Crime patrol: Dastak

   

A Woman's Fight Against Sexual Harrassment DETAILS

Post Reply New Post

Page 1 of 3

Page 1
Page   of 3
Page 2 Page 3

Muskaan92

IF-Sizzlerz

Muskaan92

Joined: 08 October 2011

Posts: 10764

Posted: 28 April 2013 at 10:44pm | IP Logged

Crime Patrol Dastak: Namrata Das' decade long fight for justice against Sexual Harassment at workplace (Episode 237, 238, 239 on 26th, 27th, 28th Apr 2013)



Let us not pray to be sheltered from
danger but to be fearless
when facing them
- Rabindranath Tagore
Mumbai, 2002
Namrta Das (real name Rina Mukherjee) who had interest in writing from her college, completed her diploma in journalism from Mumbai. After the birth of her daughter she chose to be a full time house wife.

The time flows and in 2002 when her daughter was near 4-5 year old, she decided to put her career back on track and joins a well known news paper "The Awakened" (real name of news media is The Statesman). She is working under her supervisor Ashok Purohit (news coordinator at The Statesman, Ishan Joshi in real) and after some times she starts feeling that Ashok is taking interest in her. He tries to touch her every possible moment. Her colleagues are also looking at these odd activities but no one is able to oppose him because of his position. After too much harassment she files a complain to a NGO who helps women in these types of cases related to Sexual Harassment at Workplace.

The following 7 member(s) liked the above post:

worldrajNikki.Ritu-charu_81KhotaSikaShreyapallavi25darshana23

Dear Guest, Being an unregistered member you are missing out on participating in the lively discussions happening on the topic "A Woman's Fight Against Sexual Harrassment DETAILS" in Crime patrol: Dastak forum. In addition you lose out on the fun interactions with fellow members and other member exclusive features that India-Forums has to offer. Join India's most popular discussion portal on Indian Entertainment. It's FREE and registration is effortless so JOIN NOW!

Muskaan92

IF-Sizzlerz

Muskaan92

Joined: 08 October 2011

Posts: 10764

Posted: 28 April 2013 at 10:46pm | IP Logged
Reena Mukherjee's Story in Her Own Words...


Lessons learnt ten years on

I was no novice when I joined The Statesman in 2002. I had started writing when in college and thereafter pursued a career in journalism for over a decade following a diploma in journalism in Mumbai. After a short sabbatical to do my doctorate on a UGC fellowship, I had moved to Kolkata and worked for a short time on the Business Standard. The arrival of my baby daughter had compelled me to keep off full-time work for a while.

I intended to put my career on track with this job at The Statesman in 2002.

That was not to be. Sexual harassment at the organisation, and an indifferent management changed my world altogether. I was totally demoralised by the experience and left shattered. I will not dwell on the details here, since a lot is available on this (NWMI) website. I needed gynecological treatment and medical counseling to get over my trauma.

Once I got going, I realised the truth behind the dark underbelly that characterizes the bright imprint of the Indian media. The truth that they boldly claim to espouse is conveniently swept under the carpet if it be unsuitable.

Sure, there were people who supported me. Rajashri Dasgupta, Ananya Chaterjee , Kalpana Sharma –each in her own way – brought the issue centre-stage. So did Sevanti Ninan of The Hoot. There were some colleagues at The Statesman too. Ajoy John and OP Rana tried to persuade the management to investigate into my complaint, to no avail. They had to leave the organisation for daring to speak up. OP Rana went on to make a statement to the police and West Bengal Commission for Women against the manner in which he was made to sign a letter against me by the management under duress.

Yet, the conciliation proceedings at the Labour Commissioner's office proved unfruitful. The Women's Commission was also unable to get The Statesman authorities to investigate into and look into my complaint, despite being at it for a year. The Statesman refused to comply. Period.

Once the dispute went into the labour court, it was a harrowing time for me. If you have ever seen a law court in India, you will know what I mean. A dingy, dusty, depressing place, a court in India can make a complainant feel worse than an accused. Once a case enters a court, one can forget about its future. It is best explained by what is so aptly put in a television commercial: "chalta rahe, chalta rahe."

But try as you might, most organisations will prefer to settle matters in court. Mainly because, given the state of our courts, nothing is settled for years on end.

The first few months saw their lawyers drag the case on without a single hearing, using various pretexts. Although I have been very lucky to get short dates, with few long gaps in between, vacant courts have been my bane. To explain, vacant courts are especially characteristic of the Indian judicial system. Once a judge retires or is promoted to another court, the litigants and their legal suits languish by the wayside for years. In the course of nine years – 2004 to 2013 –I have lost nearly three years since there were four different judges who were either promoted or transferred. The Statesman and its lawyers know all this only too well. They took time and stretched the case until a judge had to leave on either promotion or transfer or retirement, leaving us high and dry for months, and hence hampering progress.

In fact, the moment I managed my first win, with an order in my favour, they appealed to the High Court against it. This made me lose precious time, in spite of the High Court ruling in my favour. Of course, once sent back to the labour court, the case continued.

But it took quite some time to have the first part decided. This was whether the labour court could decide on my case or not and whether I fell within the ambit of a "workman". By then, I was too exhausted to continue. I was frustrated with the system, and thinking seriously on the amount of time and money that was going down the drain. The way the Indian judicial system is run makes a complainant feel condemned. Even a win feels no success at all. One looks at the unending path to a formal redemption.

My lawyers were unhappy; they had worked hard to get orders in my favour. "Please consider; think of the hard work we put in." I relented, and I am glad I did.

I must also make a mention of the difficulty in getting a lawyer to fight my case. The senior lawyers were unwilling to try their hand in a case that was difficult, and without precedence. They are people who like to win…hence, only tried and tested varieties are admissible! If not for Ms Sutapa Chakrabarty of HRLN, a legal aid NGO in Kolkata, I would have been compelled to argue my own case.

Notwithstanding what I say about the attitude of senior legal luminaries, my case was certainly without precedence.

Women in Indian society are expected to be docile. A generation ago, educated women with jobs were branded as "badmaash" or "paaji", since they were believed (perhaps rightly) not to brook any nonsense from anyone. Today, even though educated and employed women are a dime a dozen, women who are sexually harassed or molested are expected to keep quiet. Ditto with raped women (a venerable Hindu seer actually made remarks to that effect on the recent Delhi gang rape).

Consequently, laws made by the State to protect women remain untested at the ground level. Women's commissions were set up in the various Indian states to deal with crimes and injustices perpetrated on women many years ago. But they remained quasi-judicial bodies with very limited powers and "no teeth" to bring offenders to book. These flaws in our system emerged scathingly when the West Bengal Commission for Women started dealing with my case, under the redoubtable feminist and academician Prof Jashodhara Bagchi.

Speaking up against a frustrating system can also work against a complainant, as I have discovered. Given the libel laws in our country, one can easily be brought to task. I have two civil and criminal libel suits filed against me in Kolkata and Delhi respectively. This has meant shuttling between two cities, and three suits, leaving me little time to work.

I have had some supportive friends and colleagues, and wonderful women like Sutapa Chakrabarty who headed the HRLN and helped me legally. But, beyond the initial help, one must go it alone. Be it the police, the Women's Commission, and your lawyers, one has to juggle one's professional demands, family, fellowships, and legal disputes with the finesse of a trapeze artiste.

The labour courts are considered comparatively faster that regular courts. But they provide no relief when an individual fights a case. One scrounges for money while spending precious years for reinstatement and relief after being illegally terminated. Unless there is a labour union to do so, one is doomed.

It also means that no one will employ you easily. In my case, even though jobs were not difficult to come by, given my credentials as a prolific writer, I found it difficult to work with three cases in three different courts to attend do. Thus, I had to take up and leave jobs, both full time and part-time, that paid well and promised much. In fact, in one case, the employer offered me a two-fold raise to prevent me from leaving, assuming I was not happy with my pay packet.

I would like to mention here, fighting my case has taught me to bolster my inner reserves as I travelled up and down, seeking lawyers, undergoing medical treatment and counselling, gathering information and attending courts all on my own while continuing writing for publications, full-time or part-time. At no stage was I ever accompanied by a friend or family member, and neither did I seek to share my misery with anyone else. My husband was a passive support, who sometimes extended financial help. Of course, given the kind of patriarchy prevalent in India, this is something one must be grateful of.

A word here about the attitude of colleagues in the profession, especially in Kolkata. I became a member of the NWMI-Bengal Chapter when I met Rajashri and Ananya in connection with my case way back in 2003. This was perhaps when it had just been set up by Rajashri Dasgupta. When details of my case on NWMI went viral, we had a lot of colleagues pledging support. However, when matters picked up, several of the members decided to shun me altogether. A few even moved away from the NWMI altogether since I continued to be a member. This, in spite of the fact that I was invited to write on other newspapers that had business links with The Statesman.

Since a lot is being said about women's unity, I want to mention the attitude of some women journalists here as well. A look at the documents put up on the NWMI website will say it all, when you do a rough count of the number of women who have signed it. A certain lady, who was then the senior-most woman in the editorial section, had point blank refused to help me with a parting note on my work done for The Statesman publications, even after I had explained why I needed it. Even when the Sexual Harassment Complaints Committee was formed after pressure from NWMI's Bengal chapter, she had never bothered, as someone with considerable clout on it, to initiate an investigation into my complaint. Today, she is out telling everyone about how she had helped me with my case. Truly, all the world loves a winner.

There are others who, like Oindrilla Mukherjee, have gone on to contest my credentials as a reporter and journalist, without ever having had any contact with me, save knowing who I was. Interestingly, I already had a decade's experience working and writing for publications nationwide, while they were just a few months or a year in the profession. A few others have even sworn on what a thorough gentleman the accused offender is, and how unfounded my accusation is.

Of course, I am not surprised. Think of how many women laugh at your plight when you get teased on the streets; I know of many women who think nothing of delivering a sharp rebuke to a young girl when her clothes are tugged at or her dupatta pulled away by miscreants on the streets.

Contrast this with the help extended by several male colleagues like Partho Pratim Nag who not only supported me, but helped guide me on my path to justice.

By the same token, I cannot but be grateful for the promptness with which the Kolkata police and the Women's Commission responded when asked to testify in court. Even though it was several years since my complaint had been filed, their representatives did not spare the necessary effort to take the case ahead. The police, particularly, plod on to investigate into my complaint despite the lack of co-operation they met with at The Statesman at every stage.

I feel particularly happy with the commitment and enthusiasm that characterises youngsters in the legal profession, going by my own experience. Debashis Banerjee of HRLN, Kolkata, ably assisted by his other colleagues, managed to win favourable orders in a row, ultimately clinching the Award from the Industrial Tribunal. One of them, Ambalika Roy, has since moved to Delhi and is now handling my libel suit as a private lawyer in Delhi. Unlike several senior lawyers in Kolkata and Delhi, they were all keen to venture into uncharted territory. The case may have been difficult for them too, with no previous judgement to fall back on, and uncertainty of success looming large. But they were willing to take the plunge, and addressing what they saw as a "human rights violation."

About the future of the media, I am not that certain. My experience at The Statesman, and the quality of journalists I have had to encounter, makes me wonder as to how much of a pillar of our democracy the media can prove to be. Journalism is not about merely holding a job in a publication, but living a life of personal and professional integrity. Newspapers are not mere documents that witness history; they make and change history. Journalists make newspapers. To embody the values that our state stands for, and uphold the Constitution, we need fearless journalists who can stand for the truth. Only then, can the media serve as the Fourth Estate, and defend our democracy. Alternative media has already made a beginning to break off from the morass; one hopes that it shall lead in bringing back the values that once spelt our media.

The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

dinki24Nikki.charu_81KhotaSikaShreyapallavi25

Muskaan92

IF-Sizzlerz

Muskaan92

Joined: 08 October 2011

Posts: 10764

Posted: 28 April 2013 at 10:48pm | IP Logged
Original Letter By Reena Mukherjee.
Link:
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-Po1wLLjHVjw/UXwV6eYOz6I/AAABX8/ictoH9Ju7jA/s1600/Rina-complaint-letter-to-The-Statesman-management-the-aweken-namrata-das+copy.jpg

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

Nikki.KhotaSikaShreya

Muskaan92

IF-Sizzlerz

Muskaan92

Joined: 08 October 2011

Posts: 10764

Posted: 28 April 2013 at 10:50pm | IP Logged
Reena Mukherjee's Picture:

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-ModqPz02lsc/UXvsat2SBbI/AAABWQ/nnMPLxYN_YA/w923-h519/crime-patrol-dastak-blog-namrata-rina-das-mukherjee-sexual-harassment-kolkata-mumbai.jpg


Edited by Muskaan92 - 28 April 2013 at 10:54pm

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Nikki.Ritu-KhotaSikaShreya

dhakkan

Senior Member

dhakkan

Joined: 30 December 2011

Posts: 862

Posted: 29 April 2013 at 12:42am | IP Logged
the sad part is that no action has yet been taken against the harassers and those who supported him.

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Ritu-Muskaan92pallavi25

Nikki.

Senior Member

Nikki.

Joined: 01 January 2013

Posts: 566

Posted: 29 April 2013 at 8:52am | IP Logged
Need to watch the last episode then i will comment but seriously hats of to Namrata's patience and tolerance for waiting for justice for 10 years and she still did not give up

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Ritu-Muskaan92pallavi25

Ritu-

Coolbie

Ritu-

Joined: 13 December 2010

Posts: 15347

Posted: 29 April 2013 at 10:05am | IP Logged
I want to say one thing first. I really applaud her courage to fight against them and stand up for her self respect. I wish that Ashok should have been put behind bars and given a very harsh punishment.
 
I also wanted to say that I was very disappointed with the people at the office. No one cared about Namrita. They just cared about their job. It showed me that when problems fall upon yourself you expect people to be with you and support you but when it falls upon others you just walk away and expect it to be okay.

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Nikki.pallavi25Muskaan92

Muskaan92

IF-Sizzlerz

Muskaan92

Joined: 08 October 2011

Posts: 10764

Posted: 30 April 2013 at 12:49am | IP Logged
Originally posted by -Ritu567-

I want to say one thing first. I really applaud her courage to fight against them and stand up for her self respect. I wish that Ashok should have been put behind bars and given a very harsh punishment.
 
I also wanted to say that I was very disappointed with the people at the office. No one cared about Namrita. They just cared about their job. It showed me that when problems fall upon yourself you expect people to be with you and support you but when it falls upon others you just walk away and expect it to be okay.


Agreed. Namrata aka Reena deserves a standing ovation and so does her husband.

Really, Ashok is so shameless. he was eager to cover the Delhi Gang rape incident...Dead
But, his behaviour towards a married girl was so cheap...

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

Nikki.Ritu-pallavi25

Post Reply New Post

Go to top

Related Topics

  Topics Topic Starter Replies Views Last Post
22nd Feb 2013: Sexual Harassment at WorkPlace

2

Muskaan92 15 1346 06 March 2013 at 1:48am
By lovely_lady
false case of Sexual saranjeet.suri 5 892 11 January 2013 at 3:05am
By harish25
Complaint against sex scenes in CP

2

-Carrie- 13 5398 02 December 2011 at 8:15pm
By sweetscented
Help against crime Loveyouearth2 0 27427 17 October 2010 at 12:23pm
By Loveyouearth2
Ajay Devgn joins Crime Patrol team against honour- princess. 0 930 06 October 2010 at 2:48am
By princess.

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category

Active Forums

Limit search to this Forum only.

 

 

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.