Jodha Akbar

India-Forums

   
Jodha Akbar
Jodha Akbar

ANARKALI :* (Page 5)

dushi123 Goldie
dushi123
dushi123

Joined: 21 December 2013
Posts: 1407

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 9:00am | IP Logged
Originally posted by myviewprem

Originally posted by dushi123

i love anarkali. i love salim. but m so sad whn i get to knw that this anarkali wasn't mentioned in jahangirnama. but y ? he mentioned his othr wives nd maan bhai jagat nd othr begums too.specially his second love noor.but salim y dint u mention anarkali in your jaha'nama.she was his first love na... atleast he cud hv told her something abt her na. y no any mughal chronicles or books dint mention her. ??? one traveller had told this salim anar tale. but u can't find it in any mughal chronicles.that means wS she a fictional character ???? uhuhuhu ... m so sad nw. i wanted to believe her as a real character. but y salim dint mention her ? y no in akbarnama? poor lady. jahangir how did u forget your first love ????? :/
 
I am not sure if anarkali is fact or fiction. If it is fiction its lasted 400 years is stunning
 
If it is a fact then Mughal books have done a great job of hiding truth
This is not new to Mughals they hid all undesirable acts well
Like Dara sikoh married a street singer and no mention of her in Mughal books her name was ranadil (Aurangzeb was also mad after her after dara sikoh was killed it seems and she refused his proposition)
Some other Mughal princes love story with commoners also concealed in history nicely no Mughal book ever speaks or talks of them too
Jehangirnama was written after he became emperor and he has left out all his life history before becoming king other than some mention of his siblings etc and honestly I can never imagine an emperor writing about his love affair in his autobiography because no king will want to say how he had a love affair and lost out on girl because his parents objected
Like that sahib jamal - his son parvez wife was a commoner Zain koka's neice and he did not mention about that also his fights with Akbar to marry her etc
Jehangirnama is an official book not a personal diary that he would have mentioned such things anyways
 
 

oh thank u for clearing my doubts.. 

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

myviewprem

ghalibmirza IF-Sizzlerz
ghalibmirza
ghalibmirza

Joined: 04 September 2012
Posts: 21295

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 9:00am | IP Logged
Originally posted by myviewprem

Originally posted by dushi123

i love anarkali. i love salim. but m so sad whn i get to knw that this anarkali wasn't mentioned in jahangirnama. but y ? he mentioned his othr wives nd maan bhai jagat nd othr begums too.specially his second love noor.but salim y dint u mention anarkali in your jaha'nama.she was his first love na... atleast he cud hv told her something abt her na. y no any mughal chronicles or books dint mention her. ??? one traveller had told this salim anar tale. but u can't find it in any mughal chronicles.that means wS she a fictional character ???? uhuhuhu ... m so sad nw. i wanted to believe her as a real character. but y salim dint mention her ? y no in akbarnama? poor lady. jahangir how did u forget your first love ????? :/
 
I am not sure if anarkali is fact or fiction. If it is fiction its lasted 400 years is stunning
 
If it is a fact then Mughal books have done a great job of hiding truth
This is not new to Mughals they hid all undesirable acts well
Like Dara sikoh married a street singer and no mention of her in Mughal books her name was ranadil (Aurangzeb was also mad after her after dara sikoh was killed it seems and she refused his proposition)
Some other Mughal princes love story with commoners also concealed in history nicely no Mughal book ever speaks or talks of them too
Jehangirnama was written after he became emperor and he has left out all his life history before becoming king other than some mention of his siblings etc and honestly I can never imagine an emperor writing about his love affair in his autobiography because no king will want to say how he had a love affair and lost out on girl because his parents objected
Like that sahib jamal - his son parvez wife was a commoner Zain koka's neice and he did not mention about that also his fights with Akbar to marry her etc
Jehangirnama is an official book not a personal diary that he would have mentioned such things anyways
 
 


i think salim had many affairs, and you maybe right in saying that affairs with commoners were not mentioned as the official biography will not go in details about personal stuff! fiction or not fiction but i really liked the way they showed in MEA..here in ektanama it looks fake!..anar was a dancer and not a hair dresserD'oh

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

dushi123jojaparijatstephhhAbHer_nehamyviewprem

myviewprem IF-Sizzlerz
myviewprem
myviewprem

Joined: 18 February 2010
Posts: 10145

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 9:12am | IP Logged
Originally posted by ghalibmirza

Originally posted by myviewprem

Originally posted by dushi123

i love anarkali. i love salim. but m so sad whn i get to knw that this anarkali wasn't mentioned in jahangirnama. but y ? he mentioned his othr wives nd maan bhai jagat nd othr begums too.specially his second love noor.but salim y dint u mention anarkali in your jaha'nama.she was his first love na... atleast he cud hv told her something abt her na. y no any mughal chronicles or books dint mention her. ??? one traveller had told this salim anar tale. but u can't find it in any mughal chronicles.that means wS she a fictional character ???? uhuhuhu ... m so sad nw. i wanted to believe her as a real character. but y salim dint mention her ? y no in akbarnama? poor lady. jahangir how did u forget your first love ????? :/
 
I am not sure if anarkali is fact or fiction. If it is fiction its lasted 400 years is stunning
 
If it is a fact then Mughal books have done a great job of hiding truth
This is not new to Mughals they hid all undesirable acts well
Like Dara sikoh married a street singer and no mention of her in Mughal books her name was ranadil (Aurangzeb was also mad after her after dara sikoh was killed it seems and she refused his proposition)
Some other Mughal princes love story with commoners also concealed in history nicely no Mughal book ever speaks or talks of them too
Jehangirnama was written after he became emperor and he has left out all his life history before becoming king other than some mention of his siblings etc and honestly I can never imagine an emperor writing about his love affair in his autobiography because no king will want to say how he had a love affair and lost out on girl because his parents objected
Like that sahib jamal - his son parvez wife was a commoner Zain koka's neice and he did not mention about that also his fights with Akbar to marry her etc
Jehangirnama is an official book not a personal diary that he would have mentioned such things anyways
 
 


i think salim had many affairs, and you maybe right in saying that affairs with commoners were not mentioned as the official biography will not go in details about personal stuff! fiction or not fiction but i really liked the way they showed in MEA..here in ektanama it looks fake!..anar was a dancer and not a hair dresserD'oh
 
Yes but affair is a different matter, love is a different thing. Shah jahan had affair with many after mumtaz died but he did not build a taj for them, same for many other kings. Affair is more about physical attraction or done with intention of removing loneliness or to prove points etc. Love is something that lasts till end and even after death. Love is not only about physical attraction its more of compatability and understanding and never wanes even after a person dies. You forget an affair after its over you do not forget love even after the person leaves or dies.
 
 

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

-Rema-

TriShakti IF-Dazzler
TriShakti
TriShakti

Joined: 08 June 2012
Posts: 4130

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 9:53am | IP Logged
Who cares if she was real or not..its not gng to make any difference in this 21st centuary..
I love to watch this Jodi onscreen n that's all I care.
Watching this show only for charming Ravi n Heena n their amazing chemistry as SaNar

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

SenpaiNOTICEME-Rema-

-DZ- IF-Achieverz
-DZ-
-DZ-

Joined: 18 April 2013
Posts: 201043

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 10:17am | IP Logged
Originally posted by myviewprem

Originally posted by dushi123

i love anarkali. i love salim. but m so sad whn i get to knw that this anarkali wasn't mentioned in jahangirnama. but y ? he mentioned his othr wives nd maan bhai jagat nd othr begums too.specially his second love noor.but salim y dint u mention anarkali in your jaha'nama.she was his first love na... atleast he cud hv told her something abt her na. y no any mughal chronicles or books dint mention her. ??? one traveller had told this salim anar tale. but u can't find it in any mughal chronicles.that means wS she a fictional character ???? uhuhuhu ... m so sad nw. i wanted to believe her as a real character. but y salim dint mention her ? y no in akbarnama? poor lady. jahangir how did u forget your first love ????? :/
 
I am not sure if anarkali is fact or fiction. If it is fiction its lasted 400 years is stunning
 
If it is a fact then Mughal books have done a great job of hiding truth
This is not new to Mughals they hid all undesirable acts well
Like Dara sikoh married a street singer and no mention of her in Mughal books her name was ranadil (Aurangzeb was also mad after her after dara sikoh was killed it seems and she refused his proposition)
Some other Mughal princes love story with commoners also concealed in history nicely no Mughal book ever speaks or talks of them too
Jehangirnama was written after he became emperor and he has left out all his life history before becoming king other than some mention of his siblings etc and honestly I can never imagine an emperor writing about his love affair in his autobiography because no king will want to say how he had a love affair and lost out on girl because his parents objected
Like that sahib jamal - his son parvez wife was a commoner Zain koka's neice and he did not mention about that also his fights with Akbar to marry her etc
Jehangirnama is an official book not a personal diary that he would have mentioned such things anyways
 
And regarding him finding new love I have seen even in 21st century after a great love failure people marrying and moving on in life. That does not mean they forgot their first love or do not care for them anymore. In india society is such that people always say parents are always right and kids who go against them for love are always treated like villan only and boycotted and treated and spoken badly about even decades after the incidents. They become villan for life for going against society norms and loving someone not of their class/caste/religion etc. In this society(even law) elders are always right and youngsters who go against norm are always wrong. So what option an person has? So good that Jehangir moved on in life and found another love even if it was much later in his 40s. And Jehangir love for nur jahan was not some young love based on attraction it was a mature love he knew nur jahan cannot become mother to his kid, he knew she is widow with a child and still went against society norms and married her.
    
 

wow Clap
-DZ- IF-Achieverz
-DZ-
-DZ-

Joined: 18 April 2013
Posts: 201043

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 10:19am | IP Logged
Originally posted by marshi

@zayaholic
Miss first learn to speak emperor Akbar name correctly
He was a great king and muz was a enigma and ur Salem was a drunken bas***d
U have no idea ABT akdha love 
Got it ur sanar love will start and end in kichad better stop ur nonsense and jalal spell it correctly and not bai jodha bai mallika e hindustan got it

wow what a languageClap
may be the mods can answer u better

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

TriShakti

marshi Goldie
marshi
marshi

Joined: 03 June 2014
Posts: 1076

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 10:23am | IP Logged
Originally posted by rima4ever

Originally posted by marshi

@zayaholic
Miss first learn to speak emperor Akbar name correctly
He was a great king and muz was a enigma and ur Salem was a drunken bas***d
U have no idea ABT akdha love 
Got it ur sanar love will start and end in kichad better stop ur nonsense and jalal spell it correctly and not bai jodha bai mallika e hindustan got it

wow what a languageClap
may be the mods can answer u better
I give a damn did we speak I'll ABT sanar now no name and she should know the truth Salem was that a and how dare she call muz bai 
And rima I hate that when someone without reason brings akdha and humiliate u get it I think

The following 7 member(s) liked the above post:

mehaksingh13jojaparijat._.Bubbles._._akdha.forever_stephhhGOTforever.GreekPrincess.

dushi123 Goldie
dushi123
dushi123

Joined: 21 December 2013
Posts: 1407

Posted: 01 January 2015 at 10:27am | IP Logged
Originally posted by rima4ever

Originally posted by marshi

@zayaholic
Miss first learn to speak emperor Akbar name correctly
He was a great king and muz was a enigma and ur Salem was a drunken bas***d
U have no idea ABT akdha love 
Got it ur sanar love will start and end in kichad better stop ur nonsense and jalal spell it correctly and not bai jodha bai mallika e hindustan got it

wow what a languageClap
may be the mods can answer u better

psycho akbar and bai wasn't their real names. atleast salikali fans shud respect real characters. , ,  ,but y mods in ma thread rima???...

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

mehaksingh13jojaparijatstephhhAbHer_nehaGOTforever

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
salim-anarkali v/s jodha-akbar

2

Author: malvikatiwari96   Replies: 15   Views: 2395

malvikatiwari96 15 2395 04 January 2015 at 9:52am by LoonyLuna
link for downloading salim anarkali tune...

Author: Pretty_me   Replies: 9   Views: 4682

Pretty_me 9 4682 29 December 2014 at 2:56am by Pretty_me
Saleem Anarkali jodi name = SaNar wins

2 3 4 5

Author: overactor   Replies: 33   Views: 2993

overactor 33 2993 28 December 2014 at 2:59am by aisha.....11110
Saleem Anarkali first meeting <3

2 3 4

Author: overactor   Replies: 25   Views: 2726

overactor 25 2726 25 December 2014 at 9:48pm by TriShakti

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Jodha Akbar Topic Index

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index