Do Kajol and SRK deserve any Filmfare Best Actor award? - Page 3

Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by Chippeshwini


Shocking, many of these

Abhishek defo deserved it over SRK for Guru

Word! I personally thought that was Abhi's career best. 
Posted: 8 years ago


Kajol



1995 Kajol - Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge as Simran Singh
Madhuri Dixit - Raja as Madhu Garewal
Madhuri Dixit - Yaraana as Lalita
Manisha Koirala - Akele Hum Akele Tum as Kiran Kumar
Urmila Matondkar - Rangeela as Mili Joshi

1998 Kajol - Kuch Kuch Hota Hai as Anjali Sharma
Kajol - Dushman as Sonia / Naina Saigal
Kajol - Pyaar To Hona Hi Tha as Sanjana
Manisha Koirala - Dil Se.. as Meghna
Urmila Matondkar - Satya as Vidya

2001 Kajol - Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham... as Anjali Sharma
Ameesha Patel - Gadar: Ek Prem Katha as Sakina
Kareena Kapoor - Asoka as Kaurwaki
Karisma Kapoor - Zubeidaa as Zubeida Begum
Tabu - Chandni Bar as Mumtaz Ali Ansari


2006 Kajol - Fanaa as Zooni Ali Beg
Aishwarya Rai - Dhoom 2 as Sunehri
Bipasha Basu - Corporate as Nishiganda Dasgupta
Kareena Kapoor - Omkara as Dolly Mishra
Rani Mukerji - Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna as Maya Talwar


2010 Kajol - My Name is Khan as Mandira Khan
Aishwarya Rai - Guzaarish as Sofia D'Souza
Anushka Sharma - Band Baaja Baaraat as Shruti Kakkar
Kareena Kapoor - Golmaal 3 as Daboo
Vidya Balan - Ishqiya as Krishna Verma



srk


1993 Shahrukh Khan - Baazigar as Ajay Sharma/Vicky Malhotra
Aamir Khan - Hum Hain Rahi Pyar Ke as Rahul Malhotra
Govinda - Aankhen as Bunnu / Gulshan / Gaurishankar
Jackie Shroff - Gardish as Shiva P. Sathe
Sanjay Dutt - Khalnayak as Balaram Prasad

1995 Shahrukh Khan - Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge as Raj Malhotra
Aamir Khan - Rangeela as Munna
Ajay Devgan - Naajayaz as Jay Bakshi
Govinda - Coolie No. 1 as Raju
Salman Khan - Karan Arjun as Karan Singh

1997 Shahrukh Khan - Dil To Pagal Hai as Rahul
Anil Kapoor - Virasat as Shakti Thakur
Sunny Deol - Border as Major Kuldip Singh Chandpuri
Govinda - Deewana Mastana as Bunnu
Kamal Haasan - Chachi 420 as Jaiprakash Paswan / Laxmi Godbhole

1998 Shahrukh Khan - Kuch Kuch Hota Hai as Rahul Khanna
Aamir Khan - Ghulam as Siddharth Marathe
Ajay Devgan - Zakhm as Ajay R. Desai
Govinda - Bade Miyan Chote Miyan as Pyare Mohan / Chotey Miyan
Salman Khan - Pyaar Kiya To Darna Kya as Suraj Khanna

2002 Shahrukh Khan - Devdas as Devdas Mukherjee
Ajay Devgan - Company as Mallik
Amitabh Bachchan - Kaante as Yashvardhan 'Major' Rampal
Bobby Deol - Humraaz as Raj Singhania
Vivek Oberoi - Saathiya as Aditya Sehgal

2004 Shahrukh Khan - Swades as Mohan Bhargav
Shahrukh Khan - Main Hoon Na as Major Ram Prasad Sharma
Shahrukh Khan - Veer-Zaara as Veer Pratap Singh
Amitabh Bachchan - Khakee as Anant Kumar Shrivastav
Hrithik Roshan - Lakshya as Karan Shergill

2007 Shahrukh Khan - Chak De! India as Coach Kabir Khan
Shahrukh Khan - Om Shanti Om as Om Prakash Makhija / Om Kapoor
Abhishek Bachchan - Guru as Gurukant Desai
Akshay Kumar - Namastey London as Arjun Singh
Darsheel Safary - Taare Zameen Par as Ishaan Awasthi
Shahid Kapoor - Jab We Met as Aditya Kashyap

2010 Shahrukh Khan - My Name Is Khan as Rizwan Khan
Ajay Devgan - Once Upon a Time in Mumbaai as Sultan Mirza
Hrithik Roshan - Guzaarish as Ethan Mascarenhas
Salman Khan - Dabangg as Chulbul Pandey
Ranbir Kapoor - Raajneeti as Samar Pratap Singh

SRK didn't deserve award for DTPH, KKHH, Devdas, OMO. I wud certainly for for Hrithik in Lakhshay over SRK in swades. Lakshay is so underrated. it was such a realistic type of movie. a boy with no ambition, goofing around and then set a target in battlefield and achieve it. SRK deserves for CDI. though that year all of them were really gud but CDI was one really deserving one. 
Posted: 8 years ago
I think kajol deserved it for all the movies she got.Maybe she was not that good in MNIK but saying that gidya should have received the award instead is not right.Anyways vidya has got awards which others deserved so its ok if she didn't get one award.
Seeing the contemporaries Srk shouldn't have received an award for dtph,swades and guru.
Posted: 8 years ago
SRK definitely deserved it for CDI and Swades. I think both deserved it for DDLJ too. At that time it was something different. 
Posted: 8 years ago
Most undeserving was SRK's Critics Award for Mohabattein in 2001. đŸ˜† Edited by .Hajmola. - 8 years ago
Posted: 8 years ago
Kajol definitely deserved for Kuch Kuch Hota hai and Fanna
She won for DDLJ because that was a whole big revolution! You know, a game changing film!
She in a way deserved for that film.

Also you should realize the difference btw POPULAR and CRITICS award Filmfare! For former, performance needs to be strong and popular and film should be known! Critics award is given to performance that has been remotely unknown!
So with that perspective its justified!

Her win for MNIK was totally bogus (though I wished for the same in a way)
Posted: 8 years ago
There is a reason why Awards in India are bogus and a laughing stock. A lot people dont seem to get it even here.
You give the award to the best acting performance not how gamechanging the said role is.

Did RDJ win an oscar for Iron-Man??

Or even better examples...
Did Harrison Ford for StarWars, Indiana Jones or Blade Runner?? Though imo he desrved nominations for Raiders and Blade Runner and atleast one win.
Did Elijah win for LOTR??

Find me more game changing, impactful or Iconic roles. You cant.

That is why Oscars abd the Globes are credible.
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by -Arsal-


There is a reason why Awards in India are bogus and a laughing stock. A lot people dont seem to get it even here.
You give the award to the best acting performance not how gamechanging the said role is.

Did RDJ win an oscar for Iron-Man??

Or even better examples...
Did Harrison Ford for StarWars, Indiana Jones or Blade Runner?? Though imo he desrved nominations for Raiders and Blade Runner and atleast one win.
Did Elijah win for LOTR??

Find me more game changing, impactful or Iconic roles. You cant.

That is why Oscars abd the Globes are credible.

DDLJ was iconic
KKHH was iconic
so you agree that those films deserved the awards? (for me they do)

Right now we might seem to think that those films were chessy, not deserving of awards because such films are too common these days BUT THEN those films were something new, something different!
So Kajol and SRK deserved award for those films
Posted: 8 years ago
Originally posted by GundayVedant



DDLJ was iconic
KKHH was iconic
so you agree that those films deserved the awards? (for me they do)

Right now we might seem to think that those films were chessy, not deserving of awards because such films are too common these days BUT THEN those films were something new, something different!
So Kajol and SRK deserved award for those films


No they didnt. Simply becuase the performaces were nowhere near others those year.

When I said Harrison deseved those award, I meant that he want spectacular in both movies. Terrific performances.

Being an Iconic movie has nothing to do with acting.

KKHH is not iconic. it has already failed the test of time miserably.
Posted: 8 years ago
And I by no means am comparing DDLJ or all these movies to the brilliance of Indy, Starwars, LOTR.

Trust me I know, there couldn't be a bigger insult to the latter if I tried.


Related Topics

doc-text Topics pencil Author stackexchange Replies eye Views clock Last Post Reply
Bollywood Blind:Male Actor in love with another political actor

pencil MrChatVsNorway   stackexchange 46   eye 3013

MrChatVsNorway 46 3013 7 days ago blue-ice.1
Pair up bollywood actor/actress with Pakistani actor

pencil priya185   stackexchange 6   eye 305

priya185 6 305 23 days ago RaniPreityAish
Now it’s Srk vs Srk

pencil Bekind   stackexchange 32   eye 2205

Bekind 32 2205 3 months ago Blueberry94
Srk blocks someone on twitter during ask srk &replies to another

pencil wat_up   stackexchange 13   eye 1662

wat_up 13 1662 4 months ago wat_up
"best" or "most popular"? FF best actor awards

pencil Clochette   stackexchange 37   eye 1355

Clochette 37 1355 1 months ago Maroonporsche

Topic Info

25 Participants 35 Replies 7915Views

Topic started by Quilt

Last replied by BollyBoy

loader
loader
up-open TOP