Critical Review of Reality Shows this week!

The expectations of the viewers are high as all the three reality shows have now entered into the final phase with the top contestants giving their best. Check out the Critical Analysis to know more!

Monday, August 06, 2007 | 1:45:41 PM IST (+05:30 GMT)   |  Copyright: india-forums.com  |  Comments 14 Comments  |  3219 Views


Watching these shows, though most of the time we get satisfied, there are also times when the viewers get disappointed. Such was the case of SRGMP show this week. Fridayís episode was so disappointing that none of the viewers enjoyed watching the show where the major disappointment came from the song selection by the participants. If they donít select a song that is common among the viewers, the connection with the viewers is totally lost and they stop enjoying the show. It was sad songs theme but instead of the songs, it was the performance itself that brought the sadness among the viewers. This continued on Saturday where barring few contestants like Poonam, Amanat, Sumedha and Mussarat, others failed to give their best. Drama has now become part of every Saregamapa episode. Even if there is no subject, the mentors Himesh and Ismail bring in old subject of C2005 and just changing the names of the contestants. If it was Vinitís love story in C2005, it is now for a difference Amanat, Aneek's triangular love story. And what to say about repeated reminder of vote from Assam for Joy. Is such drama required for a musical show? The viewers are now getting more annoyed with the same old subject bring brought in again.


The disparity between the judges is now part of all the shows with Annu Malek leading the team. It has now become his habit to disagree with everyone. He makes it a point that none of them argues with him on his opinion and even if they do, his harsh tone of voice suppresses the other judges. When is he going to change this attitude of his? If this is the case in Indian Idol then SVOI is also not far behind. On one hand Abhijit is hardly giving them any marks while Jatin just to show his impartiality is giving very high ratings for every performance. How can the SRGMP Guruís stay behind!! Bappida was found always awarding very less marks to other gharana contestants followed by his Xerox-Copy comment Ė ďThere was problem in your lower notes.Ē On the other hand Ismail Durbarís Gurugraph never sees the lower notes.


The hype for contestants has still not stopped in the shows. The contestant Mauli in SRGMP is now being hyped too much while in SVOI the hype is shifted to Aabhas. Mauli gets a watch for getting highest votes (Incidentally it was not given to Raja who got highest votes for three week in running) and Aabhas is given a Dairy Milk Chocolate for performing so well while others who also performed well, were not given any appreciation. Why is such hype for the contestants? But an interesting point to note here is while SVOI is sponsored by Amul, Abbhas gets the Cadbury chocolate.Interesting Ė Isnít It?? ;)


We are again getting to see the true color of public voting. Though the deserving contestants are getting through to the next round, still the Bottom 3 or 4 contestants are one of the top performers in the show. This is being seen in all the 3 shows. Amanat in SRGMP getting in bottom 3, Emon and Puja getting in bottom 4 in Indian Idol, Aabhas and Ashpreet getting in bottom 4 in SVOI are the examples of how the public voting can cause serious damage to the talent in the later stages. Hope from next time, we donít get to see some shockers in results like this week and May the best one win!!

Author: Barnali

P.S. The opinions expressed in here is strictly those of the author. So for more information please contact the author only.



Share this News on your Social Network.

User Rating Rating(24 Votes)
  gk_09, supriyodas, Anu4u, Raima36, ~farah_r~, nabz8888, ajpudi, gopalbhai, trups, amina877, princezna, o|oNaTaShAo|o, sudhirm_2007, Jaslove, Dark Love, coolsonu, tina_sre, thesaint148, smallwonder, Ambrosia, Kiran., minuu, anishma24, mcm226

User Comments & Ratings

Join India Forums for free to comment on this story. Have an account already? Use Quick Login to comment.

Dear Readers,

  • Please do not use derogatory comments in reply to the stories published on Telly Buzz, India-Forums.
  • The credibility of the site matter to us, and the comments in bad taste tend to invariably hurt the actors/production house/channel etc.
  • So kindly, refrain from creating an unhealthy atmosphere for all, and keep your comments constructive.
  • Also, please use the Rate It button if you want to just thank the author for posting the story.

Related Shows

Love Story
Love Story

  • Posted on: 07 August 2007 at 11:35amo|oNaTaShAo|o

    Wonderful article....keep up the good work

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 10:33pmBansari7

    why do people always bring my Vinit into everything?

    anyway nice article

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 6:50pmHerman_4u

    about amant and aneek's love story i thought the same thing that whatever himesh told us about vinit he's saying the same thing here.

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 1:08pmammmu

    I'm also quite upset that Himesh and Ismail are giving 10/10's bindaas... for almost every contestant, or atleast the ones who are hyped up :S What happened to criticising and trying to improve? if you keep giving 10's, there is nothing to shoot for...

    Thanks for the article Barnalidi, very good points...

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 12:21pm~RexKiRani~

    awesome article written i agree with each and every word saidddddd

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 7:57amlive_life

    srgmp

    In SRGMP...I think the drama was no needed

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 7:05amcoolsonu

    I am fed up of the arguments b/w the judges...they shud come up wid sumthing new now!!

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 5:27amsmallwonder

    ya that chocolate thing was so weird - no announcement, nothing - suddenly u find Shaan walking in with a 5 feet chocolate lolz... but on the whole, a great week for voi... thnx for the review...

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 4:36amtina_sre

    Very well written....I too agree Mouli is hyped too much.

  • Posted on: 06 August 2007 at 3:33amkavmuks

    Are Judges doing their duty?

    Agreed.

    In AVOI.. the song selection according to the visiting celebrity is bringing the competition level down. Govinda's songs look good on screen and you can enjoy the songs (that to all some of them) only with video.
    where is Aadesh now who made such a whoo-halla about singing Hari on hari.. song.

    Why is Lalit irritated by Abhijit's marks who rarely gave more than 6 or 7 earlier? All judges are irritatingly loving to the candidates. May be they try to show that they are not like II3 judges. they have stopped telling their mistakes also.

    In SRGMP Ismail Darbar jii is acting really funny. I had some respect for him during SRMP 2005 but now I feel he is too frustrated.

    Now judges are asking for marks for their candidates from each other. : (

Tellybuzz Critics Corner Articles Index

Telly Buzz Search

  

Bollywood's Most romantic Rain Songs

Views : 162405
Comments :9

Shree - Promo

Views : 11194
Comments :0

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.