Originally posted by: ReldaI was watching Kuch Kuch Hota Hai on TV and I realized that I absolutely hated the ending. I would have preferred kajol to choose Salman and not be the after-thought, second-choice bride for Shah Rukh. I mean SRK never even thought about her in all those years and if Rani hadn't died he would have been blissfully unaware of her for ever. His avowal of love was more like opportunism and a desire for a second chance at love, IMO. Salman's love for Kajol was more deep and powerful.
Originally posted by: pooja_l
it was rani's character who was very wierd, why would u leave such a loving hubby, no wonder kajol left this role
Originally posted by: Illogicalactually, i don't think the ending for KKHH was unrealistic... clearly, kajol's character had still not gotten over her past...
Originally posted by: LifeOLicious
KKHH ending was not unrealistic I agree but the way it was executed was unrealistic. I still don't get why she ever agreed to even get married (she was not forced or anything! she made the choice herself!).....if you can't get over your past don't humiliate other people and on the wedding day turn your back! Anyways it was dramatic and it worked as a cheesy ending....it's a KJo movie so I leave it there....
Originally posted by: LifeOLiciousI disliked HDDCS ending the most....I agree with the ending. It's the right choice for a girl...but it was still very brutal in it's execution. It breaks your heart! Especially for Salman....
Adding to HDDCS discussion....Ash experienced marital life with Ajay and he was loving and agreed to take her to her lover by going against his own family. She realized this much later....she loved Salman but how much did she really know him? Could she have left her family and everyone and settle in Italy with people she barely knew? If Salman and Ash had a deeper relationship where they spent considerable time with each other (and did not live in a a foreign country...I don't think Ash was an urban girl so life in Italy may not suit her!).I am pretty sure Ash would have gone for Salman. But she was too usnure of her future with him as she didn't really know him in that way so she chose Ajay who of course loved her.
And I agree with whoever said they hated Ash's father. Absolutely! He was obnoxious! But in the end he was proven right! How irritating!
The one I really did not like was Kyun Ki (2005) (Salman & Kareena). I was crying,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
comment:
p_commentcount