Mahabharat

India-Forums

   
Mahabharat
Mahabharat

StarPaanchaali's Pratiyogita-Arjuna POW & Bhima SOW-pg133 Imp Nt

Sabhayata IF-Sizzlerz
Sabhayata
Sabhayata

Joined: 09 August 2013
Posts: 11232

Posted: 30 June 2014 at 1:31pm | IP Logged

Hello Folks!TongueTongue
A warm welcome to you all.Hug
There has been much debate on this forum about who is Panchali's Pati No. 1.Wacko  Who of the Pandavas loved her the most.  This post will not answer that question for you.LOL  Draupadi does not appear to have kept tally..Confused.alternately, Rishi Veda Vyas had more important details to note then who got what flowers for Mahabharat's Yagaseni.LOLLOL   So while many may acclaim Bheem to be Pati No. 1 without a full record and analysis of the Pandavas marriage to Panchali Thumbs Downwe cannot really assess who was truly PANCHALI'S PATI NO.1. Approve But, friends let us not lose heart.  EmbarrassedWhile we cannot judge history, which remains a mystery,  we can TRACK THE PRESENT and have our own analysis.Thumbs UpSo,presenting to you all:Cool


PPP

Starbharat Paanchaali



Key Points of This Analysis
1.We will keep a running tally of the care, concern, connection each of the Pandava Princes express for their Patni Panchali in StarBharat.  Embarrassed

 2.We will try to score the candidates objectively.  For further details please see post 2. Geek

3.We welcome your post episode input daily on which princes should be awarded points and why. Thumbs Up

4.The score for the most recent episode will be updated in the 3rd post along with rationales.Star

5.Progress Graph: Shyam09 will chart the progress of the princes in post 5 and post updates on an weekly basis at the end of the week. Wink

6.PATI of the Week: ...Poojie... assess this weekly on Sundays. Please check 4th post for details. Tongue

7.Awards for the Pati Of The Week: Abhishek_King will provide banners for the POWs.Shyam09 will provide trophies for them. Special Icons or Avis will also be there too.SmileSmile


8.Standout Performer Of The Week: ...Poojie... assess this also weekly on Sundays. Shyam09 generally makes gifs on the scenes of SOWs.EmbarrassedEmbarrassed


State of Competition Now:



Pandava Princes

Total to Date

Daily Score

Updated Total

1.       Yuddhi

210.21


0


210.21


2.       Bheem

307.97


.5

308.47


3.       Arjun

263.54


0


263.54


4.       Nakul

 101.15

0


101.15


5.       Sahadev

 70.14


0

70.14




Scores for first week: Y=10.96, B=9.46, A=11.96, N=2.80, S=2.80
Scores for 2nd week: Y=25.72, B=17.72, A=15.72, N=5.90, S=5.40
Scores for 3rd week:: Y=29.42, B=18.42, A=19.42, N=7.10, S=9.60
Scores for 4th week: Y=45.92, B=26.92, A=33.42, N=7.10, S=10.60
Scores for 5th week: Y=52.16, B=30.16, A=47.41, N=7.35, S=10.85
Scores for 6th week: Y=78.36, B=32.89, A=40.61, N=10.08, S=13.88
Pre-Stake on April 3/14: Y=76.11, B=43.14, A=47.86, N=16.18, S=15.98
Scores for 7th week: Y=73.00, B=54.34, A=48.77, N=11.33, S=14.03
Pre-VH on April 8/14: Y=70.72, B=52.58, A=49.01, N=5.51, S=8.21
Scores for 8th week: Y=90.44, B=67.02, A=70.27, N=14.35, S=15.34
Scores for 9th week: Y=139.38, B=107.87, A=109.33, N=50.69, S=34.82
Scores for 10th week: Y=162.02, B=161.09, A=178.27, N=65.96, S=48.90
Scores for 11th week: Y=174.36, B=169.63, A=165.86, N=69.06, S=51.75
Scores for 12th week: Y=178.69, B=173.26, A=181.59, N=74.72, S=55.08

Scores for 13th week: Y=178.69, B=173.26, A=181.59, N=74.72, S=55.08
Scores for 14th week: Y=183.25, B=178.77, A=193.10, N=75.67, S=56.03
Scores for 15th week: Y=188.11, B=188.83, A=200.46, N=78.67, S=59.53
Scores for 16th week: Y=187.655, B=189.075, A=200.61, N=85.515, S=63.75
cores for 17th week: Y=188.755, B=191.175, A=201.71, N=88.115, S=64.85
Scores for 18th week: Y=195.01, B=207.51, A=205.71, N=89.87, S=65.85
Scores for 19th week: Y=199.22, B=204.47, A=209.79, N=93.99, S=64.48

Scores for 20th week: Y=200.72, B=221.51, A=217.29, N=94.99, S=65.48

Scores for 21st week: Y=201.05, B=229.07, A=218.29, N=94.99, S=65.48

Scores for 22nd week: Y=201.38, B=232.61, A=222.79, N=95.82, S=66.31

Scores for 23rd week: Y=210.21, B=305.97, A=255.54, N=101.15, S=70.14

Scores for 24th week: Y=210.21, B=308.47, A=263.54, N=101.15, S=70.14
Rules:
1.This is a fun post - hopefully your sentiments are strong enough survive some lighthearted humor.LOLLOL


2.So, if you want to argue why your favorite prince should get more points or another less then please press your case.  Unlike King Dhrit we promise to hear first judge later.Wink






Edited by Sabhayata - 08 August 2014 at 2:52pm

The following 8 member(s) liked the above post:

RonMione4everamritatUma90FeynmannssroomaniSpring-DewaparnaumaAnjanaYYZ

Sabhayata IF-Sizzlerz
Sabhayata
Sabhayata

Joined: 09 August 2013
Posts: 11232

Posted: 30 June 2014 at 1:34pm | IP Logged



Positive Pati Points
1. Care n Concern: if a prince expresses care or concern for Panchali he will earn a point.  This includes things like asking her opinion, holding her hand on rough geographic terrain, helping her down from chariots, etc.  The expression need not be verbal - looks of concern will be valued.


2. Communication n Connectivity: Princes will also be awarded a point for maintaining communication with Princess Panchali - be it verbal or non-verbal (i.e. eye locks, nods, etc.).
 

3. Honour:  Each prince will earn a point for defending their Panchali's honour either verbally or in deed (i.e. killing/punishing those who have insulted her).
 

4. Gifting: Princes will earn points for gifts.


5. Make Up: Princes will be also be awarded point for efforts they make to sooth Panchali's hurt feelings when she is upset or mad.

 
6. Mark Sharing: If an act is shared by more than one prince then the point - i.e. giving Draupadi adhikaar to go to Bhisma or gathering firewood then the marks will be split by the princes involved.

7.Objections:Any objections to the scoring of a particular episode must be raised before the next episode is aired


Negative Marks

1.Staking the Princess

2.Not objecting to her being staked

3.Marrying another Princess post marriage to Panchali*

4.Bringing home another Princess post marriage

5.Romantic moments with other Princesses**

6.Violating vows to her

Peace negotiation scoring scheme

1. Here Negative Marking should be reserved for disagreeing with Panchali.  What is disagreement? Deciding to do opposite of whatever she wants.  

2. The exception to above should be that if she wants peace and is sacrificing her wish for justice and Pandav don't agree with her.  Then they should not be negatively marked.  Why?  Because they remain true to her cause of justice.

Application:
1. P wants peace & Pandav want war ==> Positive
2. P wants war & Pandav want peace ==> Negative


*Please note - negative points will be awarded for other wives only if they are specifically shown or mentioned in StarBharat.
**Children symbolize a romantic moment with mom, so any children with another wife post-Panchali will be a negative point.
***Loving children will never ever garner any pati negative points.





Edited by Sabhayata - 10 July 2014 at 1:31pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

RonMione4everssroomaniSpring-Dew

Sabhayata IF-Sizzlerz
Sabhayata
Sabhayata

Joined: 09 August 2013
Posts: 11232

Posted: 30 June 2014 at 1:35pm | IP Logged



Y

B

A

N

S

July 30 - Grading Analysis (Draft 2)

 

 

7



Arjun kills Karna. 

 

 

2

Arjun fulfills his  '101 pran' 

 

2


Bheem says the one who called "Sati" Panchali as Vaishya is now dead. 

 






0

2

9

0

0

TOTAL TALLY





Edited by Sabhayata - 02 August 2014 at 7:13am

The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

RonMione4everUma90ssroomaniSpring-Dew

....Poojie.... IF-Stunnerz
....Poojie....
....Poojie....

Joined: 01 August 2005
Posts: 42426

Posted: 30 June 2014 at 1:39pm | IP Logged


~~WINNER~~ 

Week 24  - PATI OF THE WEEK - PRINCE ARJUN

Scores for the week: 
Yudi - (210.21 -  209.88) = 0.33
Bheem - (307.97 - 305.97) = 2
Arjun - (263.54 - 254.54) = 9
Nakul - (101.15 - 100.82) = 0.33
Sahadev - (70.14 - 69.81) = 0.33

Growth: 
Yudi - ((210.21 -  209.88)/209.88) = 0.0016
Bheem - ((307.97 - 305.97)/305.97) =  0.0065
Arjun - ((263.54 - 254.54)/254.54) = 0.035
Nakul - ((101.15 - 100.82)/100.82) = 0.0033
Sahadev - ((70.14 - 69.81)/69.81) = 0.0047

Ranking: Arjun = 5, Bheem = 4, Sahadev = 3, Nakul = 2, Yudi = 1

Standout Performance: Bheem wins 10 points for his line " ..Marr gaya..woh jisne Sati Panchali ko Vaishya kaha tha..". 

Yudi =  0.33(0.45) + 1(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 0.6 
Bheem = 2(0.45) + 4(0.45) + 10(0.1) = 3.7
Arjun = 9(0.45) + 5(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 6.3
Nakul = 0.33(0.45) + 2(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 1.05
Sahadev =  0.33(0.45) + 3(0.45) + 0(0.1) = 1.5

Hence Arjun is the winner!! Smile


Credit for the trophy: Shyam09


Credit for gifs: chippedcupofchai/tumblr





Edited by ....Poojie.... - 03 August 2014 at 11:42am

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

RonMione4everssroomaniSpring-Dew

....Poojie.... IF-Stunnerz
....Poojie....
....Poojie....

Joined: 01 August 2005
Posts: 42426

Posted: 30 June 2014 at 1:39pm | IP Logged


~~~~~PATI OF THE WEEK~~~~~

~~~~CALCULATIONS FOR THE PATI OF THE WEEK~~~~

PATI OF THE WEEK = HIGHEST POINTS + BEST GROWTH OVER THE WEEK + STANDOUT PERFORMANCE

Weightage: 45% (Highest points) + 45% (Best Growth) + 10% (Standout Performance)

For calculating Highest points, we will multiply each candidate's points by 0.45 (45%). From week 3 onwards, we would only be factoring the weekly performance and not the total till date. So highest points = This week's score - last week's score. 

For calculating Best Growth, we will be ranking them, for. eg. if Nakul grew the most he gets 5, Sahadev next so he gets 4..etc. We will then multiply the rank number by 0.45 (45%).  To calculate the best growth, we will be using this equation =( (This week's total - Last week's total)/ Last week's total)

For calculating standout performance, the one chosen candidate will be earn fixed 10 points which when multiplied by 0.1 (10%) will get him an extra 1 point. 

Adding these three figures will get us the grand total and the one with the highest figure is the winner. Smile

Example: Credit goes to Anjana 

Hypothetical situation

Scores for the week: Arjun 10 pts, Nakul 8, Bheem 6 
Standout performance: Bheem gets 10 pts
Growth = if Nakul grew most he is given 5, Arjun 2, Bheem 1


Arjuna = 10(.45) + 2 X.45 + 0 (0.10) = 5.4
Nakul= 8 (.45) + 5 X 0.45 +0 (0.10) = 5.85
Bheem= 6 (.45)+ 1 X 0.45 + 10(0.10) =  4.15

So, winner is Nakul!

~~WINNERS~~

Please check the calculations for each week on the respective Pg Nos.

Week 1  - PATI OF THE WEEK- PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 13) 

Week 2  - PATI OF THE WEEK-  CROWN PRINCE YUDHISTHIR (Pg 41)

Week 3  - PATI OF THE WEEK - PRINCE SAHADEV(Pg 61)

Week 4  - PATI OF THE WEEK - KING YUDHISTHIR (Pg 101)

Week 5  - PATI OF THE WEEK -  PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 132)


The Pg Nos till Week 5 corresponds to this thread:


Week 6 - PATI OF THE WEEK - EMPEROR YUDHISTHIR (Pg 31)

Week 7 -  PATI OF THE WEEK- DAAS BHEEM  (Pg 112)


The Pg Nos of Week 6-7 corresponds to this thread:


Week 8 - PATI OF THE WEEK- PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 39)

Week 9 - PATI OF THE WEEK - PRINCE YUDHISTHIR (Pg 132)


The Pg Nos of Week 8-9 corresponds to this thread:


Week 10  - PATI OF THE WEEK - PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 90) 

Week 11 - PATI OF THE WEEK - EMPEROR YUDHISTHIR (Pg 133)


The Pg Nos of Week 10-11 corresponds to this thread:


Week 12  - PATI OF THE WEEK- PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 8)

Week 13 - PATI OF THE WEEK - NO WINNER (Pg 15)

Week 14 - PATI OF THE WEEK- PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 28)

Week 15 - PATI OF THE WEEK- CROWN PRINCE BHEEM (Pg 52)

Week 16 - PATI OF THE WEEK- PRINCE NAKUL (Pg 80)

Week 17 - PATI OF THE WEEK- PRINCE NAKUL (Pg 92)

Week 18 - PATI OF THE WEEK- CROWN PRINCE BHEEM (Pg 110)

Week 19 - PATI OF THE WEEK- PRINCE NAKUL (Pg 128)


The Pg Nos of Week 12-19 corresponds to this thread:

Week 20 - PATI OF THE WEEK- CROWN PRINCE BHEEM (Pg 14)

Week 21 - PATI OF THE WEEK- CROWN PRINCE BHEEM (Pg 29)

Week 22  - PATI OF THE WEEK -  PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 42)

Week 23 - PATI OF THE WEEK- CROWN PRINCE BHEEM (Pg 101)

Week 24  - PATI OF THE WEEK -  PRINCE ARJUN (Pg 142)



STANDOUT PERFORMANCE OF THE WEEK

~~~WINNERS~~~


Week 1 - PRINCE ARJUN: Arjun earns 10 points especially for taking out the dhanush and taking the pran for Draupadi's honour. 

Week 2 - PRINCE BHEEM: Bheem earns 10 points for his standout performance in consoling a crying draupadi and killing the snake who was about to attack Draupadi. 

Week 3 - PRINCE SAHADEV: Sahadev earns 10 extra points for being considerate towards the oath taken for Panchali (and for his favourite word being Panchali  since he uses it a lotTongueWink).

Week 4 - PRINCE BHEEM: Bheem earns 10 points for his sweet ladoo moment for Draupadi.

Week 5 - PRINCE ARJUN: Arjun earns 10 points for his intense eyelock with Draupadi when she welcomes him with Subhadra

Week 6 - EMPEROR YUDHISTHIR: Yudi earns 10 points for his conversation with Panchali at the dice hall stage.

Week 7 - DAAS BHEEM: Bheem earns 10 points for his pran of breaking Dushasan's hands for dragging Panchali by her hair

Week 8 - PRINCE ARJUN: Arjun earns 10 points for calming down Draupadi's Mahakali roop and giving Pandavas a chance to avenge Panchali's insult.

Week 9 - PRINCE NAKUL: Nakul earns 10 points for his raksha duty wherein he was reluctant to leave Panchali alone even after knowing that Yudi could be in danger. Also inviting Panchali to have lunch with them.

Week 10 - PRINCE ARJUN:  Arjun gets 10 points for his conversation with Panchali and consoling her.

Week 11 - PRINCE BHEEM: Bheem gets 10 points for not forgetting about Panchali's insults when Yudi says to let go of everything and going back to forest. 

Week 12 - PRINCE ARJUN: Arjun knowing exactly what Panchali was asking from Abhimanyu and his proud look at P when blessing Abhimanyu.

Week 13 - NO WINNER

Week 14 - PRINCE ARJUN: Arjun earns 10 points for being pro war for Panchali's insult and speaking up for her. 

Week 15 - NO WINNER

Week 16 - PRINCE NAKUL: Nakul earns 10 points for being reluctant to heal Karna and remembering that he (Karna) has tried to strip to Panchali. 

Week 17 - NO WINNER

Week 18 - CROWN PRINCE BHEEMBheem earns 10 points for remembering Panchali's insults while fighting Duryodhan and aiming to kill him. 

Week 19 - NO WINNER

Week 20 - CROWN PRINCE BHEEM: Bheem earns 10 points for remembering Panchali's insults and killing 20 Kauravs. 

Week 21 - CROWN PRINCE BHEEM: Bheem earns 10 points for remembering his pran and killing 30 Kauravs. 

Week 22 - NO WINNER

Week 23 - CROWN PRINCE BHEEM: Bheem earns 10 points for the awesome Dushasan vadh. 

Week 24 - CROWN PRINCE BHEEM:  Bheem wins 10 points for his line " ..Marr gaya..woh jisne Sati Panchali ko Vaishya kaha tha..". 





Edited by ....Poojie.... - 03 August 2014 at 11:44am

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

RonMione4everssroomaniSpring-Dew

guenhwyvar IF-Rockerz
guenhwyvar
guenhwyvar

Joined: 06 November 2010
Posts: 5266

Posted: 30 June 2014 at 1:46pm | IP Logged


Dharma-Ke-Pratik: Yuddhistira                      

=====================================================

Vrikodhara: Bhimasen                                


=================================================
Gandeeva Dhari: Arjunnaaa                            Damn That Eye Lock

======================================================

The Handsome and Dashing: Nakula          
========================================================
Phoorvabhasing Pati: Sahadeva                     

======================================================
Sabhi Pratiyogitas Overall (updated/replaced weekly)





Edited by shyam09 - 16 July 2014 at 8:24am

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

RonMione4everssroomaniSpring-Dew

Abhisheking IF-Rockerz
Abhisheking
Abhisheking

Joined: 05 October 2013
Posts: 6934

Posted: 30 June 2014 at 11:12pm | IP Logged
Res

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Spring-Dew

Sabhayata IF-Sizzlerz
Sabhayata
Sabhayata

Joined: 09 August 2013
Posts: 11232

Posted: 01 July 2014 at 1:41am | IP Logged
pg147

Scoring for 2nd august

Y

B

A

N

S

Bheem says that now its dury's time to get punished

 

.5

 

 

 

total

0

.5

0

0

0

 


pg 106


Y B A N S Grading Analysis - July 28


1

Arjun challenges and duels Karna. 
 




0
0 1 0 0 Total Tally
pg116

Y

B

A

N

S

July 29 - Grading Analysis (Draft 2)

 

 

-2

Arjun's reluctance/dilemma to kill Karna.(Objections welcome) 

 

 

 

 

 

 



-2

TOTAL TALLY


pg122

Y

B

A

N

S

July 30 - Grading Analysis (Draft 2)

 

 

7



Arjun kills Karna. 

 

 

2

Arjun fulfills his  '101 pran' 

 

2


Bheem says the one who called "Sati" Panchali as Vaishya is now dead. 

 






0

2

9

0

0

TOTAL TALLY


page 104

Grading for 26th July 2014

Y

B

A

N

S

YANS look at panchali when she says this wat will end soon(A has a single shot and rest three have one shot)

.33

 

1

.33

.33

Total

.33

 

1

.33

.33

 


pg 84

Y

B

A

N

S

July 25/2014

 

14

 

 

 

Dushy vadh by Bhim, + Arm tear Pran, +2 Shampoo Pran

 

1

 

 

 

PANCHALI!  

 

31

 

 

 

Throws Dushy like he threw P, grabs D's hair like he grabbed P's, tells Dushy to remember Dhyut Sabha ka woh din, drags, and throws D parallel to what D2 did with P, grabs & throws Dushy again like P was thrown, looks at P while dragging D, throws D again, eyelock, Remembers hand tearing Pran, rips arm that touched P's kesh, informs Dury of hand tearing, B looks at P,  B asks P if these are the hands that touched her hair, B has flashback of scene as he rips the 2nd arm, B invites P to come watch the punishment of D2, B looks at P and invites her again to come...she starts to come, B looks at P, and  tells "P" that today her pratishod is complete - she won't have to leave her hair free, I will wash your hair with his blood, Apmaan - Maryada bhang - accusations - all that has been bothering your heart will be healed today, sit Panchali - pratishod is awaiting you, Bhim pours blood onto P's hair after she sits, B gives psycho look while pouring bloodsilk, B caresses in the blood into P's hair/head, B strokes P's hair twice (2) while she exchanges looks with D2 & D1, B tells D1 that he's going to drink D2's blood as per pran (point for pran recall), B stops when P reminds him "bhai hai...",  B & P eyelock, Bhim listens and throws of the blood...disgusted that D2 has turned him into a Pischach too.

 

 

 

 

 

 

0.5

 

 

0.5

 

Yudhi & Nakul's angry look b4 hand 1 ripped

0.33

 

 

0.33

0.33

Y N S ki angry look (not sure about Yuddh!)

0.33

 

 

0.33

0.33

Y N give angry looks... S looks disgusted?!

0.33

 

 

0.33

0.33

Y N S giving angry profile look

0.25

 

0.50

0.25

0.25

A comes with M to watch chest rip  (2 looks); YNS also look on post blood spurting

0.25

 

0.25

0.25

0.25

YANS watch her walk

 0.25

 

0.25

 0.25

 0.25

YANS watch B pour blood onto P's hair

0.5

 

0.5

 

 

YA watch the shampoo

0.25

 

0.25

0.25

0.25

YANS watch as B caresses the blood onto P's hair

0.5

 

0.5

 

 

YA give satisfied look! (Y looks happy for P)

 

 

1

 

 

A looks at B's stroking in the blood!

0.5

 

0.5

 

 

"Bhai hai aapka bhi, Aarya" - AY look

 

 

 

 

 

 

4.0

46

4.75

2.50

2.00

Totals
























































































































Pg78

Y

B

A

N

S

July 24/2014 - Final Grade

 

 

 

1.0

 

Nakula challenges and fights Karna

 

 

1.0

 

 

Arjuna teaches, fights and freezes Dury

 

1.0

 

 

 

Bhim threatens & fights Ashwatama

 

1.84

 

 

 

Bhim kills remaining 18 Kaurav bros making it 98 (10/98 *18)

1

 

 

1

1

YNS together halt Dushy's escape and notify Bhim (I am splitting 1 pt btwn them - Objections welcome)

 

1.0

 

 

 

Bhim tells Angaraj that Prans don't matter and taunts Yuddhi can kill Dushy (0.5) and Arjuna can kill Dury (0.5).  So no matter what - DD will die.  

0.5

 

 

 

 

Yudhhi tells Dushy today he will get fruit of his adharma

 

 

0.5

 

 

Arjuna informs Dury & Angraj he won't stop them anymore because today an adharmi will get his fruits

 

1.0

 

 

 

Bhim informs Dushy that he won't let Dushy die till he washes Panchali's hair with his blood

 

 

 

 

 

 

1.5

4.84

1.5

2.0

1.0

TOTAL TALLY



Pg66


YBANSGrading Analysis - July 23 (Draft 3)


0.5

Arjun says we will destroy your side fully to Ashwathama. 


1

Arjun walks upto to Panchali and looks at the pyres with her. 


8

Arjun says don't look at these pyres Panchali (1) You will get more pain.. don't look (1) Arjun looks at her when Panchali calls Arya (1) Arjun looks at P when P is talking about losing everything in the pyre. (1) Panchali asks why so much death. Arjun replies to her- there were 4 statements (should this be bulked into 1) (4)


5

Panchali talks about what is the point of this victory. Arjun questions her (1) Arjun looking at her when P says Bheem will kill Dushashan tomorrow. (1) Arjun has 3 shots of looking at P when P is questioning him about turning devils ourselves. (3)


2

Arjun says look there panchali, your DIL. (1) Just think it is her VH at that dyut sabha (1) 


5

Arjun saying for any one who insult woman, molest and disrepect them, any punishment is less for them.  (1) Arjun talks about Kalyug - again 3 statements (should this be bulked into 1) (3) Arjun says for future generations, everyone should know that molesters of woman will get worse punishment than death. (1)

90.5

 Bheem says to Panchali - Arjun is right. (1) It is not the time to get upset. (1) You have keep a stable heart. (1) You have to punish Dushy.(1) You will have to do blood shampoo (1) and I have to drink his blood. (1)Tomorrow, at sunset, your sons will come to take you to the battlefield. (1) For future generations, you have to sacrifice forgiveness for one day. (1)  Bheem  (Panchali is looking at Bheem) (1) and Arjun look at her (0.5)

0.5


Bheem challenges Dushy. (0.5)
 2


Bheem says does your arms only drag woman's hairs,fool (2) (1 point extra for calling him fool)
 1


Bheem-Dushy duel (1)

3


Bheem's VH flashbacks (3)

3


Bheem says to Dushy - Won't kill you now. It is not sunset yet. Panchali is not allowed to enter the battlefield. You will see yourselves before death Panchali washing her hair using your blood. (3)
 1.02


Bheem kills 10 more Kauravs. (1.02)

19.52
22


Total Tally


pg53

YBANSGrading Analysis - July 21 (Updated)
1.53


Bheem part in killing Ashwathama - the elephant. (Part of Drona Vadh) Yudi was present there so that he can tell the truth (1.5)
  
0.50.5Nakul and Sahadev fight Karna. 
 
3.5

Arjun's involvement in Drona vadh (3) Arjun Protects Shrutakaraman (1) 0.5 deduction from saturday's episode analysis where we gave 0.5 Arjun for challenging Drona. (-0.5)
1.5




Yudi utters the half truth (1.5)
 




3
33.50.50.5Total Tally




pg 42

Grading as per 19th july

Y

B

A

N

S

Bhim's duel with drona

 

.5

 

 

 

Arjuna saves dhrishtdyumna

 

 

1

 

 

Arjuna challenges Drona for a duel

 

 

.5

 

 

Nakul and Sahdev challenge karna for a duel

 

 

 

.5

.5

Total

0

.5

1.5

.5

.5

 


pg 42


Grading as per 18th july

Y

B

A

N

S

Bhim kills 20 Kaurav

 

2.04

 

 

 

Bhim wonders how he will tell Hdimba that Ghato baby is dead

 

-1

 

 

 

Bhim says I remove the burden your paap(.5) and your brother's(.5) from this world

 

1

 

 

 

Arjuna challenges karna for a duel

 

 

.5

 

 

Total

0

2.04

.5

0

0



Pg 35

YBANSGrading Analysis - July 16


0.5

Arjun talks about giving punishment for all their sins. 
      
0
00.500Total Tally

pg 33

YBANSGrading Analysis - July 15


2

Arjun says I had done the sin of sparing his life. I had done the sin of forgiving him. (This relates to Panchali kidnapping. I take this as he understands that it was wrong of forgiving him then and even then he did it.)
 




0
2000Total Tally

pg32

YBANSGrading Analysis - July 14

1


Bheem requests Panchali to start preparing for Abhi's final rites. 
0.33  
0.330.33YNS look at shock in response to Panchali's answer. Bheem gave not much of a response. Confused
 




0.33
1
0.330.33Total Tally



pg26

Updated Grading as per 10th jun 2014

Y

B

A

N

S

 

For saying to abhimanyu what answer will we give to your jesht mata panchali if anything happens to you(since he also mentions subhi which shows he is concerned about both he gets .5)

0

.5

0

0

0

 

For saying once I had staked my brother's and wife and kingdom now I don't want to stake my children(since he showed regret at the staking of his wife and brother's and kingdom yudi gets .33 for panchali)

.33

 

 

 

 

 

Total

.33

.5

0

0

0



pg18


YBANSGrading Analysis - July 8


0.5

Karna-Arjun face off. 
  0.5

Arjun and Drona fight
 



Bheem says putra abhi.. ab tumhari maata ka...something.. what was that?..Confused

0.5


Bheem challenges Dury to come save his 30 bros. 
 0.5 


Bheem challenges Dury the 2nd time to come save his bros. 

1


Bheem saves Drupad. 
  4.06   Bheem remembers his pran.  Bheem kills 30 Kauravs (3.06)
0
6.06100Total Tally

pg 16

Grading for 7th jun 2014

Y

B

A

N

S

For mentioning his pran of killing kauravas when he tells dushi tomorrow more of your brother's will die

0

1

0

0

0

 Total

 0

 1

 0

 0

 0


pg 8


Grading 4th july 2014

Y

B

A

N

S

For remembering his pran of killing 100 kauravs

 

1

 

 

 

For calling dury kadu'

 

.5

 

 

 

For war of words with karna

 

 

.5

 

 

For the duel with karna

 

 

.5

 

 

 

0

1.5

1

0

0

pg 7

YBANSGrading Analysis - July 2 (Updated)



1
When Panchali starts speaking to Kunti, Nakul was listening in to her. 
  1

Arjun was looking at Panchali when she was talking to Kunti. 
  1

Arjun says Panchali is right mother. 


1

Arjuns speaks to Panchali that bari bari ..we will do seva of Pitamah
  1

Arjun looks at her even after Panchali looks away. 


1

Arjun says to Panchali - give me food and water for Pitamah. Today I will do seva. 
      
0
0510Total Tally

























































pg 2

YBANSGrading Analysis - July 1 (No negatives for crying)

0.5


Bheem stops Dury from attacking Arjun







0.5


Total Tally

Links to previous archive threads
Thread 5
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=4002679&TPN=2
Thread 4
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3993422&TPN=2
Thread 3
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3980069&TPN=4

Thread 2
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3962172&TPN=2

Thread 1
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=3926703&TPN=2

Edited by Sabhayata - 08 August 2014 at 2:49pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

RonMione4everssroomani.FairyDust.

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Author Replies Views Last Post
Arjuna-Draupadi or Arjuna-Subhadra OR???

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 10 11

Author: AnjanaYYZ   Replies: 82   Views: 21302

AnjanaYYZ 82 21302 23 March 2015 at 6:55am by JazzyM
StarPanchali's Pratiyogita-Pg144 Bhima POW & Arjuna SOW

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 150 151

Author: Sabhayata   Replies: 1202   Views: 56305

Sabhayata 1202 56305 16 August 2014 at 2:32pm by Sabhayata
StarPaanchaali's Pratiyogita-Pg 147 Samraat Yudhishtir nears 200+

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 149 150

Author: Sabhayata   Replies: 1195   Views: 73016

Sabhayata 1195 73016 02 July 2014 at 3:13am by Sabhayata
StarPaanchaali's Pratiyogita - P.144 Patis meet the Panchali putras

2 3 4 5 6 7 ... 149 150

Author: lexy_rix   Replies: 1193   Views: 66401

lexy_rix 1193 66401 09 May 2014 at 4:30am by Sabhayata
Pratiyogita.....

Author: snehalS   Replies: 8   Views: 1808

snehalS 8 1808 27 November 2013 at 4:03am by Manojie

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index