I beg for difference in opinion. Right now at school so won't give my opinion just yet. If this topic is still open by the time I get home, I shall come back to edit and post my view!
But one thing for sure. It's not 'unnecessary' as you call it.
I do not understand why you are upset with Sharon getting the focus she deserves at this point of her life. She is going through major complications in her life. She is not able to dance. Her passion that she once believed would only die with her. And now, everything she ever believed in is being taken away from her without her choice. Due to which, she feels as if she doesn't deserve Swayam as she doesn't want him to get away from dance because she doesn't have a choice. After this, I do not get how can you be sad that this focus is making you dislike Sharon? Why? Because Taani isn't involved?
This is a point in someone's life that needs to shown clear and to the point. I have never questioned screen space openly before. But this time, I WANT MORE on Sharon because of what she goes through. Sharon is one important character of the show since the beginning. Like we ALL will agree, she is the most complex and mature character in the whole show. She has a charisma that cannot be compared. And if this becomes the reason why someone would dislike her, then I have to say that I do not understand the thinking.
Like you said, Taani is the GS. If being a GS, she breaks rules, then what kind of a role figure would she be portraying herself as? In this case, it is evident why she needs to be away from what everyone is doing and why she isn't involved as much!
Yes, Taani is his sister. But also understand that Sharon has been the love of her life since the beginning. He knows Sharon more than he knows Taani. God forbid this scene, but if he has to choose between Taani and Sharon, I am pretty sure he would choose Sharon. He LOVES her! Yea sure. Taani's his sister. But sisterly love is different than this love, ain't it?
With gang, everything is about Dance! And GS would probably have more to do than kid around. When Rey was GS, it was a different case as he was the dance leader for Dazzlers as well. Everyone was his friends. But Taani's case is different.
I do not understand. Why compare Sharon with Taani? Sharon is noncomparible with ANYONE from the show. Sharon is Sharon. This screen space given to the character is the space she deserves!! Everyone knows Sharon for longer and she's popular and been loved by everyone in the college for longer. The question shouldn't arise as to why Sharon is everyone. She deserves to be everywhere. This is a change in one's life that no one would wish for. Taani is shown as a non-dancer and therefore, it isn't possible for both of them to get the same things. There will always be a difference and that is something we need to learn to cope with. Both situations for both the girls are different. Why bother compare and start a rift in the forum?
If you feel Taani should get more, you are more than welcome to drop the request in CV Discussion thread ! But please! Don't compare the two. There isn't a way these two can be compared. Both have their own places. Let them stay there?
I might have gone over the board with this long-ish essay. But I feel it's still short in words to express what I have to say. If I offended anyone's views via this, then know it was not intentional. It's merely my view.
Edited by *Khushii* - 07 February 2013 at 1:56pm