Sur Kshetra
Sur Kshetra

India-Forums

   

Nabeel from Pakistan won Sur Kshetra [DT Note: 10,15] (Page 6)

lotus1963 Senior Member
lotus1963
lotus1963

Joined: 30 October 2008
Posts: 616

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 5:47am | IP Logged
well if this is indeed true i am very sad not because i am an Indian, of course also because of that but Indians are very fair people also at least I am and I honestly felt that India as a team proved to be far superior to Pakistsn.
Pakistan had only Nabeel that they cound count on. We had both yashraj and Diljaan wow what a soul stirring singer straight from the hear straight to the heart. The most sincere singer of sur kshetra and hence the most consistent. I am not Punjabi either sri I am a south indian too I also didnt understand the words but like sean said I understood his music. I think that India should have won in all fairness. Now if we are into diplomacy well it's an entirely different story altogether!

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

April2007

13-old Groupbie
13-old
13-old

Joined: 25 July 2010
Posts: 52

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 7:35am | IP Logged
Originally posted by lotus1963

well if this is indeed true i am very sad not because i am an Indian, of course also because of that but Indians are very fair people also at least I am and I honestly felt that India as a team proved to be far superior to Pakistsn.
Pakistan had only Nabeel that they cound count on. We had both yashraj and Diljaan wow what a soul stirring singer straight from the hear straight to the heart. The most sincere singer of sur kshetra and hence the most consistent. I am not Punjabi either sri I am a south indian too I also didnt understand the words but like sean said I understood his music. I think that India should have won in all fairness. Now if we are into diplomacy well it's an entirely different story altogether!

I completely disagree with you about sur kshetra program.
You may be right that you have good singers but Pakistan has the best singers in this team..

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

komal110nya_ansariPentaminous.

cute-aly IF-Dazzler
cute-aly
cute-aly

Joined: 28 December 2005
Posts: 3047

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 7:52am | IP Logged

The following 3 member(s) liked the above post:

chaha_khannya_ansariPentaminous.

vkaur125 Groupbie
vkaur125
vkaur125

Joined: 10 July 2008
Posts: 88

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 7:58am | IP Logged
Nabeel was my favorite from Pakistan's side. It was hard to choose between DIljaan and Yash Raj from India. However, I'm glad that Pakistan won. Otherwise people would have said that it was a set-up and scripted show. Pakistanis were saying that since it was an Indian show, India was "obviously" going to win. Then many people were saying that Asha was so biased, etc.  At least now they know Indians plays fair and we respect outside talent. That's why there are so many Pakistani singers and actors in Bollywood. Again, congratulations to Nabeel!

Honestly, I hope they don't have another season of this show. I don't think it served the purpose of bringing the two countries and their people "together".  It did the complete opposite. I never understood why people were saying such horrible things about Asha Bhosle. I mean come on, she's a well-respected singer who has years of experience and people were cursing her out. Like come on, be mature, it's a damn show, no need to get your mouths dirty. 

Everyone is a bully these days. People think that since they are sitting behind a computer screen, they can say whatever they want to who ever they want. In real life, most of you would not say half the hurtful things you say on here. I am not just talking about the Pakistani side, I am including the Indian side as well. 

In the end, it really doesn't matter who won. Now, each and everyone is more famous and they will be making plenty of money, which was the end goal. Just look at Aman, he has already sung a few songs for movies even though he didn't "win".  Diljaan, Nabeel, Yashraj, Mulazzim, etc., in my eyes are all winners. Everyone has a different type of voice which can be used for different kinds of songs. 

In the end, people need to look within each other and try to get a grip of reality. If you're going to act like this, what are you planning on teaching your kids? To hate each others? Please, be mature. Thanks!




The following 5 member(s) liked the above post:

lotus1963s123viApril2007Niki_coolBrashCandy

s123vi Senior Member
s123vi
s123vi

Joined: 26 September 2012
Posts: 246

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 10:15am | IP Logged
@ vkaur

totally agree wid u!
 though i ll miss this show,  i don't want anothr season ! wat's d use of this aman ki asha whn ppl frm both sides r bad mouthin each othr evrytym?
indians mostly bashd aatif bt pakistanis left no stone unturnd in passin demeanin comments 4 ashaji.
d constant bashin of ashaji was beyond tolerance 4 me. she may b biasd sm tyms bt thn wat abt othr judges? they wr also not totally fair still only ashaji was targetd n calld names. it was sad 2 c sm pakistanis evn wishin 4 her death jst 4 a show!! Shockedso so cheap!Angry it was hurtful 2 c that sm ppl respect  legends on d basis of their nationality.
aatif misbehavd wid jury still he was calld a warrior. he may b a gud captain bt 4 me, he has cm out as a vry ill mannerd n arrogant prsn.

i don't think bharat pak cn evr b friends. sorry, i don't want such fake friendships.Disapprove
vkaur125 Groupbie
vkaur125
vkaur125

Joined: 10 July 2008
Posts: 88

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 11:18am | IP Logged
Originally posted by s123vi

@ vkaur

totally agree wid u!
 though i ll miss this show,  i don't want anothr season ! wat's d use of this aman ki asha whn ppl frm both sides r bad mouthin each othr evrytym?
indians mostly bashd aatif bt pakistanis left no stone unturnd in passin demeanin comments 4 ashaji.
d constant bashin of ashaji was beyond tolerance 4 me. she may b biasd sm tyms bt thn wat abt othr judges? they wr also not totally fair still only ashaji was targetd n calld names. it was sad 2 c sm pakistanis evn wishin 4 her death jst 4 a show!! Shockedso so cheap!Angry it was hurtful 2 c that sm ppl respect  legends on d basis of their nationality.
aatif misbehavd wid jury still he was calld a warrior. he may b a gud captain bt 4 me, he has cm out as a vry ill mannerd n arrogant prsn.

i don't think bharat pak cn evr b friends. sorry, i don't want such fake friendships.Disapprove

Thanks for agreeing with me. 
Yes, Pakistani judges were equally biased as well. Ghulam Ali would give 0's to the Indian singers, when they deserved a 10 and he would give 10's to the Pakistani singers when they deserved a 0. I felt the same about Abida sometimes, too. 

As for Atif, I felt he was quite rude sometimes. Even if an Indian singer sang will, he would still say "aur baither ho sakta tha". However, even if a Pakistani singer didn't do so well, he would say they were good. I mean yea, it is the job of the coach to encourage but I don't think it was right of the coach to discourage others. That's my opinion. Then he would argue with the judges. I think it was uncalled for.  I have always liked his songs and will continue to do so, as for him, I don't think so. 

There is a difference between being patriotic and being ethnocentric. One means to have love for your country and the other one means that you think you're better than the rest. And of course, it brought out an ethnocentric reaction from both sides. 

Then there is this whole issue where people start to bring in religion. I saw this one comment on Twitter, where someone tweeted something to the lines of, "I am glad Aman got a 0, Nabeel sang better than this dirty Hindu". I was appalled after reading this. Where did religion come from? What does religion have to do with this anyways? And if someone thinks their religion is better, then keep it to yourself. 

One thing I love about living in NYC is that people MOST people don't think like this. I go to school with people from all over the world, who are of different religions. I make friends, not because of the religion they follow or if they are from my culture. They are my friends because of who they are as individuals. I have Hindu, Sikh, Christian, Muslim, Buddhist, Jewish, Atheist, etc. friends and I respect them all. Unfortunately, in countries such as Pakistan, where the majority are Muslims, they don't get to experience this stuff. Same thing goes with India, unless you're in one of the major cities such as Mumbai. Thus, they think they and their religion are better than the next person. Just as all the fingers on our hands aren't all the same length, same goes for people, everyone is different. I am just saying what I feel about some (or many) people in general. So yea, I don't think India and Pakistan can be friends again either. And this is the reason. 

One thing I do love about India is the fact that it's a democracy. It doesn't have a state religion. Being 80%+ Hindus, we have a Sikh PM, when Sikhs only make up about 2-3% of the entire population. Muslims, Christians, etc. too have prominent positions in business and the government. I just hope that more people open up and accept others regardless. And I don't think this show established that, what-so-ever. Please, no more of this show! Now, I just hope people reading this don't think I am bashing a religion, country, etc. Even if they do think that, then let it be. 

I know I have partially gone off topic, so I'll end this post with a Smile





The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Real.Madrid

13-old Groupbie
13-old
13-old

Joined: 25 July 2010
Posts: 52

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 11:24am | IP Logged
Originally posted by vkaur125

Originally posted by s123vi

@ vkaur

totally agree wid u!
 though i ll miss this show,  i don't want anothr season ! wat's d use of this aman ki asha whn ppl frm both sides r bad mouthin each othr evrytym?
indians mostly bashd aatif bt pakistanis left no stone unturnd in passin demeanin comments 4 ashaji.
d constant bashin of ashaji was beyond tolerance 4 me. she may b biasd sm tyms bt thn wat abt othr judges? they wr also not totally fair still only ashaji was targetd n calld names. it was sad 2 c sm pakistanis evn wishin 4 her death jst 4 a show!! Shockedso so cheap!Angry it was hurtful 2 c that sm ppl respect  legends on d basis of their nationality.
aatif misbehavd wid jury still he was calld a warrior. he may b a gud captain bt 4 me, he has cm out as a vry ill mannerd n arrogant prsn.

i don't think bharat pak cn evr b friends. sorry, i don't want such fake friendships.Disapprove

Thanks for agreeing with me. 
Yes, Pakistani judges were equally biased as well. Ghulam Ali would give 0's to the Indian singers, when they deserved a 10 and he would give 10's to the Pakistani singers when they deserved a 0. I felt the same about Abida sometimes, too. 

As for Atif, I felt he was quite rude sometimes. Even if an Indian singer sang will, he would still say "aur baither ho sakta tha". However, even if a Pakistani singer didn't do so well, he would say they were good. I mean yea, it is the job of the coach to encourage but I don't think it was right of the coach to discourage others. That's my opinion. Then he would argue with the judges. I think it was uncalled for.  I have always liked his songs and will continue to do so, as for him, I don't think so. 

There is a difference between being patriotic and being ethnocentric. One means to have love for your country and the other one means that you think you're better than the rest. And of course, it brought out an ethnocentric reaction from both sides. 

Then there is this whole issue where people start to bring in religion. I saw this one comment on Twitter, where someone tweeted something to the lines of, "I am glad Aman got a 0, Nabeel sang better than this dirty Hindu". I was appalled after reading this. Where did religion come from? What does religion have to do with this anyways? And if someone thinks their religion is better, then keep it to yourself. 

One thing I love about living in NYC is that people MOST people don't think like this. I go to school with people from all over the world, who are of different religions. I make friends, not because of the religion they follow or if they are from my culture. They are my friends because of who they are as individuals. I have Hindu, Sikh, Christian, Muslim, Buddhist, Jewish, Atheist, etc. friends and I respect them all. Unfortunately, in countries such as Pakistan, where the majority are Muslims, they don't get to experience this stuff. Same thing goes with India, unless you're in one of the major cities such as Mumbai. Thus, they think they and their religion are better than the next person. Just as all the fingers on our hands aren't all the same length, same goes for people, everyone is different. I am just saying what I feel about some (or many) people in general. So yea, I don't think India and Pakistan can be friends again either. And this is the reason. 

One thing I do love about India is the fact that it's a democracy. It doesn't have a state religion. Being 80%+ Hindus, we have a Sikh PM, when Sikhs only make up about 2-3% of the entire population. Muslims, Christians, etc. too have prominent positions in business and the government. I just hope that more people open up and accept others regardless. And I don't think this show established that, what-so-ever. Please, no more of this show! Now, I just hope people reading this don't think I am bashing a religion, country, etc. Even if they do think that, then let it be. 

I know I have partially gone off topic, so I'll end this post with a Smile.


@vkaur
were you sleeping till now when indians were abusing badly pakistani members and singers.
Now you have  come to show your greatness here.
You people will never can come close to our singers.
We are the roots of singing Industry and you are doing copy.








Edited by 13-old - 22 December 2012 at 11:23am

The following 1 member(s) liked the above post:

Pentaminous.

13-old Groupbie
13-old
13-old

Joined: 25 July 2010
Posts: 52

Posted: 22 December 2012 at 11:25am | IP Logged
Pakistan zindaabad.

The following 2 member(s) liked the above post:

cute-alynya_ansari

Go to top

Forum Quick Jump

Forum Category / Channels
Forums

Sur Kshetra Topic Index

  • Please login to check your Last 10 Topics posted

Check these Celebrity also

Disclaimer: All Logos and Pictures of various Channels, Shows, Artistes, Media Houses, Companies, Brands etc. belong to their respective owners, and are used to merely visually identify the Channels, Shows, Companies, Brands, etc. to the viewer. Incase of any issue please contact the webmaster.

Popular Channels :
Star Plus | Zee TV | Sony TV | Colors TV | SAB TV | Life OK

Quick Links :
Top 100 TV Celebrities | Top 100 Bollywood Celebs | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise | Forum Index