Punar Vivaah Ek Nayi Umeed

India-Forums

   
Punar Vivaah Ek Nayi Umeed
Punar Vivaah Ek Nayi Umeed

What is wrong with the makers of this show? (Page 3)

--Ekta-- IF-Rockerz
--Ekta--
--Ekta--

Joined: 07 December 2010
Posts: 8168

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 5:38am | IP Logged
Originally posted by kavmuks

This PunarVivah is not even close to the earlier one. 
The characters do not pull enough interest .. there is one married guy who did not speak for first few episodes then his wife calls his GF to set everything right and she keep following them and keep crying the moment they are together.. being called "Chhachhondri" all the time.. FIL has 2 wives .. young educated sisters in law are downloaded from hell.. 

Does this story even deserve a tile of Punar Vivah? 

I have watched complete story 1 of PV and watching PV2 only in hope that it gets better in next few days  


Don't know why people don't get the fact that this is completely different story and PV1 was different.
And Regarding the title to apply as someone here said ,even its not clear until now whose PV is going to happen where as in PV1 ,it was clear enough from Day1 .So that was a simple loving story with simple lovable characters where as this is complex story with grey characters.
Both are completely different stories .Just title is same .So if title is same ,should story need to have been same or essence or characters .
If it doesn't interest you then its all okay .But it never means story is illogical or crap or what not .Its the difference in thoughts and interests which makes someone's likes to dislikes and dislikes to likes .We should not try to force our likes on others.


Regarding leap and laughing over the fact that its 2023 ,OMG .People take the story so deeply .Is it the first show who has taken leap .in many shows ,there are leaps of from some days to even 20 years . Story is someone's imagination ,yaar .Don't you sometime imagine the moments of which may come in your life later. Writer is trying to show that only through tv show.

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

MaryamMarysangita10765

love_karanabha IF-Addictz
love_karanabha
love_karanabha

Joined: 22 February 2012
Posts: 61337

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 5:47am | IP Logged
Originally posted by kavmuks

This PunarVivah is not even close to the earlier one. 
The characters do not pull enough interest .. there is one married guy who did not speak for first few episodes then his wife calls his GF to set everything right and she keep following them and keep crying the moment they are together.. being called "Chhachhondri" all the time.. FIL has 2 wives .. young educated sisters in law are downloaded from hell.. 

Does this story even deserve a tile of Punar Vivah? 

I have watched complete story 1 of PV and watching PV2 only in hope that it gets better in next few days  



Even i have watched the complete show of PV1 but PV2 is something different so give it a chance as it is only in its first month.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

MaryamMary

-Desai- Goldie
-Desai-
-Desai-

Joined: 06 April 2013
Posts: 1281

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 6:32am | IP Logged
i cant appreciate this story for some popular cast ,i don't think PV2 story of mittals like zee write itself Dead

above all i cant get in  what way the trademark title Punar vivath suitable to this  storyline D'ohwhy they dont dare to change the title ?

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Neerjaa

love_karanabha IF-Addictz
love_karanabha
love_karanabha

Joined: 22 February 2012
Posts: 61337

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 7:02am | IP Logged
Originally posted by PriyaPriya12

i cant appreciate this story for some popular cast ,i don't think PV2 story of mittals like zee write itself Dead

above all i cant get in  what way the trademark title Punar vivath suitable to this  storyline D'ohwhy they dont dare to change the title ?

Well the title will remain the same with new tagline ek nayee umeed no use complaining
enigma1 Groupbie
enigma1
enigma1

Joined: 24 November 2012
Posts: 119

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 9:37am | IP Logged
Comparisons with PV1 are bound to happen since they are extending the PV theme and its a show from the same production house.

At least, I am not comparing PV2 with PV1. Even if we look at PV2 standalone, there are a lot of crazy things that they are showing. And saying that other telly shows are not showing anything better is not an excuse here.

I started watching PV2 because I like Karan Grover and Rubina and liked their work in their previous shows. I really don't blame the actors here.

Someone (the writers) has done a horrible job with the story. Showing negativity is one thing. But, the way Sarita is abused left, right, and center is crazy. Plus, the kind of language used by Kamla for Sarita is crazy and sounds like someone is poking needles into your ears. Some people won't mind it for the sake of entertainment. But, I find it extremely insulting. and yes, everyone can have a different POV.

Forget about having your little ones listen to such language. Most people wouldn't even want to watch it with their teenage kids either. The language used for Sarita is extremely demeaning.


Edited by enigma1 - 24 June 2013 at 9:37am

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

-MishtyBlue-Neerjaa

Jaimini_DP Newbie
Jaimini_DP
Jaimini_DP

Joined: 07 May 2011
Posts: 24

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 11:20am | IP Logged
You nailed it. I've been thinking the same thing but I thought maybe I missed something on the show.
The story so far is ridiculous. Nothing on the show makes any sense. They better get this derailed train on track before everyone loses interest. 
The only reason I keep up with this nonsense is because of the leads and in the hope that they will actually fix this butchered story. Dead
Angie12 IF-Rockerz
Angie12
Angie12

Joined: 08 July 2009
Posts: 7840

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 12:39pm | IP Logged
Enigma,

You have a good point.  But which TV serial has either a realistic story or realistic characters regardless of whether the show is top rated, average or below average.  Some serials do start with a realistic theme, but within months (if not few weeks) descend into something that nobody can relate to.  However, the difference in a good show and bad show is the direction/execution/editing/script (etc.) along with good actors that can either connect viewers to a show or not.

Here, the actors are all good and have past record to show that they can deliver. Karan and Rubina have been part of Zee's highly hit shows in last 2-3 years and so have already an existing fan base.  The theme too is not bad - that of people moving on even if they are separated from past love due to circumstances.  They want to show that a woman may not always break another woman's home and can actually act as a glue in a broken marriage.  That people can still feel love for somebody and yet can build a life without that person.  The theme is not bad.  

The problem is with execution and script.  They started with a time line that is pretty long and requires explanation for the actions of all three characters.  But the CVs have not given any time to build these three main characters.  As a result, the actions of all 3 characters are coming out to be highly unrealistic to viewers.  Instead of showing a backstory or building logic, they have straight away moved into melodrama.   Also, the two characters - Divya and Raj have very good chemistry with each other.  So the makers seem to be obsessed of not showing their emotional scenes together because then viewers may start rooting for them and spoil their theme.  As a result, the scenes between them are coming out to be rather disjointed.  On top of that, they have shown that Sarita comes from a secure background and is only tolerating abuse because of her immense love for Raj.  Without any backstory to explain her character,  her actions are also making her seem a messed up character.  She is coming across as this desperate, clingy woman who would use hook or crook to make a guy lover her.  Probably that is the intent and they would later on show her getting some enlightenment that one should not destroy one's life for anybody.  But so far that is not coming across to viewers and hence it is getting hard to connect to her.  

As far as abuse is concerned,  it seems that abuse of a main character does bring ratings in TV world. There are many shows where this kind of language and abuse is shown.  Some of them have been highly rated.  The abuse is to create a lot of sympathy for a character so that audience root for that character to become successful.  Here the abuse of Sarita is meant to invoke a lot of sympathy for her.  However, abuse in one-dimensional way only turns off audience and that is what Kamla's abuse of Sarita is coming across.  

Kamla is actually a complex character who herself is being abused by both her mother-in-law and husband constantly and is repeating the same behavior with Sarita.  Unfortunately, the CVs are intent on showing her as a one-dimensional character because of their obsession with their theme - a new hope.  Instead if they show Kamla's behavior as a cycle of abuse, then viewers would understand this behavior better.  She was abused by her mother-in-law and husband and now she is repeating the same cycle with her daughter-in-law.

They feel the more they show abuse of Sarita, the more audience would want a new hope for her.  The question is will audience stick that long to see the new hope if they cannot connect with these characters.

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

MaryamMary

enigma1 Groupbie
enigma1
enigma1

Joined: 24 November 2012
Posts: 119

Posted: 24 June 2013 at 12:56pm | IP Logged
@ Angie: Yes, the biggest problem seems to be with the execution of the script and the way these characters are shown. It is hard to sympathize with the characters.

I also feel that people generally forget the distinction between the actors and the characters they are playing. If anything, both Raj and Divya are highly flawed and so is Sarita. As much as I like Karan and Rubina as actors, I'm sorry but objectively speaking, it is hard to connect with the characters they are playing. The same is true for Srishty's character.

Although I do sympathize with Sarita, it is a bit of a stretch to think that a woman would tolerate this utter crap at the hands of her in-laws and her husband for 10 long years. Remember that Sarita has put up with crap at the hands of her in-laws (VERBAL) and her husband (SILENT and more PAINFUL) too.

One thing I thought I'll mention. Why is it that Sarita has to sleep on the floor for 10 long years? Why couldn't Raj do it? Ridiculous, Isn't it? I know several PV2ians will give the argument that perhaps Sarita was the one who volunteered to do it. Come on. Couldn't Raj at least say "We can't live like husband and wife. But, you don't need to sleep on the floor".


Edited by enigma1 - 24 June 2013 at 3:58pm

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Punar Vivaah Ek Nayi Umeed Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index