Today once again we get an extremely painful ,gut-wrenching episode which made us all cry and feel for the loss of Geet and Maan ...but it was a beautifully executed and gripping episode
Agree dear - Beautiful episode. Well thought out, executed, enacted - just simply wonderfully done.
I m in tears actually watching the episode
..the scene where both slept in each other's arms on the hospital bed and cried their heart out will remain a memorable scene for me forever in this series
...it was beautifully captured and u can feel the extreme pain of both the characters the way they both so tightly held each other and felt the pain of losing their angel together
....Why I say GHSP is still better than other soaps is because here neither there is any melodrama nor any unnecessary stretching of hospital drama nor a cliched way of doctor saying "Geet can never b a mom"
nor Maan-Geet r blaming each other for the loss..instead they prefer to blame themselves for the loss and then cry in each other's arms
...the pain depicted looks realistic...watching their expression u can say yes these two hv really lost something very precious...and thats why I love the show whether it goes as per my wish or not ...
This no nonsense attitude of GHSP is what keeps us hooked... Loved the bed scene. I think it goes in my hall of fame too.
True - she had us all sympathyze with her at her vulnerability. Brilliantly acted Drashti
MSK is not good with words ...he always fumbles in such situations ...thats why we saw him walking out of the room because he was helpless and clueless about what to say..he hated the fact that Geet asking him to give their baby back and he could not do so....
...he could manage to get her a kulfi or a aloo tikki anytime and anywhere...but when it came to the most precious angel of their life,he could not get it for her
Precap actually shows a progress in the story because somewhere all 3 MSK,Dev and Geet right now r sharing the same pain and we can say that Dev-Geet r actually connected to a very strange bond ...that is the baby which is their blood....so I m glad that CVs r trying to show this complex relationship between the three characters here
...Mayb Dev's intention in the precap in just to console Geet because they both r sharing this same loss...but will this make MSK feel even more guilty or make him feel like a outsider there ??
...Or will his love for Geet overshadow all his other insecurities ??
....CVs hv shown a MC which is painful...some wanted it and some not...but what I can see from last 2 episodes is that they hv a planned track ahead and they r moving accordingly
Jyo - you are right - it definitely seems like the story is moving in a concrete direction now.. I am so excited.
There were few turn-offs in the episode like Dadi's cliched filmy dialogues trying to show her emotions but it din't touch me too much
;Then Arjun's concern for Geet doesn't make any sense
...But these were small issues...and overall GC-DD's brilliant performance overshadowed these minor issues today
Sorry again dear - another POV. I think Arjun being concerned for Geet is very well justified since the beginning of Arjun track. Arjun has no issues with any other family member of Khuranas except Maan. Even what he did to Annie was justified in his own right vs. wrong fight by saying he did all this just to hurt Maan. From the first encounter with Geet Arjun has always felt connected to Geet. She poured her heart out to him (A stranger then) in their first meeting, and he gave her his best suited advise. She stuck up for him to be the wedding planner. She always trusted him and defended him to maan. I don't think Arjun ever wanted anything bad for Geet. I didn't find THAT weird at all. But what I DID find off - was that they never show him come back from getting water, and no faceoff with Dev. I understand that wasn't the right time but then they shouldn't have shown him in the hospital in the first place. How could he have missed Dev in the hospital. What would his reaction have been? They could have added that one little ingredient in the story to make it more spicy. Or may be not. Who knows. All I am saying is that I didn't find Arjun's concern for Geet too weird.
Outstanding execution..flawless editing and direction...and Fantabulous acting by GC-DD is enough to give the episode full marks
Ok this was Episode Analysis and now I hv something else to say in General about this Post-MC Track
After going through FB and IF where I hv seen many r bashing either DD for the MC since she din't want a baby-bump or the CVs for it...I hv something to say today again
I cannot speak for others ..but can speak for myself...I analyse a show ,because I love to do it for my own satisfaction..I don't care if someone else is reading me or not...I love predicting or debating and I will keep doing that ..if not for this show..then mayb for some other show...it gives me the satisfaction to understand various human psychology in virtual world..
I think post-MC more of us r clueless about what next and that is what is making us so passive in our thinking....what happens is that when we watch a show,we make up a story in our mind about the characters and expect them to behave in a way we hv fantacized it...just when we see its going against our wish,we start getting negative towards the show and jump to conclusions like story is over..characters r ruined...etc etc
..its because we ourselves r blank and stunned with the sudden twist in the storyline which mayb we hv not expected...but think of it...isn't this the creativity coming from the CVs where still after 1 year they hv the capability to shock us ...After watching saturday's episode..how many cried ...or how many went numb asking what next ?...I guess all had that feeling in their mind...right
...and that itself is the answer that story is not over because we r asking what next....its just that what we hv predicted has not happened...so again we can say unpredictable nature in the show is back...isn't that positive ?...
MC is painful...but even pain can b beautifully depicted on screen if the CVs hv a vision
...I dunno if anyone has read my analysis for the MC-Episode...but I hv already predicted the future story..I dunno if it will happen the way I hv visualised ...but still like I said it gives me satisfaction to keep predicting irrespective of the outcome ..mayb I m stupid or over-positive or whatever
..but I hv been doing this for past 12 yrs now
......I feel the loss of baby can b seen fron a different POV...if the MC would hv happened because of Brij or NT..we can say Geet lost her justice battle...but was that the case ?No..Geet lost her baby in a accident because for the first time she showed more concern for her hubby than her baby...we can say the choice loop started by MSK is completed by Geet here.....This itself can give rise to a gripping track ....how will MSK react when he will come to know about it ?..will this change Geet-MSK ka equation ...will they b able to come out of this loss ?...was Dev behind all this ?...Can Geet still get her justice ?...Will this loss make Geet strong and she will join KC to come out of her depression ?...These questions can make the future track...so from which angle we can say Story is over ?...Yes I agree things hv not gone the way we wanted ..but that doesn't close the options....if baby track had a story potential then even MC-track hv a story potential....we just need to think from that point now...Geet might hv lost her baby but does this end her journey or struggle ?..
WOW - great perspective Jyoti. I never thought of it as a closed loop until you mentioned it. Geet's concern for Maan was more than the baby. SOOOO TRUE!!! Wonderfully perceived.
And lets b honest here..Did CVs really do justice to the baby track even once ?
....Several illogical scenes were shown which made us question whether Geet will give birth to a superman or what sort of pregnency is this
...we might hv justified it all because we wanted the baby but somewhere we hv seen that CVs themselves were not comfortable carrying out the baby -track....they were not able to progress with the story with the baby track for last 2 months if u see....I dunno who is at fault here....CVs or actors or who,..its not my problem..I m seeing it as viewer...and I can see CVs had no real vision with this baby track...Mayb now with MC-Track they hv a certain vision
....mayb now they r more comfortable to progress the story ahead ...because the way MC-Episode was executed....I feel CVs hv a track in mind...they know what they r doing....Its a challenge for them and for the first time they hv dared to do something which had stunned half of the fans...We hv extreme views just because saturday ka episode moved us...shocked us...made us clueless ....how many other shows hv actually evoked so many emotions altogether in virtual world ??...so that itself gives rise to many possibilities ./..
Analysis/discussions/debates is not just limited to demanding from CVs we want this and we want that.....Analysis/Discussion/debates should b done till the time we hv certain emotions left for the show....emotions can b extreme here..but the fact that we all r affected one way or the other itself proves that whatever we might say,we still want to know WHAT NEXT ?...
About DD's baby bump issue..who m I to judge here....Its not my headache..I m just a general viewer
....as long as an actor, she will give us mindblowing performance irrespective of which direction the track goes...I will continue to admire her professionalism...fact that her expressions in last 2 secs of the episode moved me to tears ,I will admire her....fact that both GC-DD's performance hv evoked such strong emotions in all of us,I will admire them in thier profession....What they want to do or not do is their choice..every actor draws certain limitations in their career to make sure that their performance looks convincing and they don't make a mockery of themselves on screen if they r not comfortable with it....SRK refused lip-kissing on screen ...does that make him unprofessional ?...he might b hving reasons for it
....And here we don't even know the real story ...based on one gossip page of TOI,is it fair to jump to conclusions that DD is responsible and throw mud at an actress who hv continued to give mindblowing performance over 10 months...why we love Geet serial so much...why we feel connected to this show so much ? Is it not because of the actors who never failed to surprise us for their flawless acting ....and today just because things in the story don't go our way,is it fair to throw mud on those actors ?...it mayb the CV's vision also...mayb they r not comfortable with a baby track...mayb they want to move the story in a different direction...who knows what is the inside story....I feel we as viewers should stop speculating about an actor's personal life equation or their demands or whatever because inspite of hving 100s of birdies noone really knows what goes behind the screen.....We hv visualised something,but CVs went the opposite direction...so what next ?...lets accept it that way without blaming anyone else...