Saravanan Meenatchi

India-Forums

   
Saravanan Meenatchi
Saravanan Meenatchi

Saravanan Meenashi Updates & Discussions (Page 115)

.NJ. IF-Sizzlerz
.NJ.
.NJ.

Joined: 28 September 2007
Posts: 17956

Posted: 26 January 2016 at 9:13pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by sonr

What's the difference between what's going on now and witchcraft. Instead of casting a spell, the director caused an amnesia to make Meenatchi do what she didn't want to do to begin with. This is BAD. Kuyila pidichu koondil adaichu paada sollukira ulaham. Now she started singing to their tune.

She kept herself pure physically until this amnesia business. She stayed true and confessed her heart's commitment to her love up until the accident. Now this witchcraft (amnesia) is horrible. When her memory returns, she is going to feel defiled, intruded, desecrated, profaned, violated, etc. What will she do if she loses her virginity to Vettaiyan and then her memory returns, and finds herself still in love with Saravanan? I was okay up until she started touching him. Now she is no longer pure, but defiled.

First the director spoiled Meenatchi's true love. Now he is spoiling Her chastity. What more does she have to lose?


what chastity are you talking about, meenakshi is married to vettaiyan, both have full rights on each other...she may forget that, but fact remains...

how come question about chastity and purity didn't come into your mind when meenakshi was longing to be with someone else and not her husband...

first time I'm seeing a fuss over a wife touching her very own husband, that too to apply medicine out of guilty conscience...LOL


The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

lulu1243hopper_ocean.Starbucks.-Swetha-

.NJ. IF-Sizzlerz
.NJ.
.NJ.

Joined: 28 September 2007
Posts: 17956

Posted: 26 January 2016 at 9:19pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by ShankarVel

Originally posted by migan

Originally posted by .Starbucks.

Originally posted by .NJ.


^...sorry pa, enakku pidikave pidikale...I hope director doesn't go that way...

you are talking about the theme...but what is in the theme when the character went missing...before anything happens, let us VM fans enjoy what is shown, please don't spoil the fun...for me, if meenakshi marries saravanan and settles with him I will quit this show for good instead of writing 10 reasons why Meenakshi should select Vettaiyan...

see, V will remain as a hero with or without M,and Saravanan will always remain as a second man with or without M...


I second thisBig smile



3rd this.Big smile


Yes guys I can understand... U guys are fans of Vetaiyyan I think... S everyone have their own opinion on the show.. I respect that.

Saravanan can come or not, meenakshi may reunite with him or not. But I unable to bear these days meenakshi starts loving vettaiyan in the same way she started with saro...



so you mean to say meenakshi should remain single without love and not loving anyone even if saravanan is dead...

not many remember saravanan meenakshi story today...the story central point is VM...even is saravanan comes back, he will remain as a second man in her life and love...

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

lulu1243hopper_ocean-Swetha-

sonr Groupbie
sonr
sonr

Joined: 27 October 2015
Posts: 164

Posted: 27 January 2016 at 7:16am | IP Logged
Originally posted by .NJ.

Originally posted by sonr

What's the difference between what's going on now and witchcraft. Instead of casting a spell, the director caused an amnesia to make Meenatchi do what she didn't want to do to begin with. This is BAD. Kuyila pidichu koondil adaichu paada sollukira ulaham. Now she started singing to their tune.

She kept herself pure physically until this amnesia business. She stayed true and confessed her heart's commitment to her love up until the accident. Now this witchcraft (amnesia) is horrible. When her memory returns, she is going to feel defiled, intruded, desecrated, profaned, violated, etc. What will she do if she loses her virginity to Vettaiyan and then her memory returns, and finds herself still in love with Saravanan? I was okay up until she started touching him. Now she is no longer pure, but defiled.

First the director spoiled Meenatchi's true love. Now he is spoiling Her chastity. What more does she have to lose?


what chastity are you talking about, meenakshi is married to vettaiyan, both have full rights on each other...she may forget that, but fact remains...

how come question about chastity and purity didn't come into your mind when meenakshi was longing to be with someone else and not her husband...

first time I'm seeing a fuss over a wife touching her very own husband, that too to apply medicine out of guilty conscience...LOL




That marriage was forced. Though her hands weren't physically tied, the circumstances handcuffed her. In early January in Techsatish, someone wrote an excellent article on how Meenatchi's hands were tied on the wedding day. Vettaiyan understood that and waited for her permission to touch her. Using Meenatchi's current condition to touch her is abuse. Right now Meenatchi has the knowledge of a small child in an adult body. There is no husband wife relationship right now because she has no knowledge of it. In all the western countries, touching anybody, including your wife, without her permission is considered harassment. Recently I read the news, in North America an Iranian went to jail for 4 years for sexually harassing his wife. In Meenatchi's case, since she is like a child mentally, it would be a case for under aged harassment. This ia a very serious crime. Parent's should take care of this matter.

Imagine, she comes to her self one day and find herself all used up, which she would have never done with her right mind. She can take the guy to courts. Some psychologist would have to estimate the mental age. Sri Devi had an age of 7 year old in Moonram Pirai because that's all she remembered. I  don't know what would be Meenatchi's. She is definitely acting without any common sense. She used to be very clear in her thoughts and sensible, and a very loving person.
sonr Groupbie
sonr
sonr

Joined: 27 October 2015
Posts: 164

Posted: 27 January 2016 at 7:42am | IP Logged
Originally posted by .NJ.

Originally posted by ShankarVel

Originally posted by migan

Originally posted by .Starbucks.

Originally posted by .NJ.


^...sorry pa, enakku pidikave pidikale...I hope director doesn't go that way...

you are talking about the theme...but what is in the theme when the character went missing...before anything happens, let us VM fans enjoy what is shown, please don't spoil the fun...for me, if meenakshi marries saravanan and settles with him I will quit this show for good instead of writing 10 reasons why Meenakshi should select Vettaiyan...

see, V will remain as a hero with or without M,and Saravanan will always remain as a second man with or without M...


I second thisBig smile



3rd this.Big smile


Yes guys I can understand... U guys are fans of Vetaiyyan I think... S everyone have their own opinion on the show.. I respect that.

Saravanan can come or not, meenakshi may reunite with him or not. But I unable to bear these days meenakshi starts loving vettaiyan in the same way she started with saro...



so you mean to say meenakshi should remain single without love and not loving anyone even if saravanan is dead...

not many remember saravanan meenakshi story today...the story central point is VM...even is saravanan comes back, he will remain as a second man in her life and love...



I think it's better that she remains single than falling for the one she hated and dreaded to be around. Like Appatha once told Tamil, "If you don't like Saravanan, get her someone better than him, not Vettaiyan." The current story central might be VM, but it sucks. Though the director tried to prop V up by making everybody else bad, it still doesn't work. He even made the most loving father Tamil, loving mother and brother to be so bad. It was a role model family in the whole town. Saravanan came in, a notch above them. He impressed her with his love, beating her father's love. Meenatchi said, "I thought nobody will love me like my father, but here is Saravanan."

V stood too tiny in front of Tamil's love and Saravanan's love. Just to prop up a nobody like V, a guy without education, job, social status, or good manners; the director made well established, educated, good loving people look bad. I mean EVERYBODY bad. That's why the story sucks. I used to think he is a great director, but now with his current move. he lost all my respect.

When people were leaving Vijay TV, Kavin's commitment to stay with them is probably the reason, he decided to prop him up. He could have done it in a different show, not this one. The way he is going about doing it is horrible. He has slaughtered the characters. He has destroyed the story. Meenatchi's character is compromised. Only to satisfy this one man's one sided love, and his desire to have this girl at all cost.
.Starbucks. IF-Sizzlerz
.Starbucks.
.Starbucks.

Joined: 07 March 2014
Posts: 15197

Posted: 27 January 2016 at 8:58am | IP Logged
^ If her love was so true and pure for Saravanan, then she should have never fell for Vettaiyan now (after the amnesia incident) in the first place. It is her mind that went through memory loss, not her heart right?

But she did anyway. Which only proves that her she developed love for Vettaiyan long back. When she is able to accept it now without hesitations, she wasn't able to before. So let's say she gets her memory back and she goes back to her Saravanan story, she will never be able to forget the times that she was actually happy with Vettaiyan when she lost her memory. Instead of being half-true to Saravanan, she can be full true to Vettaiyan. Again, that won't happen immediately as this is a serial at the end of the day and it needs to run for several episodes. And in another case, if she forgets her memory loss period after regaining her memory like Moondram Pirai, it wouldn't make sense to have shown this entire track in the first place. And even so, she already started to love Vettaiyan before losing her memory, and that will be the continuation point of their story once again.

And there is nothing wrong in having a second love, and it is not fair to degrade Vettaiyan's character like you are doing by agreeing to Apatha's statement about anyone other than Vettaiyan. In fact, his character is more realistic than Saravanan who was really only a fantasy character. In SM1, Saro's character was realistic and in SM2, they portrayed Saravanan as a mahaan. To be honest, I feel more of a connection with Vettaiyan's character and SM1 Saravanan character, rather than SM2 Saravanan.

Finally, I think this Meenakshi is more sensible and clear in her head than the one before the amnesia incident. That's because she seriously lost her clarity on her love for Saravanan soon after her wedding with Vettaiyan. And there is nothing wrong with that. On the other hand, Vettaiyan was always clear about his love for Meenakshi, there was no one else for whom he was debating with his feelings.

There is a saying - "If you really like something and you see another thing and you start liking that as well, go for the second one because, if you truly liked the first one, you wouldn't have even paid heed to the second one."

So, for me, it is always Vettaiyan and Meenakshi. That would provide the most realistic end to the story.


The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

lulu1243ZEESXY.NJ.-Swetha-

lulu1243 Newbie
lulu1243
lulu1243

Joined: 14 January 2016
Posts: 21

Posted: 27 January 2016 at 12:03pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by .Starbucks.

^ If her love was so true and pure for Saravanan, then she should have never fell for Vettaiyan now (after the amnesia incident) in the first place. It is her mind that went through memory loss, not her heart right?

But she did anyway. Which only proves that her she developed love for Vettaiyan long back. When she is able to accept it now without hesitations, she wasn't able to before. So let's say she gets her memory back and she goes back to her Saravanan story, she will never be able to forget the times that she was actually happy with Vettaiyan when she lost her memory. Instead of being half-true to Saravanan, she can be full true to Vettaiyan. Again, that won't happen immediately as this is a serial at the end of the day and it needs to run for several episodes. And in another case, if she forgets her memory loss period after regaining her memory like Moondram Pirai, it wouldn't make sense to have shown this entire track in the first place. And even so, she already started to love Vettaiyan before losing her memory, and that will be the continuation point of their story once again.

And there is nothing wrong in having a second love, and it is not fair to degrade Vettaiyan's character like you are doing by agreeing to Apatha's statement about anyone other than Vettaiyan. In fact, his character is more realistic than Saravanan who was really only a fantasy character. In SM1, Saro's character was realistic and in SM2, they portrayed Saravanan as a mahaan. To be honest, I feel more of a connection with Vettaiyan's character and SM1 Saravanan character, rather than SM2 Saravanan.

Finally, I think this Meenakshi is more sensible and clear in her head than the one before the amnesia incident. That's because she seriously lost her clarity on her love for Saravanan soon after her wedding with Vettaiyan. And there is nothing wrong with that. On the other hand, Vettaiyan was always clear about his love for Meenakshi, there was no one else for whom he was debating with his feelings.

There is a saying - "If you really like something and you see another thing and you start liking that as well, go for the second one because, if you truly liked the first one, you wouldn't have even paid heed to the second one."

So, for me, it is always Vettaiyan and Meenakshi. That would provide the most realistic end to the story.



Agree with u 100%! Today's episode was kind of boring without Vettaiyan. Hope they have him in tomorrow's. 

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

.NJ..Starbucks.-Swetha-

.NJ. IF-Sizzlerz
.NJ.
.NJ.

Joined: 28 September 2007
Posts: 17956

Posted: 27 January 2016 at 5:59pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by sonr

Originally posted by .NJ.

Originally posted by sonr

What's the difference between what's going on now and witchcraft. Instead of casting a spell, the director caused an amnesia to make Meenatchi do what she didn't want to do to begin with. This is BAD. Kuyila pidichu koondil adaichu paada sollukira ulaham. Now she started singing to their tune.

She kept herself pure physically until this amnesia business. She stayed true and confessed her heart's commitment to her love up until the accident. Now this witchcraft (amnesia) is horrible. When her memory returns, she is going to feel defiled, intruded, desecrated, profaned, violated, etc. What will she do if she loses her virginity to Vettaiyan and then her memory returns, and finds herself still in love with Saravanan? I was okay up until she started touching him. Now she is no longer pure, but defiled.

First the director spoiled Meenatchi's true love. Now he is spoiling Her chastity. What more does she have to lose?


what chastity are you talking about, meenakshi is married to vettaiyan, both have full rights on each other...she may forget that, but fact remains...

how come question about chastity and purity didn't come into your mind when meenakshi was longing to be with someone else and not her husband...

first time I'm seeing a fuss over a wife touching her very own husband, that too to apply medicine out of guilty conscience...LOL




That marriage was forced. Though her hands weren't physically tied, the circumstances handcuffed her. In early January in Techsatish, someone wrote an excellent article on how Meenatchi's hands were tied on the wedding day. Vettaiyan understood that and waited for her permission to touch her. Using Meenatchi's current condition to touch her is abuse. Right now Meenatchi has the knowledge of a small child in an adult body. There is no husband wife relationship right now because she has no knowledge of it. In all the western countries, touching anybody, including your wife, without her permission is considered harassment. Recently I read the news, in North America an Iranian went to jail for 4 years for sexually harassing his wife. In Meenatchi's case, since she is like a child mentally, it would be a case for under aged harassment. This ia a very serious crime. Parent's should take care of this matter.

Imagine, she comes to her self one day and find herself all used up, which she would have never done with her right mind. She can take the guy to courts. Some psychologist would have to estimate the mental age. Sri Devi had an age of 7 year old in Moonram Pirai because that's all she remembered. I  don't know what would be Meenatchi's. She is definitely acting without any common sense. She used to be very clear in her thoughts and sensible, and a very loving person.



harassment, when did V harassed her? It was only meenakshi who came and apply ointment on him...secondly vettaiyan is unaware that M has lost her memory, he thinks she is falling for him...

let us see how he reacts when he gets to know M doesn't remember saravanan, if he continues getting close to her physically, then I'll agree with...if not, please take back your words!

Edited by .NJ. - 27 January 2016 at 5:59pm
hopper_ocean IF-Veteran Member
hopper_ocean
hopper_ocean

Joined: 23 May 2011
Posts: 22432

Posted: 28 January 2016 at 3:32am | IP Logged
I am sort of enjoying this weeks episodes yet at some point i feel bored Ermm Kind of feeling the story started to go back in a slow pace.
I feel meenashi is being what she always wanted to be deep down her heart. She had the feelings for V but she always thought its just a normal affection on her thai mama nu. This am saying cause Meenashi still seem to find herself not friendly with her family members. Its clear to see she hesitates while talking to them and there is no natural feeling. But with V she seem to be far more on comfort zone. Though she lost her memory i feel her heart knows who V is nu.

I think director is going to drag to much especially with this villan etc. One thing i am glad myna  knows the truth but i only hope she tells that to V. I dont want V goes on being happy thinking that M has accepted him fully nu. V is a very truthful person and i am very much sure that if he knows she lost her momery - he will maintain his distant. He surely does not seem to be the type of guy who will take advantage. 

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

lulu1243.Starbucks.-Swetha-

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
SM written updates 23-27 Feb monday updates

2

Author: hopper_ocean   Replies: 12   Views: 2180

hopper_ocean 12 2180 27 February 2015 at 8:48pm by hopper_ocean
Saravanan Meenashi promo 23th-27 th June

Author: hopper_ocean   Replies: 7   Views: 908

hopper_ocean 7 908 22 June 2014 at 11:48am by migan
saravanan Meenashi mansion

Author: hopper_ocean   Replies: 5   Views: 731

hopper_ocean 5 731 19 June 2014 at 8:56pm by hopper_ocean
Saravanan Meenashi Discussions 26 - 30 may

2 3 4 5

Author: .LovelyDreamer.   Replies: 35   Views: 3714

.LovelyDreamer. 35 3714 02 June 2014 at 10:37pm by nallammai
Saravanan Meenashi Discussions 05-10 May

2 3 4 5 6

Author: .LovelyDreamer.   Replies: 40   Views: 3841

.LovelyDreamer. 40 3841 11 May 2014 at 7:40pm by SatrupaKiAnami.

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Saravanan Meenatchi Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index