Mhatma Gandhi Certainly played A Big Role In Our Independence !

But Often At Times I Meet People Who Think And Believe That Many of his work was Not Right .
Ex: -  bhagat singh , sukhdev and rajguru got hanged till death , if gandhi would have wanted He Could Have Save Them ?

Like : when Gandhi ended NCM (national cooperation movement ) Respected J.L.Nehru and S.C.Bose gote angry and left him and goes on to Make separate party .!

There may be many more .

there are positive too , he fought for racial discrimination in south africa and won the movement over there .
people say some his desicion taken that time was correct too !



wana ask you awl , which side you are in ??

Edited by Ankithate - 01 October 2012 at 5:59am

1 lyk d4 G4ndh1 c0s h3 b3 l1k3 t0t4lly g4ngst4 b0ss dud3. H3 b3 s0 g4ngst4 d4t d4 P0mm13s b3 runn1ng w1t d4 t41ls btwn d4 l3gs

 There is no doubt in regards to his contribution during freedom Struggle. But I DON'T LIKE HIM FOR @Bold reason

First, Gandhi had nothing to do with respect to the execution of Bhagat Singh, Sukhdev and Rajguru..Gandhi-Irwin pact clearly mentioned that it would not cover the release of those prisoners who were accused of murder or terrorism and hence Gandhi could not bargain their life on papers. But still Gandhi sent personal mercy petition to the viceroy, as he was against capital punishment, which obviously got rejected..

Second, I think you are confusing two events - CR Das and Motilal Nehru formed the Swaraj Party after Gandhi called off the non-cooperation movement and was imprisoned. (They wanted to push for reforms from within the constituent assembly, instead of boycotting it.) Subhas Chandra Bose formed Forward Block after Gandhi thwarted his plans of launching offensive campaigns against the British, at the eve of the war with the help of Axis powers..Gandhi deemed Bose's obvious inclination towards authoritarian regimes obnoxious; besides he believed, and with strong reasons, that an uprising in India might directly affect the war in Europe and lead to Nazi victory over Britain and Europe...We must note, at this time Britain was completely alone against the Axis powers, facing the brunt of German air invasion at home while Japanese forces were speeding towards South Asia. US was neutral and Russia had a non-aggression pact with Germany. That is why, I think, Gandhi launched his civil-disobedience movement only when the two sides were evenly matched and prospects of German victory over Europe were finished.

Anyways, Happy Gandhi Jayanti to all Indians and Happy International Non-Violence Day to all humans..

Gandhi preached non violence, and it all went down the drain during partition. Where was he when the violence spread across the border? All years of non-violence was out in one go. 

Edited by Aquilia_Aditi - 01 October 2012 at 3:47pm

THE ACCOUNT OF THE MEMBER WHO POSTED THIS MESSAGE HAS BEEN TEMPORARILY BANNED.

If you think this is an error please Contact us.

@ Bold:  Excuse ME  ...Did ya just call me MEAN ? I have always lived for others ..Yay ! ..I can live for you too if you insist on that ... ...Ask my dead GF / BF whom I killed accidentally ...and they ll ascertain that .. I have been following Gandhi's rules from the 17th Century ...And I do not contrite over that...And what do you mean there is nothing that's unethical ? Do you believe even Murder and Rape are ethical? Does your conscience allow ya to advocate such crimes? Or call them ethical ? huh!  ...No wonder a few who Loathe me have LIKED your post ...The same sweet people who want me dead ..

                                       Hold on... My  STEP uncle would like to say something to you ...Let me hand the keyboard to him ..

 Hey Aditi ..
 
 Hahaha ..I'm Vintu's Step Uncle ...Don't pay any heed to what Vintu has to say ..Cause Vintu is MUG   ..Haha ..Yeah ..I like your thoughts ..and concur with ya ..Thou art amazing ..I idolize  Addy ..( Adolf Hitler  )  ..My favorite ...He too believed in the Third Reich for the Germans  ..his Favorite .. ..He massacred all who didn't believe in him..

  Live for yourself is the Mantra ..Ethics and Morales are passe values ..and very unethical ..I refuse to believe in such obsolete way of thinking .. ..You don't need to be sorry about anything ..Cause like you I too don't believe in Gandhian principles and not even a bit sorry about that..
.
 Cheers to you ..Cheers to us ...

I hate for the reason that he delayed our independence. He preached non violence but supported british during world war and told indian soldier's to fight on their part instead of supporting S.C.BOSE he was partial in that sense. He sat on a fast to handle 65 crores to pakistan after indepence when v wer at war with them.