Debate Mansion

What is the best way to treat depression?

WillSmith456 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
What is the best way to treat depression?

New generation anti-depressants including Prozac and Seroxat only help
a small group of the most severely depressed, according to a study
carried out by the University of Hull.

Many individuals believe the drugs do work for them, but researchers
claim that this could be a placebo effect - people feel better simply
because they are taking a medication which they think will help them.

Prescriptions for anti-depressants hit a record high of more than 31
million in England in 2006. The government has promised more
investment in talking therapies, which ministers see as a better alternative
to drugs.

Do you agree with the research findings? Have you taken anti-
depressants? Did you find them helpful? Are you someone who dealt with
depression without using chemical treatments? Should the government
invest more money in talking therapies?   

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1076

Users

9

Frequent Posters

return_to_hades thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 7 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
Excercise releases endorphins and endorphins makes people happy. The answer is clear. An active lifestyle.
TallyHo thumbnail
Anniversary 18 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
anti depressants are definitley overprescribed...and anti depressants can work only if there is a chemical imbalance...
any social/familial issues that exacerbate the situation need to be dealt with

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: TallyHo

anti depressants are definitley overprescribed...and anti depressants can work only if there is a chemical imbalance...
any social/familial issues that exacerbate the situation need to be dealt with

totally with u here doc.  depression resulting from behavioral or familial issues should be dealt with w/o the use of drugs.  as rth pointed out above, nothing works better than keeping oneself occupied with constructive activities😊

qwertyesque thumbnail
Anniversary 17 Thumbnail Group Promotion 5 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

try hving s*x (remember monsters ballπŸ˜†), laughter therapy... watch simpsons, take prozac or finally shoot yourself..(not u. just u in general) .if nothing helps πŸ˜† these are some nuske...for treating depression... 😊

ya ya i dont take anti-depressants... as much just once in a while...right now mostly at step 1...πŸ˜†

Edited by qwertyesque - 16 years ago
Posted: 16 years ago
Originally posted by: qwertyesque

try hving s*x (remember monsters ballπŸ˜†), laughter therapy... watch simpsons, take prozac or finally shoot yourself..(not u. just u in general) .if nothing helps πŸ˜† these are some nuske...for treating depression... 😊

ya ya i dont take anti-depressants... as much just once in a while...right now mostly at step 1...πŸ˜†

πŸ˜†πŸ˜† itna hans rahey ho toh bhi sirf step 1πŸ€”  actually step two toh paar ker hee chukey ho aur simpson apni av mein laga rakha hai......😲  abhi bhi waqt hai buddy, sambhal jao.  u r on the verge of taking prozacπŸ˜‰πŸ˜›πŸ˜†

chatbuster thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

i had a friend whose sister was manic depressive (i think that's the term?). she'd get suicidal and had made a few attempts earlier. quite a nympho too, pretty disoriented and engaged in self-destructive behavior. much later, when she was in her teens, her folks took her to a leading lab and found out she had a chemical imbalance in her brain. she's been under medication since, and seems she's doing better. just someone's story in case it helps to know. made me view these illnesses differently from how i might have seen them earlier.
Posted: 16 years ago

^^but not all depressions are because of chemical imbalances. only some are and in those cases, medication is required. nothing helps other than medication there.  psychiatrist treatment along with medication works wonders though.  it is said that less than 10% of all cases of depression are due to chemical imbalances.

i agree, in our culture people don't take depression or certain other psychological disorders seriously. many times even chemical imbalances are left unattended. but depression due to certain behavioral or familial situations can be overcome with strong will power, caring family and keeping oneself busy doing constructive activities. counselling helps too but lot of desis look down upon conselling as well.

like any other psychological illness, there are many theories on depression also.  something interesting i found on the net:

Is depression caused by chemical imbalance?

ALL emotional responses have a chemical consequence. When we laugh, for example, there is a greater amount of chemical endorphins (natural painkillers) released into the blood stream. Endorphins do not cause laughter however, they are a consequence of it.

Until recently, and partly because of drug-company marketing, the widespread belief was that depression was a biological illness. It's even been called a 'disease.'

Bear with us if you have completed the Depression Learning Path already, as you will have already read this, but it really is so important.

Depression is 10 times more common in people born since 1945 compared to people born before 1945. So, ten times as people are becoming depressed now as compared to fifty years ago (and this research takes into account increased reporting and public awareness). Biology doesn't change this fast. Genes don't alter this rapidly - so this is a clue that clinical depression and its increase are more to do with the way society and lifestyles are changing.

Depression is not an inevitable consequence of adverse life circumstances either, as only a minority of people exposed to difficult situations go on to develop clinical depression.

So what is depression if not a result of chemical imbalances - the physical symptoms are real enough!

Depression is actually a state of high arousal. Depressed people have higher concentrations of stress hormones (cortisol, noradrenaline) than non-depressed people.(1) The apathy and exhaustion seen in depressed people is a consequence of too much arousal, and the way the body and mind respond to this arousal.

The way we respond to situations (with thoughts of hopelessness, helplessness, anxiety, anger, etc.) effects the emotions we feel which, in turn effect the chemicals which are released.

But the emotionally aroused brain and the presence of stress hormones in turn affects how we think and feel - so it is a 'two way street'. Thoughts and emotions affect chemical composition and chemical composition affects thoughts and emotions.

So, to sum up, beating depression is not about bad things happening to us but rather how we have learned to respond to life events - god or bad.

Thyroid problems, food intolerances and other physical illness can lead to feelings of depression but less than 10% of clinical depression is thought to have a chemical basis. Appropriate psychotherapy has still been shown to be more effective than drug treatment alone in the treatment of chemically based depression, and far more effective in preventing relapse. By far the majority of depressions are learned phenomena not chemical ones.

To learn more about how arousal affects physiology and depression, take the Depression Learning Path.

 

Edited by Gauri_3 - 16 years ago
lighthouse thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

 Prozac and psychiarist both can make one feel worse sometimes. We all know side effects of anti depressants, but has anyone heard how a psychiatrist can make one feel bad. 😊.

 "My psychiatrist told me I was crazy and I said I want a second opinion. He said okay, you're ugly too." Rodney Dangerfield.πŸ˜›

*Jane* thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

I think what RTH and TallyHo said just about sums up how I feel this should be treated.

I'm, personally, adverse to any kind of drugs (medical or otherwise) so I don't take any pills (no problems with others taking it, just don't want to put it inside my body). I may have gone through depression but most just call that the teenage angst years. πŸ˜ƒ