Posted: 06 May 2011 at 3:23pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by merelychic
Originally posted by AbbiePrivate
Originally posted by qazplm
Originally posted by AbbiePrivate
I loved Hrithik in JA, he looked great esp in fighting scenes but sometimes he seems emotionless to me .. Salman Khan wouldve suited the role better IMHO
Wow, that is quite an interesting perspective. I can understand Salman pulling off a Partner/Wanted role quite effortlessly, but portraying Akbar better than HR? Definitely not.
Hrithik is miles and miles ahead of Salman in terms of acting. Heck, he's miles ahead many bollywood stars. I may not be able to stand his offscreen dull personality, but on-screen he's a brilliant actor. Although he hasn't made the best choices in his career, JA is one of his few movies where he excelled as an actor. His physique and stature added to the persona of the character.
In my opinion, Salman would have tried a Veer and completely ruined the character. But then again, he might have just pulled out a surprise.
Miles of Salman in terms of acting? since when? qazplm n merelychic.. Im here to comment what I think not to convince whoever.. n that's what all of us doing here, so, I disgree with all respect .. I can't name one performance of HR that really impressed me even JA.. as an actor he's so-so.. acc to me.. but it's not a big deal to each his own
I know you are entitled to your opinion but now that you questioned since when is Hrithik considered a better actor than Salman, allow me to do the honors of reminding you.
PLz dnt do the honors... if u like 2... den go to some UNIVERSITY
Are you aware of the number of awards(rigged or not) and critical acclaim Hrithik has managed to accomplish at short span which Salman is yet to achieve despite being his senior? He was amazing in Fiza,Lakshya,Guzaarish,Jodha Akbar,Koi Mil Gaya to name a few.
Shud i Remind u that Before Hrithik got launched in KNPH... he ws so lean dat his father cudnt launch him... so it was the BIG HEARTED "SALMAN KHAN" who trained him in his own GYM 2 get a 6 pack abs n body shody...
Rather Showing GRATITUDE... his fans showing ATTITUDE
but Salman on the other hand? can you name one career defining movie of his? I repeat he is the worst actor who is best suited in his comfort zone(the silly masala flicks) and that's why his fanbase mainly consists of single screen audiences and thats about it. even he worked with the best directors and tried to step out of his comfort zone by playing challenging roles particularly in Tere Naam and Kyun Ki like Hrithik but the ultimate verdict? He still failed to make a mark in these ventures and instead all the critics/reviewers ended up making fun of his 'laughable' performance and the general consensus is strictly negative. and Hrithik on the other hand was showered with lavish praises and 99% of the critics stood by him..
why only Hrithik? even Salmans peers/fellow Khans like SRK and Saif are more respected actors than him.
so bottom line? Salman is a horrible non-actor who is never taken seriously as an actor and this is a FACT, so take it or leave it.
It's been More than a DECADE for Mr.Hrithik Roshan in film Industry, still he hasn't given 1 ALL TIME BLOCKBUSTER for your honors i would like 2 tell u this only Salman has 4 ALL TIME BLOCKBUSTER movies... infact his Debut Movie was ATBB... I have nothing agaisnt HRITHIK... but when his fans start talking against Salman... den i shud gave dem da honors and ask dem "Let Hrithik gave his 1 ATBB Movie" den aana we wll talk
Edited by Da_BagarhBilla - 06 May 2011 at 3:25pm