Posted: 22 December 2012 at 12:31pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by vkaur125
Nabeel was my favorite from Pakistan's side. It was hard to choose between DIljaan and Yash Raj from India. However, I'm glad that Pakistan won. Otherwise people would have said that it was a set-up and scripted show. Pakistanis were saying that since it was an Indian show, India was "obviously" going to win. Then many people were saying that Asha was so biased, etc. At least now they know Indians plays fair and we respect outside talent. That's why there are so many Pakistani singers and actors in Bollywood. Again, congratulations to Nabeel!
Honestly, I hope they don't have another season of this show. I don't think it served the purpose of bringing the two countries and their people "together". It did the complete opposite. I never understood why people were saying such horrible things about Asha Bhosle. I mean come on, she's a well-respected singer who has years of experience and people were cursing her out. Like come on, be mature, it's a damn show, no need to get your mouths dirty.
Everyone is a bully these days. People think that since they are sitting behind a computer screen, they can say whatever they want to who ever they want. In real life, most of you would not say half the hurtful things you say on here. I am not just talking about the Pakistani side, I am including the Indian side as well.
In the end, it really doesn't matter who won. Now, each and everyone is more famous and they will be making plenty of money, which was the end goal. Just look at Aman, he has already sung a few songs for movies even though he didn't "win". Diljaan, Nabeel, Yashraj, Mulazzim, etc., in my eyes are all winners. Everyone has a different type of voice which can be used for different kinds of songs.
In the end, people need to look within each other and try to get a grip of reality. If you're going to act like this, what are you planning on teaching your kids? To hate each others? Please, be mature. Thanks!
this is the first time im seeing you post here and its nice to read that you would
like peace and hv many friends of all religions.
however, pls do go through ALL the posts since beginning of show on india
forums and tell me WHO you find doing the abusing.
there were handful of pakistanis and from them too some were neutral and
unbiased. there were some one or two indians who commented on show as
whole and didnt hate.
but towards end most neutral ones left. i think they got put off by the tone
of the posts here.
there were even some really weird characters who posted abusive posts
coming in multiple ids abusing pakistani captain and supporters of that
team and the mods very rightly banned them and removed those posts.
as for show i speak for myself. if more talent and fresh voices like
nabeel mulazim and imraans can be found, i would definitely watch another
sur kshetra. it was wonderful to listen to them just as it was diljaan, aman.
my opinion of ashaji has never been good and it went even further down
watching her behaviour on this show.
i know the fact that this show was held in dubai and not india affected the
kind of guests on the show- they couldnt get big movie stars to promote their
show like sa re ga ma pa and so lowered the visibility of show but mulazim
imraan/diljaan/etc and indeed himeshji, atif and sometimes jury made it entertaining
even without big stars making appearance.
i agree the fighting atmosphere was really off putting especially in beginning
but i think inspite of that, sur kshetra was a very worthwhile journey. there
were warm moments between the participants and the contestants seem
to have cherished their time on the show.
i hope it has given music industry of both countries some new superstars.
and yes, nabeels win sort of proves that an indian produced show can
award a pakistani the prize. how they decided, who who voted for nabeel
is yet to be seen, since episode is yet to be shown.