Should Bollywood give second chance to Shiney? - Page 7

Originally posted by: desigal90

Being an A lister or not has nothing to do with it Maddy. With a tag like this, I doubt even an A lister would retain his honor and dignity.

And comparing Salman to Shiney is not quite fair according to me.

Salman's black buck incident seemed more stupidity than anything to me. As for his accident on the road, that was terrible. But even that to some extent can be redeemed by saying his intention was not to kill. The incident was horrific, but his intent was not.

 

Shiney on the other hand raped someone. His intentions were just as he heinous as his crime. What a traumatic traumatic act. You break a woman, physically as well as mentally and emotionally in rape. And he was fully aware of what he was doing. Exercising his dominance over a poor girl.

Edited by -Maddy- - 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Kabeer.

Woah!! Hold that cab right there mate :), first of all how did you even reach that decisive conclusion'  that I may be supporting Salman, he is worthy of opprobrium as I've always maintained. Yes the system is infested with corruption which permits proven cases to traipse around at will.

we are talking about Salman now. On Salman my thoughts are, if he did kill a person, he should pay for it. But there is a big, fat, if. I am not sure he did kill that person, or his driver was driving the car. He says he was not at the driving seat, so I give him benifit of the doubt. He needs to be a proven guilty, to give us the right to think about his freedom. I am not a Salman fan. Now don't kill me pleaseEdited by sheee - 12 years ago

I am studying for my law paper and suddenly, 2/3 topics look LAW related.. Am I hallucinating or I am still awake? =/

Originally posted by: Nuktaacheen

don't think sogazelle meant it for 'you', though he/she did quote you... it was more of a general comment...!  😛😛  people are writing shiney off on one hand, yet on the other hand, singing praises and 'going off easy' (i believe is the term) on someone else, because they flaunt their charitable deeds...!   😛😛

Trying to be human afterall!😊

I don't know why people who think Salman is not guilty and Shiney is guilty are being attacked and called hypocrites. Can others who are being so judgemental on these people get inside their heads and know what their though process is if the people find one celeb guilty and one not guilty, or if they think one celeb should be given a chance and the other shouldn't? Maybe the A, B lister thing is not the only criteria.. and the nature of crime or something else is their criteria.. why are people making everything black and white.. there are distinctions between crimes, there are distinctions between circumstances.. at the end it is everyone's personal decision to make a judgement.. i don't think one opinion is hyporcitical over the other. Edited by ladygaga - 12 years ago