New User? Register Now
Draco_Luver
Newbie
Joined: 30 July 2005
Posts: 28
Haha. 
*~Ish~*
Groupbie
Joined: 17 April 2005
Posts: 96
i feel that he's dead for sure
JKR's words: she had to kill off dumbledore because Harry (like all heroes) has to go the road alone
annnd...i think the Unbreakable Vow is gonna kno if Snape killed dumbledore or not...if dumbledore is still alve...and bye bye snape (he should've died or will die) so to fulfill the the Vow...dumbledore needs to be dead..u can't fool the Vow
those r just my views..and i'm happy with dumbledore's portrait as long as he's there (a reason i think harry WILL go back to Hogwarts..to talk to the portrait)...as much as i want him to be alive...i don't think he will *sigh*
I agree with you Ish.
I also feel that Dumbledore is truly dead as:
1) JKR has never resurrected any character who died - Harry's parents, Sirius, etc. So it is unlikely that she will resurrect Dumbledore except through a Portrait of old headmasters or the Chocolate Frog Cards
2) You are absolutely right about the Unbreakable Vow. If Dumbledore was still alive, Snape would have definitely died as he would not have fulfilled the terms of the contract...
Like the Goblet of Fire, the Unbreakable vow is a powerful magical contract and its not an object which can be confunded.
yup...i'm pretty sure he's dead, but that doesn't mean harry can't talk to him...there's always the portrait
Monaji
Senior Member
Joined: 17 June 2004
Posts: 641
Draco_Luver
Newbie
Joined: 30 July 2005
Posts: 28
i feel that he's dead for sure
JKR's words: she had to kill off dumbledore because Harry (like all heroes) has to go the road alone
annnd...i think the Unbreakable Vow is gonna kno if Snape killed dumbledore or not...if dumbledore is still alve...and bye bye snape (he should've died or will die) so to fulfill the the Vow...dumbledore needs to be dead..u can't fool the Vow
those r just my views..and i'm happy with dumbledore's portrait as long as he's there (a reason i think harry WILL go back to Hogwarts..to talk to the portrait)...as much as i want him to be alive...i don't think he will *sigh*
I agree with you Ish.
I also feel that Dumbledore is truly dead as:
1) JKR has never resurrected any character who died - Harry's parents, Sirius, etc. So it is unlikely that she will resurrect Dumbledore except through a Portrait of old headmasters or the Chocolate Frog Cards
2) You are absolutely right about the Unbreakable Vow. If Dumbledore was still alive, Snape would have definitely died as he would not have fulfilled the terms of the contract...
Like the Goblet of Fire, the Unbreakable vow is a powerful magical contract and its not an object which can be confunded.
yup...i'm pretty sure he's dead, but that doesn't mean harry can't talk to him...there's always the portrait
*~Ish~*
Groupbie
Joined: 17 April 2005
Posts: 96
| Topics | Topic Starter | Replies | Views | Last Post | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Which Dumbledore Actor? | Mrs.MuffinSobti | 25 | 1551 | 25 January 2009 at 10:29am By Ahlaam5 |
|
| Did Dumbledore have a right? | shellytt | 5 | 286 | 11 January 2009 at 10:35am By fly_chick |
|
| Dumbledore's Army Elimination Game | ~*Thamizhan*~ | 43 | 1340 | 31 August 2008 at 1:15am By tukz_REmix |
|
| Did dumbledore really love/care 4 Harry? | Mit's113 | 18 | 2497 | 18 January 2008 at 7:22am By lucky_lakshmi |
|
| dumbledore a "gay"-explain | chinkyshona | 9 | 525 | 07 January 2008 at 6:57pm By *Jane* |
Be the part of India's biggest discussion portal.
It’s easy to Join and it’s free.
Register now while it’s free!
Already a member? Close this window and log in.
