Posted: 10 November 2012 at 5:09pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by estel@Bold - She came for aploizing for what she said to him and he said he forgave her for what she said to him. He might have thought that she is very disturbed and that why he didn't tell her at that time. And one more thing Sapna n sidhuji chated for sometime abt this in Live Feed where sapna told him that she is suffering from depression n may be sidhuji must have told her that she went wrong .
@Bold - So abt whom was he talking? He didn't name anyone.Did he? And ofcourse disliking thinking process of certain people is No crime. He would have come across as dual face only if he has praised thinking process of some at first place n later denied it/ But he didn't. If you are talking about Sapna then he clearly told her what he felt in Katgara istead of bad mouthing abt her .
And whats wrong with hugging someone? Come on this is No war. Diagreeing with someones thought process is one thing that doesn't mean if someone disagree u can't be friendly n nice to person.
I don't know about you but I do take objection to "Koi baat nahin
". If you object someone's attitude, their thought process and their behavior then don't say that
. That is misleading.
Not like he "liked her" why hug her and tell her he "understands" her. You can't necessarily understand
someone if you dislike their thought process. She came around looking for approval and that was the perfect time to tell her behavior outside wasn't right.
I know I am not the only one that objected to Sidhu's behavior with Sapna in that scene. Dexter and I were both convinced he should have pointed out she was wrong instead of hugging her and all his subsequent dialogues afterwards.
Yes, he told it to her later, but that hugging scene is misleading. He hasn't included her as part of "liked" nor did he dislike her. One example in this forum I can give you is cruiser's post - even cruiser thought it looked
a bit personal. That's strange when you don't even consider the person as one that you like.
Only time anything was shown to audience was Katghara where sidhuji totally objected her behaviour. Why hugging scene was misleading? She said sorry to him n was crying. So he hugged her just to console her at that moment? Come on now hugging n forgiving is also sin
And different people react to situation in different , may be he might have thought to give her some space n let matter calm down so he He deferred his stance till he understand full situation.