Nach Baliye - Shriman vs Shrimati

   

Vote on merit not on popularity (Page 3)

Post Reply New Post

Page 3 of 6

Page 1 Page 2
Page   of 6
Page 4 Page 6

ShivTRSS

IF-Dazzler

ShivTRSS

Joined: 15 September 2012

Posts: 3514

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 8:23pm | IP Logged
I know Charlie is lacking, but it does not give us right to question their love. Dance is amar's forte, so obviously Charlie has the most pressure. Coz they r ages apart in dance abilities. I agree with the post, but I dont think Charmar are here just coz of votes. Votes play a large role, but not totally. I think, Sajid is trying to put their weaknesses in worst possible sight. Comparatively, they r very strong, but amar's great dancing makes everyone think Charlie is not putting effort. Though I agree that she needs to be more hardworking, focused and confident. Amar can't be eliminated coz of her and what sajid said abt votes, that was absolutely unfair. Noone deserves an insult like that esp after a good performance on a diff concept like that. She did forget which is not acceptable but like a good team amar was encouraging her and she kept going. Gosh, I really want her to give her 100%.

The following 4 member(s) liked the above post:

Nikki_s-Rambler-sanjana_D3tiny15

Dear Guest, Being an unregistered member you are missing out on participating in the lively discussions happening on the topic "Vote on merit not on popularity (Page 3)" in Nach Baliye - Shriman vs Shrimati forum. In addition you lose out on the fun interactions with fellow members and other member exclusive features that India-Forums has to offer. Join India's most popular discussion portal on Indian Entertainment. It's FREE and registration is effortless so JOIN NOW!

zpreme

Senior Member

zpreme

Joined: 06 November 2012

Posts: 568

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 8:39pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by ShivTRSS

I know Charlie is lacking, but it does not give us right to question their love. Dance is amar's forte, so obviously Charlie has the most pressure. Coz they r ages apart in dance abilities. I agree with the post, but I dont think Charmar are here just coz of votes. Votes play a large role, but not totally. I think, Sajid is trying to put their weaknesses in worst possible sight. Comparatively, they r very strong, but amar's great dancing makes everyone think Charlie is not putting effort. Though I agree that she needs to be more hardworking, focused and confident. Amar can't be eliminated coz of her and what sajid said abt votes, that was absolutely unfair. Noone deserves an insult like that esp after a good performance on a diff concept like that. She did forget which is not acceptable but like a good team amar was encouraging her and she kept going. Gosh, I really want her to give her 100%.

So I'm taking a guess that the bold sentence is somewhat indicated at my comment? Erm, in this case I can question their "love" cause the member that goes by 'AmarCharlieFan', mentioned that Charlie will now show her effort because she "loves" Amar, so then I'm left to ask why she hasn't been putting in the effort all this time? Considering that her effort is now symbolic of her love towards Amar, it seems she doesn't then love him, clearly. Or has this lalalove only just took its stand?

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Diya_Taarey

ShivTRSS

IF-Dazzler

ShivTRSS

Joined: 15 September 2012

Posts: 3514

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 8:51pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by zpreme

Originally posted by ShivTRSS

I know Charlie is lacking, but it does not give us right to question their love.Dance is amar's forte, so obviously Charlie has the most pressure. Coz they r ages apart in dance abilities. I agree with the post, but I dont think Charmar are here just coz of votes. Votes play a large role, but not totally. I think, Sajid is trying to put their weaknesses in worst possible sight. Comparatively, they r very strong, but amar's great dancing makes everyone think Charlie is not putting effort. Though I agree that she needs to be more hardworking, focused and confident. Amar can't be eliminated coz of her and what sajid said abt votes, that was absolutely unfair. Noone deserves an insult like that esp after a good performance on a diff concept like that. She did forget which is not acceptable but like a good team amar was encouraging her and she kept going. Gosh, I really want her to give her 100%.

So I'm taking a guess that the bold sentence is somewhat indicated at my comment? Erm, in this case I can question their "love" cause the member that goes by 'AmarCharlieFan', mentioned that Charlie will now show her effort because she "loves" Amar, so then I'm left to ask why she hasn't been putting in the effort all this time? Considering that her effort is now symbolic of her love towards Amar, it seems she doesn't then love him, clearly. Or has this lalalove only just took its stand?

yes, I directed it to u. Its a fact, she is in nb coz of amar. But her effort is a different thing. She is practising, she is working for amar. Just because she is not upto our expectations, we cant she does not love him. Its wrong thats all I meant

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

-Rambler-

taani_20

Senior Member

taani_20

Joined: 15 March 2008

Posts: 337

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 8:55pm | IP Logged
I agree people should vote on merit, not on popularity. But that's very unlikely to happen, which kind of sucks. That's why a lot of such reality shows with audience voting become a popularity contest instead of dance competition.

On the other hand, I completely disagree with the whole conversation going on in this thread about Charlie's lack of effort. I'm not a fan of this girl but seriously, it's one thing to state that she is not a good dancer, or even to say she can't dance to save her life. I couldn't agree more with this fact. But how does that equal to she is not putting in effort?? The whole idea that if you practice and put in the effort, you can accomplish anything in this world is nice, but it's not true. So maybe Charlie is putting in the effort, as much effort as she can, but it's just not working. Dancing just doesn't seem to be her cup of tea. But I think to make claims that she's not putting in the effort, or she doesn't love Amar enough, is insulting to her, and honestly no one has the right to say that about her, because truth is you don't know the reality.

The following 6 member(s) liked the above post:

saira22Nikki_s-Rambler-sanjana_D3ShivTRSStiny15

Diya_Taarey

IF-Rockerz

Diya_Taarey

Joined: 31 March 2012

Posts: 5067

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 8:57pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by tamanna_20

I agree people should vote on merit, not on popularity. But that's very unlikely to happen, which kind of sucks. That's why a lot of such reality shows with audience voting become a popularity contest instead of dance competition.

On the other hand, I completely disagree with the whole conversation going on in this thread about Charlie's lack of effort. I'm not a fan of this girl but seriously, it's one thing to state that she is not a good dancer, or even to say she can't dance to save her life. I couldn't agree more with this fact. But how does that equal to she is not putting in effort?? The whole idea that if you practice and put in the effort, you can accomplish anything in this world is nice, but it's not true. So maybe Charlie is putting in the effort, as much effort as she can, but it's just not working. Dancing just doesn't seem to be her cup of tea. But I think to make claims that she's not putting in the effort, or she doesn't love Amar enough, is insulting to her, and honestly no one has the right to say that about her, because truth is you don't know the reality.

But do you think she deserves to be in this competition as long as she has with the performances she has been giving because if we go by merit.She definitely does not in my opinion.

zpreme

Senior Member

zpreme

Joined: 06 November 2012

Posts: 568

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 8:59pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by ShivTRSS

Originally posted by zpreme

Originally posted by ShivTRSS

I know Charlie is lacking, but it does not give us right to question their love.Dance is amar's forte, so obviously Charlie has the most pressure. Coz they r ages apart in dance abilities. I agree with the post, but I dont think Charmar are here just coz of votes. Votes play a large role, but not totally. I think, Sajid is trying to put their weaknesses in worst possible sight. Comparatively, they r very strong, but amar's great dancing makes everyone think Charlie is not putting effort. Though I agree that she needs to be more hardworking, focused and confident. Amar can't be eliminated coz of her and what sajid said abt votes, that was absolutely unfair. Noone deserves an insult like that esp after a good performance on a diff concept like that. She did forget which is not acceptable but like a good team amar was encouraging her and she kept going. Gosh, I really want her to give her 100%.

So I'm taking a guess that the bold sentence is somewhat indicated at my comment? Erm, in this case I can question their "love" cause the member that goes by 'AmarCharlieFan', mentioned that Charlie will now show her effort because she "loves" Amar, so then I'm left to ask why she hasn't been putting in the effort all this time? Considering that her effort is now symbolic of her love towards Amar, it seems she doesn't then love him, clearly. Or has this lalalove only just took its stand?

yes, I directed it to u. Its a fact, she is in nb coz of amar. But her effort is a different thing. She is practising, she is working for amar. Just because she is not upto our expectations, we cant she does not love him. Its wrong thats all I meant

Your and my expectations probably shape differently. I don't think questioning her love for him is "wrong" if they're gna demonstrate their means of love openly on TV, I am enabled to pass judgement intentionally or unintentionally. It takes place quite naturally.

zpreme

Senior Member

zpreme

Joined: 06 November 2012

Posts: 568

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 9:01pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by tamanna_20

I agree people should vote on merit, not on popularity. But that's very unlikely to happen, which kind of sucks. That's why a lot of such reality shows with audience voting become a popularity contest instead of dance competition.

On the other hand, I completely disagree with the whole conversation going on in this thread about Charlie's lack of effort. I'm not a fan of this girl but seriously, it's one thing to state that she is not a good dancer, or even to say she can't dance to save her life. I couldn't agree more with this fact. But how does that equal to she is not putting in effort?? The whole idea that if you practice and put in the effort, you can accomplish anything in this world is nice, but it's not true. So maybe Charlie is putting in the effort, as much effort as she can, but it's just not working. Dancing just doesn't seem to be her cup of tea. But I think to make claims that she's not putting in the effort, or she doesn't love Amar enough, is insulting to her, and honestly no one has the right to say that about her, because truth is you don't know the reality.

Trust me, I am not tryna refrain myself from insulting Charlie. 

ShivTRSS

IF-Dazzler

ShivTRSS

Joined: 15 September 2012

Posts: 3514

Posted: 03 March 2013 at 9:08pm | IP Logged
Oh god, I know u r not a hater yar. All I mean is we cant say like that she does not love him. She needs to give her 100% to prove her love but dont question it like this. We cant judge their personal life na thats what I meant. You know amar is the dancing sensation so obviouslly charlie can never match his level. But if seen individualy, I think, she is putting as much of effort as everyone but dancing with amar, I think it makes her come in bad sight. It is my opinion maybe we differ

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

-Rambler-sanjana_D3

Post Reply New Post

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category

Active Forums

Nach Baliye - Shriman vs Shrimati Topic Index

Limit search to this Forum only.

 

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.