Joined: 29 August 2004
Wonder: Why did Aman ask Rahul Vaidya "Who amongst Abhijeet / Sana would you like to see in the Finals?" even before the results were announced. Strange, theseorganizers are even giving out hints...[/QUOTE]
Joined: 02 September 2004
Joined: 02 September 2004
I would like to reply to the points you have raised-
Joined: 02 September 2004
The three rounds for the final are
( 1) Your fav song from Indian Idol journey
(2) Your song from Indian Idol Album
(3) Judges Choice
Joined: 20 September 2004
pmahesh, everyone is entitled to their own opinion and i must say I do agree with some of things you have said above. But while saying that, i want to add here that people are going overboard with comments that rahul vaidya was copying sonu... Sonu did not think so himself. Its people like farah khan who started this thing out.
Did u hear Rahul sing Ehsaan tera hoga.. he sang it beautifully and with loads of emotions. He sounded (of course not a patch on the original) like Rafi... Why are comparisons not being made there. Rahul has a good voice and he sings well. He carries himself well on stage and has an excellant screen presence. Abhijeet sounded like Kishore when he sand Julie.... Was he copying Kishore... NO. Allow all of them to sing their own songs and then only will u realise their originality. When each of them sings a song, it is difficult for us not to compare them with the original and judge them on their own merit. When Rahul sang Ehsaan tera hoga, naturally comparison was drawn to Mohd. rafi and immediately the mind rejected it saying it was not as good as original. But it is only when one looks at it in isolation do u realise that by himself also it was not bad and was in fact pretty good.
OK. I am a Rahul Vaidya fan, I can go on and on about him. But i feel one cannot deny him his due. I dont mean to hurt the sentiments of anyone or even comment on others opinions. I am just expressing mine.
Joined: 29 January 2005
well done priti u really said what all i wanted to say . everyone saw rahul as an over confident and very very spoilt brat except for a few people. he did deserve being voted out for his own good coz he is not yet ready to get the title and about amit sana , i think he is a wonderful singer . i havent missed even one episode of indian idol and having watched all his performances he is really a very versatile singer and he really tries hard on his stage performance and it is working too . if it is his looks then there are many who have exceptional talent minus the looks . please people there are ohter things in the besides looks . no wonder our country is the one where the most fairness products are used . and fair and lovely ad says it all . i think we should give a hint to amit sana to put fair and lovely and come for the grand finale . what wonderful ad for them .
i really really hope amit sana wins he has exceptional talent and a certain charm toooo.
good going amit sana i am keeping my fingers crossed for u
Joined: 01 October 2004
Like greatmaratha has already discussed, i find ppl always complaining abt Rahul copying sonu very strange...isnt it sonu u ppl r talking abt ???? then who could judge his voice being copied better other than sonu, but he himself isnt complaing abt that......when he finds rahul vaidya the only threat to himself in the future (and i believe sonu is one of the best singers from the whole sub-continent ) y r we questioning rahul's singing ability????? its sonu who knows more abt the ABC of singing than any of us and he doesnt have any prb with rahuls singing style, y r we making such a big issue of it?????
P.S: i hope abhijeet wins 'cuz out of the two left, hes the one who deserves the title.......but as far as voting is concerned , im prepared to expect the worst.........
Joined: 18 February 2005
thanx for replying.. i was about to reply but u raised all points so there is nothing new to say...
one more,, abhi and amit may not be humble persons in real life but in front of screen they are!!! and rahul vaidya is not !! (he is over confident, too agressive about selcting songs) he hasen't achieved much in his life but still he feels he is the best.. so what kind of person he might be in real life, we all can guess!! and as pmahesh said, we have to bother only about their screen presence not actual...
i agree that most of the music directors are inspired by any others work. even greats like c ramchandra( go re go re o banke chore - film samadhi note and note copied) o p nayyar( ae dil hai mushkil- CID) shankar jaikishan, madan mohan( tujhe kya sunao ae dilruba- ankhri dao---- original yeh hawa yeh rat ye chandani- sangdil) have copied but if you look at their entire career, u will notice that 90% songs are originals and 10% are copied or inspired, but in case of anu malik reverse is the case
he copied nusrat fateh ali khan, his barsat mein hab ayega sawan ka mahina is lifted from "main zindagi mein hardum rota hi raha hoon" and many more...
and please do not compare anu with AR rehmaan!!!! please, if u want to compare then compare him with bappi lahiri, nadeem shravan
rahul sang "ehsaan tera" really well, but sonu himself sings like rafi so whats the point? have u noticed song selection of rahul? he almost selected sonu's songs only !!! otherwise rafi's( chahunga main tujhe, ehsaan tera, ajahun ayye balama)and when he selected chaiya chaiya, we all know what happened!!,but if u compare others ... they are far ahed... most imp thing is THEY ARE ORIGINAL. and why should somebody listen a "sonu nigam" type singer? he can always listen to sonu only!!!
i have nothing personal against RV, i still feel he was the better singer amongst the whole lot ( of course barring rahul saxena and vishal kothari--i think vishal is the most unfortunate guy in this event,, loosing in the first gala round. rahul saxena vs vishal kothari in finals!!!! what a wonderful treat that would have been!!!) and the most important point u people do not consider, if he would have become the idol, he would have continued singing like sonu nigam. there wouldn't have been any improvement from his side. Atleast now one thing is assured, he can find out his mistakes(atleast he should do that) and try to work on them. this is only a begining of his career not the end.
i hope we find a new RV in the next season(sony should give him and others a second chance)as a matured singer, and it will ultimately beifit him, us and whole music world
Indian idol 4 and Indian Idol 3
Author: hardyrules Replies: 13 Views: 5777
|hardyrules||13||5777||05 November 2008 at 1:34pm by iluvparleen|
American Idol final VS Indian Idol final
Author: val0822 Replies: 1 Views: 2244
|val0822||1||2244||20 September 2007 at 7:53am by Deeya|
Darjeeling Idol and Not Indian Idol
Author: anjalibc Replies: 35 Views: 8878
|anjalibc||35||8878||08 September 2007 at 2:22pm by Tumhari_Khushi|
Indian Idol - American Idol
Author: pri_is Replies: 6 Views: 2433
|pri_is||6||2433||21 June 2007 at 7:25pm by roshniae|
Popular Channels :
Quick Links :