  karne  ki  kya  jarurat  hai?  dont  want  to  think  about  maheshwari  and  specialy  rajashri  Angry jis  din  usko  pata  chalega  god  save  us  the  mostSleepy she  will  cry  like  Cryand  when  akshi  was  in  lokar  room  that  time  mari  baachi Cry. now  she  even  cry  more  and  i  cant  take  it. i  still want  CV  to  show  naksh  imotion  and  not  rajashris  and  crying  . i  dont  want  her  to  take  akshi  to  maheshwari house  atall. i  want  naksh  togather  and  they  might  have  to  send  them  on  vacation  to  have  some  time  togather and  away  form  the  crying. hope  CV  cover  all that.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

_vinita_

saru.g IF-Sizzlerz
saru.g
saru.g

Joined: 07 April 2010
Posts: 11171

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:43pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by madhaviben

Originally posted by FLGators

Originally posted by madhaviben


yes  now  bahu  need  her  . birthday  per  jo  besan  ki  chikki  khayi  thi  voh  yad  karke  G3  will  help bahuLOL. bahu  ne  jo  maka  jaap  kiya  hai  uska  phal  mangne  ka  vakte  aagaya  hai.

hope so too...misunderstandings na ho, bus. The whole thing about Akshara not knowing is to create dramaOuch Pata nahi ab kitne din rona dekhna padegaCry They don't have anything happening at the Maheswari's other than some gossiping women who can't mind their business... Rashmi track is going nowhere. Rona dhona sab kuch hai lagtha hai...Ouch

tum  rona  dhona  ki  baat  karrahi  ho  i  was  thinking  that  now  Rashmi  ki  shadi  mai  maa  akshara  se  gulabo  giri  na  karvane  lage  that  she  is  now  preg  anymore  fir  aaram  karne  ki  kya  jarurat  hai?  dont  want  to  think  about  maheshwari  and  specialy  rajashri  Angry jis  din  usko  pata  chalega  god  save  us  the  mostSleepy she  will  cry  like  Cryand  when  akshi  was  in  lokar  room  that  time  mari  baachi Cry. now  she  even  cry  more  and  i  cant  take  it. i  still want  CV  to  show  naksh  imotion  and  not  rajashris  and  crying  . i  dont  want  her  to  take  akshi  to  maheshwari house  atall. i  want  naksh  togather  and  they  might  have  to  send  them  on  vacation  to  have  some  time  togather and  away  form  the  crying. hope  CV  cover  all that.

haa this time I dont want rajshri to take her to maheswaries... again there also rona dhona starts... it better naksh stays in singhanias... It will be even more good, if dj n rb tells naitik to take her some good place to feel her better... cv's atleast take them somewhere this time... after that they can show rashmi's marriage...

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

anamika00Madhavi_Di

Tafseer IF-Sizzlerz
Tafseer
Tafseer

Joined: 19 March 2009
Posts: 24510

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:49pm | IP Logged
Thanku sari for the wonderful post...Big smile yaar yeh forum humein har cheez ki knowledge deti hai...isiliye isse door jaane mein bohot dukh hota hai...LOL LOL
and i know YR hai isliye ismein kuch alag hi dikhayenge...i never wanted a MC which is very common in K-serials...dhakka maarna, papita ka juice peela dena, etc etc etc...
Dimri ne bohot dhund ke nikaala hai yeh reason...which is rare but not an impossible situation...i can relate to this coz same thing happened mere ghar par bhi...Ouch Ouch pata hi nahi chala ki she miscarried the child... medicines dekar foetus nikaala gaya...Ouch this is the reason YR mere dil ke aur bhi kareeb hota jaata hai...can't relate to it so much...
n now i don't think Singhanias will blame Akshara for the MC...coz yeh dikhana bohot hi pagalpan hoga...Confused these articles are so misleading...abse i will only read it n won't believe it...i can't say ki i wont read those articles coz YR se realted kuch bhi news padhna hi hai...LOL
ab toh bas dekhna hai how the family handles this...esp Naksh...
promo mein Akshara just couldn't believe it yaar...Ouch

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

anamika00Madhavi_Di_vinita_--Sari--saru.g

Tafseer IF-Sizzlerz
Tafseer
Tafseer

Joined: 19 March 2009
Posts: 24510

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:51pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by saru.g

Originally posted by madhaviben

Originally posted by FLGators

Originally posted by madhaviben


yes  now  bahu  need  her  . birthday  per  jo  besan  ki  chikki  khayi  thi  voh  yad  karke  G3  will  help bahuLOL. bahu  ne  jo  maka  jaap  kiya  hai  uska  phal  mangne  ka  vakte  aagaya  hai.

hope so too...misunderstandings na ho, bus. The whole thing about Akshara not knowing is to create dramaOuch Pata nahi ab kitne din rona dekhna padegaCry They don't have anything happening at the Maheswari's other than some gossiping women who can't mind their business... Rashmi track is going nowhere. Rona dhona sab kuch hai lagtha hai...Ouch

tum  rona  dhona  ki  baat  karrahi  ho  i  was  thinking  that  now  Rashmi  ki  shadi  mai  maa  akshara  se  gulabo  giri  na  karvane  lage  that  she  is  now  preg  anymore  fir  aaram  karne  ki  kya  jarurat  hai?  dont  want  to  think  about  maheshwari  and  specialy  rajashri  Angry jis  din  usko  pata  chalega  god  save  us  the  mostSleepy she  will  cry  like  Cryand  when  akshi  was  in  lokar  room  that  time  mari  baachi Cry. now  she  even  cry  more  and  i  cant  take  it. i  still want  CV  to  show  naksh  imotion  and  not  rajashris  and  crying  . i  dont  want  her  to  take  akshi  to  maheshwari house  atall. i  want  naksh  togather  and  they  might  have  to  send  them  on  vacation  to  have  some  time  togather and  away  form  the  crying. hope  CV  cover  all that.

haa this time I dont want rajshri to take her to maheswaries... again there also rona dhona starts... it better naksh stays in singhanias... It will be even more good, if dj n rb tells naitik to take her some good place to feel her better... cv's atleast take them somewhere this time... after that they can show rashmi's marriage...


arrey baba no Maheshwaris...Ouch i am not willing to hear n watch her meri bachchi meri bachchi... Dead  its very irritating to watch her paglanpan again and again..
plzz use Naitik ke paas rakho n show them coming out from this loss...
hope to see them happy once again after i am back from my vacation..Big smile

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

_vinita_saru.g

smrth Goldie
smrth
smrth

Joined: 21 December 2009
Posts: 2239

Posted: 10 May 2011 at 10:52pm | IP Logged

@ TS,

Kudos. The post is rationalizing the things in perspectives. They've come up with a calculated risk. The tasting part is aesthetics. So far, not missing much, but for some minor technicalities...May they keep it up... Their goal, to show the couple negotiating one of the deepest pain a couple can face, hope they might have thought of consulting some professional on psychological aspects of this kind of loss and go about it carefully. They have an opportunity at hand...if only public melodrama restricted, (not possible though, the support cast will not allow it!LOL) and private scenes more subtle and more prevalent (hopeful)...

 Yes, good there is no vamp as events unfolded...The actors were good and Naitik's act evoked empathy. His situation landed him greater scope and he excelled (the actor). So is Hina. Hope she'd improve her grief scenes with more of subtlety.

@ last sentence, Such rationalizing posts are a treat to read-open forum give us this opportunity- invited or uninvited.Thumbs Up For me too this watch has become a 'long haul'...started in company of near ones and grew on me with some topicalities and some flashes of brilliances...Lately, perhaps they are doing things correctly. How else would they induce thought provoking posts?!

The following 8 member(s) liked the above post:

xyzeanamika00Madhavi_Di_vinita_moonlight08--Sari--_charu_saru.g

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index