This content was originally posted by: .Vrish.Vibs
Is it okay to comment on the episode here?I always thought that Janamejaya was right, and Astika was wrong. I recall first reading about this in the ACK Parikshit. Janamejaya did this yagna to bring justice to his father, but Astika really had no rationale for asking for Takshaka to be spared. Particularly when thousands of innocent nagas were massacred in that yagna fire, while Takshaka - the only guilty one here - ended up scot free. Looks like the concept of justice was alien to rishis then - be it Vyasa, Astika, Drona or Parashurama.I once read in Dr RC Majumdar's 'The Vedic Age', which is about the history during that time. He conjectured that all this was probably allegorical, and that what probably happened was that Parikshit was involved in a war w/ the Nagas in which he got killed, and that Janamejaya continued the war and really had them on the mat. That's the only explanation that makes sense, otherwise, massacring thousands of Nagas, while letting the guilty one go free just b'cos he was a buddy of Indra made no sense whatsoever.
This content was originally posted by: VibhishnaBy all means, its alright with me. As long as the mods allow, we can discuss here.
I'll try to include the translation for the full dialogue. It will probably be better to give detailed updates. After listening to both sides, I do agree with Vyasa - both of them are right. When asked by Janamejaya as to why Takshaka should be spared when he had killed Parikshit, Astika replies that he was a victim of fate drawn to do his duty by Shringi's curse. He further says that Arjuna destroyed an entire forest with all the creatures just to feed Agni who asked him for the favour - which (as per Astika's explanation) was much worse than what Takshaka did.
Dr. R. C. Majumdar's view is interesting. Is there an online link to his work?
This content was originally posted by: .Vrish.Did Arjun burn the Khandava forest to feed Agni, or clear the way to build the capital of the Pandavas? I always thought it was the latter.
This content was originally posted by: .Vrish.Vibs, when is the next episode?
comment:
p_commentcount