Mahakumbh

India-Forums

   
Mahakumbh
Mahakumbh

Mahakumbh 5-8: Tangled skeins

sashashyam IF-Sizzlerz
sashashyam
sashashyam

Joined: 04 January 2012
Posts: 13119

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 5:12am | IP Logged

Folks,

As I sat back and thought over the last week's four episodes, the tangled skeins were not just in the tale, but inside my head as  well. Normally, in any fictional narrative, there  is a recurrent, central thread, a leit motif,  which is the core, the keystone, of the whole structure. It could be doomed love, it could be revenge,  it could be a mystery to be unravelled. But here, in our tale, there are many leit motifs,  all tangled with each other, making  it impossible to judge either which is going to be the predominant one, or where these criss-crossed strands are going to take the tale, and us the viewers as well.

Two recurrent themes: So I looked about to see if, even amidst this profusion of themes, we could identify just two, which would be likely to stay with us, at least for some time to come.

One suggests itself readily - the bonds that have no name, but are yet far stronger than those of blood or tradition. The other, though in a more restricted and limited sense as yet, is of retribution for evil, whether at the hands of the righteous and the  innocent, or at the hands of still greater evil.  Let us see  how these themes played out during the last week.

Take 5: Then I intend to give you  my own Take 5 for the week, my choices for the 5  most arresting scenes we saw. Your own ratings and choices might be quite different, but that is the fun of the whole exercise! But to begin,

Benaam rishtey:  that are far stronger that those of blood.

Maimuyi & Rudra:  The first, and the strongest, is of course the visceral bond that has developed, over 12 long years, between Maimuyi and the  bachuwa who had sneaked into a corner of her arid heart against her will and almost without her knowledge, and had then proceeded to take it over so completely that now, for her, the sun rises and sets on her Rudra.

Seema Biswas brings this total emotional dependence alive onscreen with a sureness of touch that tugs at your heartstrings. Watch her brimming over with maternal pride as she watches Rudra making an unexpectedly impressive debut as Lord Rama in the Dussehra Ramleela.  As she dresses him and does his make up with infinite tenderness and joy. When  she does his aarti  and cheers him on from the sidelines of the procession. Her eyes glow with an inner light, the tired lines in the worn out face  are erased for an instant as  a tide of joy wells up from the core of her being.

Watch her fear for this beloved child overcome  her natural goodness as she warns Rudra, in no uncertain terms, not to engage in such risky ventures as saving the jyotishi  Tiwari from the deep waters in which he was drowning. And her agonizing over the danger to Rudra posed by the garuda chin on his back, which fills her with a nameless foreboding.

Watch the fear that surfaces in her mind, like a snake rearing its hood, whenever he is gone  for  a while without her knowing where he has  gone -and the sharp whiplash in her  Kahan gaya tha tu?? -  as when Rudra returns after having located Udiya Baba's  wife and brought her with him, in order to make  the passing easier  for his guiltridden soul.  

The most evocative of all, watch Maimuyi's face as the bits and pieces of  Ravana effigy crash in a shower of  burning embers all around Rudra and Udiya Baba. She has been crying herself hoarse trying to stop Rudra,  but now all those screams seem to have been congealed into  the still agony, the frozen despair  in her eyes and her face. It reminded me of Edvard Munch's iconic painting,  The Scream.

Udiya Baba & Rudra:  This bond is  of a slightly different kind,   and not only because  nothing can equal maternal love for its  tenderness and unconditional protectiveness. Rather, it is a substitute relationship, though it is in no way lacking in strength.

Udiya Baba loves Rudra, genuinely and deeply,  and is ready to die to save him. But this is largely, as we now learn, because  this unknown boy has, in Udiya Baba's eyes, become a substitute for his lost Bishu. Not just that, by saving Rudra from drowning during the 1989 Kumbh, Udiya Baba feels in some way liberated from the festering guilt due to his inability to save his own small son in a similar situation. Feels that Lord Vishwanath has forgiven him for that  failing, which he himself has come to see as a crime, a sin, on his  part.

Thus, every time he imparts a bit of wisdom to Rudra,  he is actually talking to the son he lost so cruelly. When he tells Rudra  that to go forward fast towards one's goal, like the arrow from the bow,  one first has to pull back, like the pratyancha  or bowstring has to be pulled back, strongly and with unwavering focus, and  gazes in delight as Rudra follows his instructions, it is Bishu whom Udiya Baba sees, not Rudra.

When he learns about the bomb planted under Rudra's chariot by Pandey's goon, he is determined that this time, history is not  going to repeat itself. There  is no way  he is going to let Rudra die, no way he is going to fail Rudra the way he failed his Bishu.

Whence the  desperate race against time to get Rudra off that doomed  chariot before the bomb explodes. His breath sobbing is his overworked lungs,  gasping from the strain  of running so hard at his age, bent over double as his muscles seize up and tug at his ribs - and Robin Das is fantastic in the raw physicality he brings to this scene - unable to make Rudra hear his warnings over the  all pervading din, Udiya Baba still succeeds  in saving Rudra a second time, even  if it is, this time, at the cost of his own life.  For with this, he has, in his own eyes, redeemed himself, both in the eyes of the Lord and in his own.

If Udiya Baba did have to go so soon, and I for one am very unhappy about it, there could have been no better, no prouder exit for him. And with  the wife, whom he had abandoned in a paroxysm of guilt and grief, now coming to him and very likely forgiving him,  he will go to his Maker in peace at last.

Rudra: For Rudra, these two are by now  his whole world. The ones with whom he feels secure. The ones who have eased, at least in part, the pain of the loss of his parents and his home. For now  Varanasi and the  Manikarnika Ghat  are his home, and  Maimuyi and Udiya Baba are his family.

The loss of Udiya Baba is thus, for Rudra, a kind of replay  of 1989,when he lost his real father. But now at least he has  his Maimuyi,  his sheet anchor. And while he is bound to miss the  wise mentor that Udiya Baba had become for him,  he will at least have the satisfaction that he was able to ease him passing by  freeing him of years of festering guilt  about Bishu and his wife. This  can be seen  in Rudra's eyes as he explains his absence to Maimuyi, they are at once clouded  with the grief of anticipated loss and   lit up  with  a sense of achievement .

Shivanand & Kuba,  and the boy's  mother:  This is a relationship into which all the three  have been pitchforked by Fate, but it none the less strong for that. Nor is it less deep  because it is rooted not in  love,   for a child or for a man or a woman, but in humanism,  and the courage needed to save another, even a stranger,  who is in danger, even if this means endangering oneself.  

It is thus more abstract, but just as admirable, and just as heartwarming.

The proxy son: For Shivanand,  the alert, energetic, resourceful and good-hearted Kuba is a sort of substitute the son he had lost 12 years ago, and he sees the kid Rudra in him right from the time the  boy approaches him as he lies on  the road. He treats him as he would have treated Rudra,  and his protectiveness towards the  boy makes him urge Kuba's mother to break free of her shackles, for the child's sake. To prevent his psyche from becoming warped over time, so much so that he begins to believe that Dard denewale ki jeet aur dard sehnewale ki haar hoti hai.

When he plays with Kuba on the bridge, it is Rudra whom he is lifting in his arms and  whirling around. And when he bargains with Grierson,  bartering his surrender for the safety of Kuba and his mother, it is his surrogate child whom he is saving. I feel that in the  future,  a grown  up Kuba will have an independent relationship with Shivanand, but for now, he is a proxy for Rudra, and cared for as such.

A human bond: Shivanand's relationship with Kuba's mother is rooted in twin emotions: profound gratitude  to her for having given him shelter at a crucial time at great risk to herself,  and later helped him  is  so many vital ways, and the linked desire to  save her and her son from the hell they inhabit at present.  It is not a romantic relationship in any sense, nor is it  a platonic  one. Both these need a personal  angle to the relationship, and here there is nothing of the sort.

It is rather the bond between one human being and another, between two beings who have, thru the vagaries of fate, been pitchforked  into  a situation  where they need each other  to survive, though to different degrees,  and thus stand by each other  no matter fact.

It remains to be seen if there is anything more to this  bond in the years ahead, but as of now, thanks to Shivanand, Kuba and his mother are free at last.

A reluctant heroine: Kuba's mother exemplifies the truth  of the saying that courage is not the absence of fear, but the ability to  face fear and overcome  it. She  is the very embodiment of  an abused woman,  beaten into physical and mental submission and  servitude by a brutal, sadistic husband, who gets his highs  out of terrifying her for anything and nothing, treating her like a dog to be kicked when the mood takes him, and to be called to heel at other times.  The scars that years of  such treatment have left  are there in her   sunken, narrowed eyes, in the  dark bruises from  the last punch in the eye that had been dealt out to her,  in the drawn, prematurely aged face,  in the perennial tension  in her body language, in the frantic haste with which  she  polishes Shivanand's fingerprints off  the "incoming calls only" phone set.

And yet, having brought home  the man,  whom her car had hit for no fault of hers,  to please her son, she is steadfast in helping him even as she battles rising tides of abject fear as she thinks of her husband. It is only when her son's life is at stake that she confesses to Messer that Shivanand  is inside,  and later, when she sees him in her car in front of the church, she empties her purse  of her last money so that he can make phone calls. Finally, when he approaches her in the church one last time,  she is terrified that  someone will spot her with him,  but yet she  gets ready to  drive him to the Indian Consulate.

Why does she do all this for a stranger? At  the perennial risk of  being found out and  murdered by her husband, thus leaving her beloved son to a horrible fate? Initially, it  is out  of a sense of guilt  for having hit and injured this stranger. But  for the most part, it is humanism at its purest, goodness without any thought of reward.

And also because,  in this poor tormented woman's life,  Kuba's  relationship with this stranger brings a few moments of unalloyed  happiness. Watch her smile with pride when Kuba offers his piggy bank to the departing Shivanand. And again, the  first real smile seen on her face when Shivanand, after  fixing the lock and  throwing away the  key for luck, hugs Kuba and then picks him up and whirls him around with  the kind of playful paternal affection his father should have shown him but never  did.

So, to save the life of this stranger who has somehow become part of their lives, hers and Kuba's, this  cowering, mouselike woman  picks up a beam and batters her brutish husband to death.  As she rains blow after blow upon his recumbent form, the protectiveness for Shivanand  morphs into a tidal wave of hatred and the long suppressed desire for revenge against  the man who has made her life with him a living hell. 

The same satisfaction at due retribution can be seen when she does not run  away with Kuba,  as she is told to  by Shivanand, but stays back, rejoicing and smiling at every crippling blow he hits one of the goons, and finally when he kills Messer with his bare hand.

As Shivanand raises his hand in a farewell gesture from the helicopter that is taking him back to captivity,  she looks up at  him with an indefinable expression  on  her  upturned face. Is it regret at his recapture? Is it fear for him?  We do not  know.

What  we do know is that she is standing  straight now,  and years have been wiped  off the  once weary, perennially fearful face. Kuba aur uski maa ke liye achche din aa gayee hain.

Nemesis at work: Retribution: The Bible says: The mills of God grind slowly, but they grind exceeding small.

Last week brought this out with startling clarity. First, there was Kuba's horrible father,  battered to death by his mother as Kuba looked on, impassively,  but perhaps with a  terrible inner joy as he saw the man he had asked Shivanand to kill laid low thus unexpectedly.  

It was that request of Kuba's, all the more telling for the level, unemotional tone in which it was made,  that brought home to us, far  more than any beatings or other abuse by his father could have done, the horrors of the life Kuba's mother, and thus Kuba  at one remove, had been enduring all these years.

I am not normally  a bloodthirsty person, but I would have liked to have landed the brute a few blows myself.

Next was Messer, the Blade Man. A thug whose casual sadism was equalled only by his arrogance.  Nothing can beat the chilling realism with which he was introduced  to us. Standing at the edge of a grave in which lay the body of a half clothed, murdered woman, clearly his latest "completed job".  A bunch of red roses in his left hand, obviously to be laid, in a ghastly tribute,  on the grave once it has been filled up. Nothing, except perhaps the matter of fact tone in which he offers Kuba's mother the choice of two ways in which he can cut Kuba's throat if she does not speak up.

So it was eminently satisfying to see Shivanand deploy his martial arts skills (regardless  of the handicap posed by his unkempt hair frequently getting  in front of his eyes!WinkThe chap clearly needs a close crop)  and not only lay low the whole assortment of thugs deployed by Messer, but in the end  kill the Blade Man himself with   the side of  his bare hand.

Then,  in the precap, there was khoye paaye  Pandey,  having committed the folly of trying to circumvent Swami Balivesh's dire last warning,  reaping the consequences at the Swami's hands. It was unclear whether he was being  stabbed to death or only blinded, but  in either case,  his days are clearly numbered.

I do not suppose Nemesis,  the Greek goddess of  retribution for evil, is going to deal with the Polish Cardinal and his cohorts, nor with Swami Balivesh and his gang, with similar celerity, for that would  put paid to our tale in 12 episodes instead of 120!

It is clear that Shivanand's  father's Brahma Nisht Panth will still be  in a sad, leaderless  state for  a while yet. Seeing that the adult Rudra  is still standing atop the rail bridge in Varanasi, it does not seem that Shivanand is back in India even after another 12 years. And the Swami's Sri Santh Panth will  undoubtedly flourish like the  green bay tree, as the  Bible says of the wicked.

It will very likely  take all of another  12 years for Rudra to  not  only  identify all his special powers, but to learn to use them wisely  and to the best effect. So  we have curb our thirst for retribution and possess our souls in patience, while the young ladies here make the most of Gautam Rode's Salman Khan stunt  on the bridge!WinkWink

Still, it was good to have had a trailer for what is to come! 

My Take 5: Now for my pick of the  5 most dramatic scenes, visually and content-wise,  this last week. Personally, I would have  chosen the killing of Kuba's  father to top the list, but that has already been dealt with, so let us look elsewhere.

-          Rudra carrying Udiya Baba,wrapped in a blanket, out of the fiery mess that the Ravana effigy had created as it burnt down.  There is a remote majesty to the boy's face that makes all the onlookers see him not as what he is, but as Lord Rama, the protector of mankind, in person. Earlier, the whole fire scene was done much better than is the  norm on TV.

-          Rudra is sitting by the ghat,  his whole body hunched in misery as  he awaits news of Udiya Baba's state of health. When Maimuyi approaches him,  he raises his face to her  in mute, fearful enquiry. In his eyes one can see all the resurgent fear of loss,  the loss of one of the two pillars on which his life rests at present. When she  says Hosh aa gaya,  the boy's face clears as if a wave had passed over it. He rises to his feet in a single, supple movement, and races  off, like an eager  greyhound,  to get to his Udiya Baba.

 -          The sudden emergence of a forest of trishuls in the river,  blocking the goons who are after Rudra.  It was an extremely arresting scene visually, and  even more satisfactory  was the brutal dunking that followed for the goons, who were dragged along ruthlessly while being periodically plunged into the water. When they finally were left to bob up and down in the shallow water, while Pandey's  brother  in law was dragged away to face the Swami's wrath, I for one was delighted. In fact, this scene might qualify for inclusion in the Retributions section!

-          After Jyotishi Tiwari brushes aside complaints about a poor smashan dweller playing Lord Rama in the Ram Leela, and insists that Rudra, a veer rakshak,  and none else would be his Rama, some members of the audience get up to leave. But before they  have reached the exit, Rudra's sonorous recitation,  of not only the doha he  had been taught by Tiwari, but of another that he had apparently not yet been taught, judging by Tiwari's astonishment, brings them up short. And the very naysayers,  now seeing the Lord Himself  in this young boy, fold their hands in obeisance.  It was a beautiful illustration  of the power of simple faith to  open  up eve n the most  bigoted and closed of minds.

-          A little earlier, Rudra mentally replaying a recording of the Jyotishi  Nityanand Tiwari reciting the test doha,   and then reproducing it akshara saha sahi.  It was a lovely little  bit about yet another of Rudra's special powers,  but introduced almost casually without any OTT flourishes.

 You can now relax, folks, for this is itWink!

Let me conclude by sending  you all, and your families,  my warm good wishes for 2015  to be good in every way for you, bringing you the best of good health, peace of mind and fulfillment. And if you get these three, happiness  is sure to follow!

Shyamala B.Cowsik



Edited by sashashyam - 28 December 2014 at 10:27am

The following 50 member(s) liked the above post:

ringrosesRANOUSidra86Calliopebiggetrainparul2999srividyahvparas99vspdandeliappukrishspidiebanglesNilaraniCoolpreechembiprav2chitteratisp108-AditiSSamsangeethacroziaxxberrysweetrev4evaSadia_JenAmmishtidoihappychappyyurimehta11ddsoapstwilakunchuKusum04-Obsessed-Gul.S_EfSandhya.ASindhuMenonRashmi81AbHer_neha--sumana13--ngayouArshicsghalibmirzaPrincessNNeel_MJoynessCarmillaNestleToulouseelasingh-Swetha-Nikki_TitliVasusenaRadheya

yurimehta11 IF-Dazzler
yurimehta11
yurimehta11

Joined: 26 October 2013
Posts: 3974

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 5:58am | IP Logged
Nice post thanks for pm Happy and prosperous new year to you

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

sashashyam

Sadia_JenAm IF-Dazzler
Sadia_JenAm
Sadia_JenAm

Joined: 11 June 2009
Posts: 3325

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 7:49am | IP Logged
This is a brilliant amd extremely comprehensive analysis auntie!! Ur views r so authentic andd detailed!
Btw ur post is being applauded in twitter by the writers of the show, utkarsh and aniruddh..

Utkarsh: @AsianPathak padhiyega sir :)
"@_jjazzy_: A must-read, comprehensive analysis of last week's episodes of #Mahakumbh india-forums.com/forum_posts.as...


Anirudh:
@utkarshnaithani sometimes I feel viewers are more profound and clear then our minds ...


Big smile

Edited by Cornia_JenAm - 28 December 2014 at 8:03am

The following 13 member(s) liked the above post:

ringrosesapple64paras99NilaranichembiSamsangeetharev4evatwilangayousashashyamArshicsNestleToulouse-Swetha-

sashashyam IF-Sizzlerz
sashashyam
sashashyam

Joined: 04 January 2012
Posts: 13119

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 8:12am | IP Logged
Thank you so much, my dear.

I used to know Utkarsh quite well  during my brief 6 week stint in DKDM, and then I used to post my analyses on his FB page. He is still active there, but it seemed that he does not read things there too much.

But after I had written this, I saw that he had posted a message to me on his FB page,

Thank you for your efforts, Shyamala ji
Your love is precious to me... and the entire Team of #Mahakumbh

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4266510

Gratitude...

-Utkarsh

, with  the Twitter exchange that you had cited given underneath. So it is clear that he is in touch thru that page FB as well. I  have thus sent him the link for this post too.

How does one follow him or Anirudh on Twitter?

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by Cornia_JenAm

This is a brilliant amd extremely comprehensive analysis auntie!! Ur views r so authentic andd detailed!
Btw ur post is being applauded in twitter by the writers of the show, utkarsh and aniruddh..

Utkarsh: @AsianPathak padhiyega sir :)
"@_jjazzy_: A must-read, comprehensive analysis of last week's episodes of #Mahakumbh india-forums.com/forum_posts.as...


Anirudh:
@utkarshnaithani sometimes I feel viewers are more profound and clear then our minds ...


Big smile


Edited by sashashyam - 28 December 2014 at 10:29am

The following 7 member(s) liked the above post:

NilaraniSamsangeethaSadia_JenAmngayouSindhuMenonArshics-Swetha-

adiana12 IF-Rockerz
adiana12
adiana12

Joined: 23 October 2011
Posts: 7390

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 8:27am | IP Logged
Hi Shyamala, thanks for the pm. Yes I did watch all the epis last week but I also saw the shift from the previous week - The story is slowly biting the dust - I just have one lament - 'why, o why do we need our heroes to be perfect and walk on water?' - becoz that entire Ramayana sequence was just that - I honestly now wish that another KB rises for our television and film industry soon - atleast the story once again will become the hero, as it should 

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

sashashyam

ddsoaps IF-Dazzler
ddsoaps
ddsoaps

Joined: 29 August 2012
Posts: 4957

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 9:17am | IP Logged
Thank you for the PM Shyamalaji...
It is such a pleasure reading you. What a fabulous in-depth analysis this is.ClapClap.

Loved every bit of it. 






The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

sashashyam-Swetha-

Sidra86 Groupbie
Sidra86
Sidra86

Joined: 10 December 2010
Posts: 79

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 9:19am | IP Logged
Thank you for the PM Shyamalaji...Smile
Fantastic  Post Smile


Edited by Sidra86 - 28 December 2014 at 9:19am

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

sashashyam

Arshics IF-Sizzlerz
Arshics
Arshics

Joined: 22 February 2012
Posts: 15789

Posted: 28 December 2014 at 10:05am | IP Logged
Fantastic post Shyamala. and great round up of week 2.

Will look forward to your take 5s every week.

The sight of Rudra as Ram, his coming out of the fire holding udiya baba, the trishul bearing Sadhus in the water all had a high visual impact and will be unforgettable!

And the relationships - so beautiful and well etched that they are really touching.

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

appukrishsashashyam

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Mahakumbh Creation Gallery

2 3 4 5 6 7

Author: mnx12   Replies: 48   Views: 8811

mnx12 48 8811 24 April 2015 at 1:55pm by RupaGautamRode
~~MAHAKUMBH Members Introduction Corner~~

2 3 4 5

Author: Ipsita_Ipu   Replies: 35   Views: 6063

Ipsita_Ipu 35 6063 31 March 2015 at 11:02pm by dash8
Mahakumbh 1-4: The Quest for Immortality DT note pg 15

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 14 15

Author: sashashyam   Replies: 117   Views: 9009

sashashyam 117 9009 09 January 2015 at 12:39pm by sashashyam
Zachary Coffin shares his experience on Mahakumbh

Author: Sadia_JenAm   Replies: 5   Views: 1001

Sadia_JenAm 5 1001 27 December 2014 at 4:57am by MrDarcyfan

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index