Originally posted by HakkaBakka
Originally posted by tulipbaby53
I think she has a wonderful and strong voice, but I still didn't like how the judges put her in the Top 15 even though she messed up her 2nd audition. I know she's talented and capable, but they were supposed to judge based on that day. They did not show such mercy on others. I didn't find it fair because her rendition of "Sajda" start strong, but it fell apart after that. Even Shankar Mahadevan had to sing along with her.
Now, I'm not trying to hate on her or anything like that! I like her and her voice, but I just did not find this one thing fair.
Tulip, if Renu proved to be very good singer going forward then all credit should be going to judges, their guts and instincts. They gave her chance just based on her singing instead of any other biasing. Yes, if Renu failed then I will blame judge and their judgement about identitying talent.
Yeah, I understand what you're trying to say. I do again want to repeat that I do love her voice. I think did prove herself to be worthy of the Top 15 during Saturday's episode, but I just wonder if they had ignored some of the other contestants' second auditions (because they were not as strong), what if they would also be able to prove themselves worthy of being in the Top 15? Again, I do love her voice, but I just did not find it really fair on the judges.