Joined: 14 April 2011
Joined: 02 June 2011
Joined: 09 September 2011
Joined: 10 January 2012
Joined: 22 February 2006
Joined: 04 August 2010
Joined: 18 May 2012
@Manzilmukul, thoughtful points I agree with some, but I disagree with some of them. Since you added a PS not to make you see logic, this is for the others who would like to know.
Type casting is not good and since it is universal it is obvious there are advantages to the creators in portraying the character. But there is nothing wrong in a bahu trying to be good looking or wearing embroidered dresses and jewellery. Just as a man dresses up to go to his profession, a "home maker" (bahu's profession) should be good to dress up as long as she enjoys it and not imposed.
I would like to point out that typecasting is shown not just for women but to everybody - for example a good husband and a successful professional man are shown in similar stereotypes. A high ranking professional is shown to be abnormally rude, snobby and bossy just to make a point! My point is - we just need to mentally filter them and see through it. In any case, in Sandhya's case, she is not shown as dumb, docile, etc.. and in fact she is the smartest in the family.
In my opinion it is wrong to imply negativity (door mat, etc) to a girl who is shown as a "good" bahu, and implying an aggressive, rebellious image as progressive and desirable (a reverse stereotype?). I know it is controversial, and I am open for the brickbats!
IPS has a lot of halo around it (another stereotype!). It is said that one has to forget their families to be a good IPS - it is as wrong as forgetting one's professional life to be a good bahu/husband. True that their professional lives are highly demanding and family lives are affected (like in many other professions), but to "forget" family is going a bit too far (a professional door-mat?). IPS are indeed allowed and encouraged to a work-life a balance (there are specific training programs for them for this as part of stress management). There are as many happily married IPS officers as in any other profession. I think the next phase of DABH is on how Sandhya IPS balances her work and family. I hope viewers will not exclaim "What?! IPS officer cooking for her family!".
The trophy - it is a recognition and encouragement to bring out the excellence in skill, performance and success, not as a starting point for a list of "additional" responsibilities on the winner. This is true even for a Bharat Ratna. Tendulkar's life is not going to change even after getting it. Whatever responsibility that goes with it is more emotional and self-imposed than formal expectation. ALL IPS officers have SAME level of expectation at work, whether the BEST cadet or the WORST cadet.
My point is, even after becoming IPS and winning the tropy, Sandhya is absolutely right in expecting to be posted close to home to strike the work-life balance.
One point I strongly oppose in Manzilmukul's post is that Sandhya is suffering in "dharma, parampara, pratishta and samman". On the contrary, woman is given high importance in our Dharma and Parampara and a woman is the pratishta and samman of every family. There are always digressions and wrong practices, but the spirit of our dharma is always to regard woman in high esteem. One needs to understand the real intent and meaning of our dharma, identify the wrong practices and shun them. It is absolutely wrong to imply that our dharma needs to be rejected, just to be progressive.Agreed that the Sandhya's character has shortcomings, it is not perfect and ideal, just like any real human being. Some things are not exactly inspiring if looked at individual event level. But what inspires me is the very fact that someone who is cheated into her marriage, that too into an incompatible family, instead of just being depressed and crying for her fate, actually changed her fate and that too by love, honesty, courage and hard work. She will have happiness both at home and work and she will also make her family and country proud. She is exemplary AT THIS LEVEL and needs to be emulated.
Joined: 19 March 2012
|Topics||Topic Starter||Replies||Views||Last Post|
|Sandhya's Expressions-VBNOTE. PG4||meenu21||25||1899||14 April 2014 at 3:30am
|Can Sandhya be inspirational?||shruthiravi||18||1130||12 February 2014 at 7:41am
|Real life Inspirational IPS officers updtd PG 5||jhema||34||3224||05 February 2014 at 10:36pm
|**~Inspirational Inspector Singh AT~**||ranil.||22||678||05 January 2014 at 5:30am
|L@$T OnE To Po$T LoVe$ An@$ R@$hID ThE Mo$T-VBNote Pg36||DEBOLINA96||283||5066||04 November 2013 at 10:51am
With a ranking of 6.6 TRP, Diya Aur Baati Hum was crowned the highest ... 26
TV actor Romanch Mehta who is seen in Life OK's Devon Ke Dev. Mahadev ... 10