Posted: 15 November 2012 at 7:27pm | IP Logged
Ive seen Sare Ga ma Pa
those singers go off sur so much but still the judges mostly Shankar m go wah wah
of course some of them are good. they pick out those who hav got classical training
and been singing for some years in public. like jasraj. he is a performer.
but really i dnt understand the judges going completely crazy over his performance.
i think nabeel and sara outperform somebody like jasraj any day and budha, aman,
yashraj are better than him.
i like sur kshetra because get to revisit some songs of older days which are really
melodius but we hv forgotten and the pakistani singers sing such lovely pakistani
songs which i can only know by hearing them here. normally i dont listen to pakistani
songs. people like mulazim unigue voice, style, imraan melodius voice, they are
different and completelely raw so there is some sort of raw appeal about them.
this is why i like sur kshetra otherwise there is always indian idol star voice of india
and x factor etc if you want normal style popular songs.
Another thing is because of different backgrounds culture etc nabeel mulazim and
imraan bring a different kind of personality to the show. they hv some very earthy
feel to them not cosmopolitan completely and they way they present themselves and
interact brings a different feel. i hv seen yashraj too many times on other shows at
least three i think and dont find his showmanship appealing, you can get that every
popular singing show, that hero giri and that kind of dancing to the girl and all im
tired of it all now having seen it all before. i know the presenters are trying to push
him forward in limelight in every episode to compete with other team in personality
and maybe they are really setting him to compete in final but whatever, if the
pakistanis werent there with atif mulazim imraan nabeel this show would lose some
appeal for me. i wont say sara because she is good in singing but her personality is
okay nothing extraordinary.
i think diljaan adds a whole lot here and maybe aman because his singing is powerful
and he presents different kind of style even in dressing and looks with his hair tied back
and all that.
the above is my take and no one else need agree with me. i know we are all different
people with different likes dislikes and POVs.
Edited by pakeezah - 15 November 2012 at 7:39pm