India-Forums

   

Shaimak changes Last week winners...

HashiBoo IF-Sizzlerz
HashiBoo
HashiBoo

Joined: 15 January 2010
Posts: 12251

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 10:48am | IP Logged
Shaimak apologises for the mistake he has done last week. He realised that Mayuresh was better than Puneet that day and he changed the marks he has given 9- Mayuresh abd 8 - Puneet;

So Team Jalwa and Josh both were winners...

The following 8 member(s) liked the above post:

musica10devashree_hshootingstar27pigbelly4myfeethindu4lyfyipee.shona.Dabulls23

joyce_k Goldie
joyce_k
joyce_k

Joined: 13 January 2006
Posts: 1284

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 11:35am | IP Logged
I think that was a noble act by Shiamak Sir.
 

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

rouble_lover

petticoat IF-Stunnerz
petticoat
petticoat

Joined: 19 October 2006
Posts: 31655

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 11:36am | IP Logged
that was a good move! :)

The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

tanya12tawashepigbelly4myfeethindu4lyf

Jessica11001 Goldie
Jessica11001
Jessica11001

Joined: 26 May 2010
Posts: 1382

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 11:55am | IP Logged
although i agree that mayuresh deserved better marks last week, i didn't like that shaimak changed the score...that means judges can turn their decisions any time they want...no point of giving scores then...

The following 11 member(s) liked the above post:

gckasturiPayal9luv2danceaewasuresh555Anjaani_DastaanDesiGirl_shivani003musicheals-PhoenixD-yipee

tawashe Senior Member
tawashe
tawashe

Joined: 19 February 2011
Posts: 257

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 11:56am | IP Logged
Gosh, i didnt even know how to react to that. yes, i honestly felt that mayuresh should have won and that he was blatantly robbed. despite being a jalwa supporter i didnt celebrate the victory last week and right after DKS finished, i went to bed feeling very uneasy. This was why i didnt post much in this forum last week. Seems like Shamak sir also went through the same emotions. I loved what mayuresh said after that. he didnt have 'HA in your face' attitude, he wasnt happy and excited. he was so calm and really respected the judges despite their HUGE mistake. I loved how he so calmly said that we are all humans and humans make mistakes, but he always respects the judges' decisions. Seriously, now i'm slowly becoming his fan. I've always liked him but never cared much about him to love him or become his fan, even though there are some of this performances that i absolutely love. However, since DKS, especially last week's episode and this week's episode my opinion of him has changed for the better. Now I'm slowly becoming his fan.

I hope the judges won't make such mistakes again (yes i know all humans are prone to mistakes even though they are professionals). Like even though I thought Mayuresh was much better than Punit in the takkar, it definitely wasnt fair for Punit to be declared winner and then have that taken away from him. Something like that happening, regardless of who it is and in what profession, its just not pleasant, and to some degree is a bit embarrasing as well. But just like Mayuresh, i loved how he handled it and i loved his reply. 

Nevertheless, I was thinking, if we take into account Shamak sir's new score for that takkar then the two teams' score for last week is a tie. However, if the judges had not made this blunder and mayuresh had won the takkar then team josh would have won last week, but instead now its a tie. I know only shamak sir changed his score and remo sir did not. however i do believe that when you score at the moment like how the judges do in DKS, then the score that one judge gives does influence the score that the other judge gives even if it is just by a little, especially considering that they do discuss amongst each other. So thus, taking this into account do you still think its unfair?

I think in this entire drama, this mistake by the judges was unfair for two people
mayuresh and punit.
mayuresh lost when he clearly deserved to win, and punit did not deserve that humiliation of being told in front of everyone that there was a mistake and he in fact wasnt as good as initially told.

I just hope the judges dont make such major mistakes again this season and all the future seasons of DID.


Edited by tawashe - 06 May 2011 at 12:09pm

The following 13 member(s) liked the above post:

jaskittanya12gckasturigop94Noor_Ul_Ainluv2danceshootingstar27pigbelly4myfeetshivani003HashiBooEuphoria.LeadNitratepetticoat

petticoat IF-Stunnerz
petticoat
petticoat

Joined: 19 October 2006
Posts: 31655

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 11:58am | IP Logged
actually my favorite part in this mess is mayuresh maintaining his composure..

neither did he look heartbroken/depressed/angry last week nor did he look too excited(jumpy, in-ur-face laughing) today...he is a nice guy genuinely

The following 15 member(s) liked the above post:

tanya12tawashedevashree_hbhoomikauttampigbelly4myfeethindu4lyfash91sensodyneshivani003HashiBooEuphoria.yipeeFakeLove-x-Reshu-x-Dabulls23

tawashe Senior Member
tawashe
tawashe

Joined: 19 February 2011
Posts: 257

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 12:03pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by tawashe

Gosh, i didnt even know how to react to that. yes, i honestly felt that mayuresh should have won and that he was blatantly robbed. despite being a jalwa supporter i didnt celebrate the victory last week and right after DKS finished, i went to bed feeling very uneasy. This was why i didnt post much in this forum last week. Seems like Shamak sir also went through the same emotions. I loved what mayuresh said after that. he didnt have 'HA in your face' attitude, he wasnt happy and excited. he was so calm and really respected the judges despite their HUGE mistake. I loved how he so calmly said that we are all humans and humans make mistakes, but he always respects the judges' decisions. Seriously, now i'm slowly becoming his fan. I've always liked him but never cared much about him to love him or become his fan, even though there are some of this performances that i absolutely love. However, since DKS, especially last week's episode and this week's episode my opinion of him has changed for the better. Now I'm slowly becoming his fan.

However, I hope the judges won't make such mistakes again (yes i know all humans are prone to mistakes even though they are professionals). Like even though I thought Mayuresh was much better than Punit in the takkar, it definitely wasnt fair for Punit to be declared winner and then have that taken away from him. Something like that happening, regardless of who it is and in what profession, its just not pleasant, and to some degree is a bit embarrasing as well. But just like Mayuresh, i loved how he handled it and i loved his reply. 

Nevertheless, I was thinking, if we take into account Shamak sir's new score for that takkar then the two teams' score for last week is a tie. However, if the judges had not made this blunder and mayuresh had won the takkar then team josh would have won last week, but instead now its a tie. I know only shamak sir changed his score and remo sir did not. however i do believe that when you score at the moment like how the judges do in DKS, then the score that one judge gives does influence the score that the other judge even if it is just by a little, especially considering that they do discuss amongst each other. So thus, taking this into account do you still think its unfair?

I think in this entire drama, this mistake by the judges was unfair for two people
mayuresh and punit.
mayuresh lost when he clearly deserved to win, and punit did not deserve that humiliation of being told in front of everyone that there was a mistake and he in fact wasnt as good as initially told.

I just hope the judges dont make such major mistakes again this season and all the future seasons of DID.


Oh, i forgot to add one more thing.
So basically this is what happened:
-->   Shamak sir said that one major thing had been bothering him and eating him up and that he was unable to sleep at night. He said that  in last week's takkar Mayuresh was much better than Punit and deserved a higher score.

--> Mayuresh is so calm and collected about the entire situation.

---> I end up crying like crazy cuz I'm happy that Mayuresh deserved what he got, but also because I realized what an amazing genuine down-to-earth respectable person he is, just like Dharmesh Sir. I guess sooner or later, the good always get what they deserve.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

rouble_lover

HashiBoo IF-Sizzlerz
HashiBoo
HashiBoo

Joined: 15 January 2010
Posts: 12251

Posted: 06 May 2011 at 12:20pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by tawashe

Originally posted by tawashe

Gosh, i didnt even know how to react to that. yes, i honestly felt that mayuresh should have won and that he was blatantly robbed. despite being a jalwa supporter i didnt celebrate the victory last week and right after DKS finished, i went to bed feeling very uneasy. This was why i didnt post much in this forum last week. Seems like Shamak sir also went through the same emotions. I loved what mayuresh said after that. he didnt have 'HA in your face' attitude, he wasnt happy and excited. he was so calm and really respected the judges despite their HUGE mistake. I loved how he so calmly said that we are all humans and humans make mistakes, but he always respects the judges' decisions. Seriously, now i'm slowly becoming his fan. I've always liked him but never cared much about him to love him or become his fan, even though there are some of this performances that i absolutely love. However, since DKS, especially last week's episode and this week's episode my opinion of him has changed for the better. Now I'm slowly becoming his fan.

However, I hope the judges won't make such mistakes again (yes i know all humans are prone to mistakes even though they are professionals). Like even though I thought Mayuresh was much better than Punit in the takkar, it definitely wasnt fair for Punit to be declared winner and then have that taken away from him. Something like that happening, regardless of who it is and in what profession, its just not pleasant, and to some degree is a bit embarrasing as well. But just like Mayuresh, i loved how he handled it and i loved his reply. 

Nevertheless, I was thinking, if we take into account Shamak sir's new score for that takkar then the two teams' score for last week is a tie. However, if the judges had not made this blunder and mayuresh had won the takkar then team josh would have won last week, but instead now its a tie. I know only shamak sir changed his score and remo sir did not. however i do believe that when you score at the moment like how the judges do in DKS, then the score that one judge gives does influence the score that the other judge even if it is just by a little, especially considering that they do discuss amongst each other. So thus, taking this into account do you still think its unfair?

I think in this entire drama, this mistake by the judges was unfair for two people
mayuresh and punit.
mayuresh lost when he clearly deserved to win, and punit did not deserve that humiliation of being told in front of everyone that there was a mistake and he in fact wasnt as good as initially told.

I just hope the judges dont make such major mistakes again this season and all the future seasons of DID.


Oh, i forgot to add one more thing.
So basically this is what happened:
-->   Shamak sir said that one major thing had been bothering him and eating him up and that he was unable to sleep at night. He said that  in last week's takkar Mayuresh was much better than Punit and deserved a higher score.

--> Mayuresh is so calm and collected about the entire situation.

---> I end up crying like crazy cuz I'm happy that Mayuresh deserved what he got, but also because I realized what an amazing genuine down-to-earth respectable person he is, just like Dharmesh Sir. I guess sooner or later, the good always get what they deserve.



you spell it for me :) I couldnt write more about that as  i was excited to share in IF while watching the program... Thanks ..
I also become a fan of Mayuresh and has impressed with Siddesh ...

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index