Joined: 30 May 2007
thank u very much for the tamil link...The song is sung By P.sushila and Ghantasala......resposting the tamil link ..ufortunately,cldn't find a youtube link
and a big thank you again for posting Shreya's version.She also sounds gr8,she wasn't very old then probably14-15..coz it was the kids competition....in fact,she is my favourite li'l champ she was amazing
Joined: 30 May 2007
You are absolutely right, I was also amazed how can we say this song flawless or close to original. Actually she even did not try to go close to original. This song has not only variation in line but variation in words. Even simple word like "bole" is pronounced with variation of voice. Anamika never sang the taan(aa aahaa aa aaa aaa... I am not sure if it is called taan) full lenght, she went till 70-75% of the original. Anamika clearly avoid doing tough thing and took easy route, she should have been allowed to sing full song. Poonam tried that modulation and variation, which is beauty of this song but at couple of places she put little more than required variation/modulation. If you listen Anamika's version you will feel she was a bit flat. I dont know about music, but my feel is, beauty of this song is the variation and modulation of voice... I can not say any of them were close to original but Poonam tried to go close to original while Anamika even did not try to go close. As this is my favorite song, so I could not stop myself commenting on this.
But I appreciate Anamika for just trying this song, I never think she belongs to this genre but she did her best. She will improve with age. She is the only contestant who can be called as singer in this show and she put lot of effort after Smita's elimination. Others are not even at the level of reality show singer.
I agree with everything u've said...The level of singers in reality shows nowadays is not in the same class of earlier SRGMP ones,where each singer wld be a gem and wld be outstanding.Aren't there shc singers anymore/do they not particpate in these shows?I agree Anamika stands out among the lot.
as for the original song,i agree with all u've said.I also felt that she didn't match upto the original taan(in aa aaa),or go anywhere near it(esp the ending notes).This song needs more softness and yet more strength in its notes.Even the words "kuhu kuhu"shld be sung in a certain manner...like half singing and half like the sound of the koyal.....all these are small things which make the song outstanding.But full marks to Anamika for atempting this song and managing to sing it well.She is young and will certainly improve over time.
she is listening to the right songs and learning the right things.she will go a long way
|Topics||Topic Starter||Replies||Views||Last Post|
|Kuhu Kuhu - who was better||diamond444||45||2596||02 December 2009 at 7:14pm
|who can sing kuhu kuhu bole koyalia||Indradhanush||46||2338||13 September 2008 at 9:43am
|Poonams Kuhu Kuhu Bole||mat1||7||733||11 October 2007 at 12:02pm
|Kuhu Kuhu Bole Koyalia...||juggyE||16||1359||28 September 2007 at 9:27pm
|Kuhu Kuhu Bole Koyalia:The classical duet||Barnali||22||12537||21 November 2006 at 9:24pm