Qubool Hai

India-Forums

   
Qubool Hai
Qubool Hai

Is Sanam (Jannat) still Aahil's legal wife?

beekay1 Goldie
beekay1
beekay1

Joined: 08 May 2013
Posts: 1041

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 6:28am | IP Logged

***** DISCLAIMER *******

This is not a post that is bashing any group nor supporting any group. So please, may we have unbiased comments here. Whatever is said here is just my opinion not because hate or love any person or group. This post is not bashing actors. Its just an analysis of the story and the characters.


Is Sanam  still Aahil's legal wife?
Wasn't the marriage a contract marriage where Sanam had also signed the divorce papers?  So it means that Sanam is not legally married to Aahil. Aahil was to tie the knot with Sanam to make it official and that is when Sanam2 happened, right?  So rightfully Sanam2 is Aahil's legal wife.

I am a silent reader in this forum at most times and I am confused with the posts that bash Shaad saying that he is wrong in doing what he is doing...using Sanam's memory loss to "his" benefit. But is he using her memory loss to his benefit or is he doing it for for the security of two nations. He is just fulfilling his duty as a soldier. Sure he fell in love but he has not taken advantage of Sanam physically...as in enforcing husbandly-wifely duties until now. He is just in protect-mode as he knows her life is in danger. He also made her wear the burkha to ensure her safety.

I thought the Pak section was quite interesting and quite liked it... the reason is that it brought to my mind what our army, navy, air force personals have to endure out there in the battlefield... They sometimes have to suppress their conscience and do what is right for the country and not one individual or themselves. They have to even forget family commitments (he went against his father and aunt). Sure he fell in love with Jannat eventually, but can any person control an emotion called love?

I don't think Shaad even knows that Jannat(Sanam) is married? Does he?  Shaad saved Sanam from being killed by claiming her as his wife Jannat and as I recall he was also quite insistent that Jannat goes her own way after that till he realized that she had valuable information. He did feel guilty but it was his sense of duty that made him do "wrong". 

Was it really "wrong"? Wasn't he thinking of the safety of two nations and that's millions and millions of lives to save instead of one and his conscience? 

I quite liked it that 4lions, Gul in their own illogical way honored our men out there fighting for our safety. I do admit that it could have been done better...  

Isn't Aahil the one, who is in the wrong here? He's legally married to one but pursuing another. I'm not talking about love coz love does not give us the right to do wrong. Shouldn't he first work on divorcing Sanam2 before he runs after Sanam?

I'm just looking at this logically... 


Have a great day







The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

ikhlasstastahninNikita_Smithslippery_chilkaGitaIyer

KhatamKahani IF-Stunnerz
KhatamKahani
KhatamKahani

Joined: 27 December 2009
Posts: 27846

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 6:32am | IP Logged
Originally posted by beekay1


***** DISCLAIMER *******

This is not a post that is bashing any group nor supporting any group. So please, may we have unbiased comments here. Whatever is said here is just my opinion not because hate or love any person or group. This post is not bashing actors. Its just an analysis of the story and the characters.


Is Sanam  still Aahil's legal wife?
Wasn't the marriage a contract marriage where Sanam had also signed the divorce papers?  So it means that Sanam is not legally married to Aahil. Aahil was to tie the knot with Sanam to make it official and that is when Sanam2 happened, right?  So rightfully Sanam2 is Aahil's legal wife.

I am a silent reader in this forum at most times and I am confused with the posts that bash Shaad saying that he is wrong in doing what he is doing...using Sanam's memory loss to "his" benefit. But is he using her memory loss to his benefit or is he doing it for for the security of two nations. He is just fulfilling his duty as a soldier. Sure he fell in love but he has not taken advantage of Sanam physically...as in enforcing husbandly-wifely duties until now. He is just in protect-mode as he knows her life is in danger. He also made her wear the burkha to ensure her safety.

I thought the Pak section was quite interesting and quite liked it... the reason is that it brought to my mind what our army, navy, air force personals have to endure out there in the battlefield... They sometimes have to suppress their conscience and do what is right for the country and not one individual or themselves. They have to even forget family commitments (he went against his father and aunt). Sure he fell in love with Jannat eventually, but can any person control an emotion called love?

I don't think Shaad even knows that Jannat(Sanam) is married? Does he?  Shaad saved Sanam from being killed by claiming her as his wife Jannat and as I recall he was also quite insistent that Jannat goes her own way after that till he realized that she had valuable information. He did feel guilty but it was his sense of duty that made him do "wrong". 

Was it really "wrong"? Wasn't he thinking of the safety of two nations and that's millions and millions of lives to save instead of one and his conscience? 

I quite liked it that 4lions, Gul in their own illogical way honored our men out there fighting for our safety. I do admit that it could have been done better...  

Isn't Aahil the one, who is in the wrong here? He's legally married to one but pursuing another. I'm not talking about love coz love does not give us the right to do wrong. Shouldn't he first work on divorcing Sanam2 before he runs after Sanam?

I'm just looking at this logically... 


Have a great day




Very short answer. Because that's all which is needed as your premise itself is false and incorrect.

Sanam never signed divorce papers and she always maintained it to Tanveer and later Sanam2 that she is still legally and officially Aahil's wife.

Aahil is officially and legally considered married to both Sanam and Sanam2. This was shown in Tanveer Chowk episode, as well as Sanam2's various statements to media.

Sanam is missing.


Edited by KhatamKahani - 07 May 2015 at 6:37am

The following 22 member(s) liked the above post:

NoLifeme.....LelyaHanie-secretlove-Mahu34..PlayfulKiss..-GrilledCheese-fanraya-Raj-AGirlHasNoNamemicshyJShuklasimran_singh_24Laura..RaingoddessIntuitiveMs.Sherlocked...Tanu...MrDarcyfanadventure_gurlflora212

flora212 IF-Stunnerz
flora212
flora212

Joined: 25 December 2011
Posts: 36088

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 6:34am | IP Logged
Sanam is Aahil's Legally Wedded Wife. She never signed divorce papers.  Marraige is marraige whether its contract or not cause they are not divorced.  Sanam 2 is not legally wedded with Aahil as she is not Sanam Ahmed Khan. But in the eyes of public yes she is considered Aahil's second wife officially. And no Aahil doesn't need to tie knot with Sanam again. 

The following 21 member(s) liked the above post:

me.....NoLifecherryfrasierLelyaHanie-secretlove-harshana1..PlayfulKiss..Mahu34-GrilledCheese-fanrayamicshyAGirlHasNoNamesimran_singh_24Laura..Raingoddess...Tanu...IntuitiveMs.SherlockedMrDarcyfanKhatamKahani

KhatamKahani IF-Stunnerz
KhatamKahani
KhatamKahani

Joined: 27 December 2009
Posts: 27846

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 6:37am | IP Logged
Originally posted by flora212

Sanam is Aahil's Legally Wedded Wife. She never signed divorce papers.  Marraige is marraige whether its contract or not cause they are not divorced.  Sanam 2 is not legally wedded with Aahil as she is not Sanam Ahmed Khan. But in the eyes of public yes she is considered Aahil's second wife officially. And no Aahil doesn't need to tie knot with Sanam again

+2000

There is no need for Aahil and Sanam to marry again.

The following 17 member(s) liked the above post:

LelyaHanie-secretlove--GrilledCheese-..PlayfulKiss..JShuklamicshyfanrayaAGirlHasNoNameLaura..Raingoddesssimran_singh_24MrDarcyfanMs.Sherlocked...Tanu...Intuitiveflora212

KhatamKahani IF-Stunnerz
KhatamKahani
KhatamKahani

Joined: 27 December 2009
Posts: 27846

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 6:50am | IP Logged
Also, Shaad is conning and deceiving "Jannat." He very early on decided to keep up the lie for SK, which put "Jannat" in more danger. Then he continued his lies when it had no connection to SK, because he was falling for her. During all this time, he never bothered to act decently and had no problems taking shameless liberties with her (without her real consent) and bragged about his fake husband credentials to his father.

Doesn't matter if this woman is married or not. He is basically keeping her in a kidnapped and brainwashed state, with him either having no conscience or having bought into his own lies.


Edited by KhatamKahani - 07 May 2015 at 6:54am

The following 19 member(s) liked the above post:

NoLifeme.....PrettYSmileLelya-secretlove-harshana1..PlayfulKiss..-GrilledCheese-fanrayaAGirlHasNoNameJShuklamicshyLaura..RaingoddessIntuitiveMs.Sherlocked...Tanu...MrDarcyfanflora212

flora212 IF-Stunnerz
flora212
flora212

Joined: 25 December 2011
Posts: 36088

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 6:56am | IP Logged
Originally posted by KhatamKahani

Also, Shaad is conning and deceiving "Jannat." He very early in decided to keep up the lie for SK, which put "Jannat" in more danger. Then he continued his lies when it had no connection to SK, because he was falling for her. During all this time, he never bothered to act decently but had no problems taking shameless liberties with her (without her real consent) and bragged about his husband marks to his father.
Doesn't matter if this woman is married or not. He is basically keeping her in a kidnapped and brainwashed stare, which him wither having jo conscience or having bought into his own lies.
in one word he is a "Lier" and joke to army men ! I personally feel he is female version of Tanveer who also used to be masoom during initial times. Everything you said is absolutely correct. 

Edited by flora212 - 07 May 2015 at 6:59am

The following 17 member(s) liked the above post:

me.....LelyaHanie-secretlove-..PlayfulKiss..-GrilledCheese-fanrayaAGirlHasNoNameJShuklamicshyLaura..RaingoddessIntuitiveMrDarcyfanMs.Sherlocked...Tanu...KhatamKahani

micshy IF-Dazzler
micshy
micshy

Joined: 08 May 2010
Posts: 4745

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 6:59am | IP Logged
Originally posted by beekay1


***** DISCLAIMER *******

This is not a post that is bashing any group nor supporting any group. So please, may we have unbiased comments here. Whatever is said here is just my opinion not because hate or love any person or group. This post is not bashing actors. Its just an analysis of the story and the characters.


Is Sanam  still Aahil's legal wife?
Wasn't the marriage a contract marriage where Sanam had also signed the divorce papers?  So it means that Sanam is not legally married to Aahil. Aahil was to tie the knot with Sanam to make it official and that is when Sanam2 happened, right?  So rightfully Sanam2 is Aahil's legal wife.

I am a silent reader in this forum at most times and I am confused with the posts that bash Shaad saying that he is wrong in doing what he is doing...using Sanam's memory loss to "his" benefit. But is he using her memory loss to his benefit or is he doing it for for the security of two nations. He is just fulfilling his duty as a soldier. Sure he fell in love but he has not taken advantage of Sanam physically...as in enforcing husbandly-wifely duties until now. He is just in protect-mode as he knows her life is in danger. He also made her wear the burkha to ensure her safety.

I thought the Pak section was quite interesting and quite liked it... the reason is that it brought to my mind what our army, navy, air force personals have to endure out there in the battlefield... They sometimes have to suppress their conscience and do what is right for the country and not one individual or themselves. They have to even forget family commitments (he went against his father and aunt). Sure he fell in love with Jannat eventually, but can any person control an emotion called love?

I don't think Shaad even knows that Jannat(Sanam) is married? Does he?  Shaad saved Sanam from being killed by claiming her as his wife Jannat and as I recall he was also quite insistent that Jannat goes her own way after that till he realized that she had valuable information. He did feel guilty but it was his sense of duty that made him do "wrong". 

Was it really "wrong"? Wasn't he thinking of the safety of two nations and that's millions and millions of lives to save instead of one and his conscience? 

I quite liked it that 4lions, Gul in their own illogical way honored our men out there fighting for our safety. I do admit that it could have been done better...  

Isn't Aahil the one, who is in the wrong here? He's legally married to one but pursuing another. I'm not talking about love coz love does not give us the right to do wrong. Shouldn't he first work on divorcing Sanam2 before he runs after Sanam?

I'm just looking at this logically... 


Have a great day




Very neutrally trying to put my perspective ... 

Just trying to give an example, When Zoyaan happened, that nikaah happened out of Zoya's choice, here again A girl is being forced into a relationship out of her will ( n here out of her marriage too) it makes it even more despisable for me  as an audience ... I blamed both Ayaan n Asad during that track, here y should Shaad be not blamed,   In Zoyaan Zoya had a bit if her choice, while Jannat who is amnesic doeznot have a choice in this matter, shes living in a delusion n then why do he have to call her wife , why could not he say Sister ... Thers no justification to him being calling her his wife only to save her from the mob. N then continuing with the same pretense...  Im sorry but i never got this "saving two nations" theory, how will he save 2 nations by keeping a woman who sounds even more suspicious his wife n then trusting her blindly., 

As KK n nafs have already replied n Sanam herself made it clear to Sanam 2 n the audience as well that he n Aahil are legally married so i wont go there 


Edited by micshy - 07 May 2015 at 7:06am

The following 18 member(s) liked the above post:

NoLifeme.....Hanie-secretlove-PrettYSmile..PlayfulKiss..AGirlHasNoNameJShuklasimran_singh_24RaingoddessLaura..Ms.Sherlocked...Tanu...IntuitiveMrDarcyfanadventure_gurlflora212KhatamKahani

zynia890 Senior Member
zynia890
zynia890

Joined: 10 April 2014
Posts: 985

Posted: 07 May 2015 at 7:03am | IP Logged
Yes she surely is...sanam is aahils wife...and shad presents jannat as his wife... though jannat and sanam are same person but jannat doesn't exist...once she regains her memory she will remember she is of course sanam aaahilraza Ibrahim ( getting BG of how KVB says this)

The following 19 member(s) liked the above post:

NoLifeLelyaHanie-secretlove--GrilledCheese-..PlayfulKiss..AGirlHasNoNameJShuklamicshysimran_singh_24RaingoddessLaura.....Tanu...Ms.SherlockedIntuitiveMrDarcyfanadventure_gurlflora212KhatamKahani

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
New sanam gets ready to kill sanam in Pakistan - pinkvilla

Author: Az07   Replies: 0   Views: 799

Az07 0 799 02 April 2015 at 2:17am by Az07
How can new sanam say sanam naukrani?

2 3

Author: Forumlicious   Replies: 20   Views: 2930

Forumlicious 20 2930 06 February 2015 at 8:05am by tejaswie
Qubool Hai | Sanam Discovers Sanam and Aahil in Bed

Author: flora212   Replies: 3   Views: 1347

flora212 3 1347 29 January 2015 at 3:27am by Lovenarbhi
Spoiler: Tanveer saves Sanam from Sanam 2

Author: HeavenlyBliss.   Replies: 9   Views: 3199

HeavenlyBliss. 9 3199 27 December 2014 at 12:57pm by Sanjhari
Sanam Sanam Sanam :'(

2 3

Author: flora212   Replies: 22   Views: 4029

flora212 22 4029 27 October 2014 at 3:53pm by fanraya

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index