Adigaag: It's time to stop saying that Gurmeet is a non-dancer...That's exactly my point - Gurmeet can dance - whether he is a good dancer or not is subjective - so why were so many of his fans and Jhalak saying he is a non-dancer when originally these same very fans said he was a fantastic dancer.
You missed my point completely - that is why I used the word "probably" and never used the word "definitively" - you cannot have it both ways - either he was a non-dancer or a fantastic dancer. In other words, if he was a non-dancer then that is proved to be false by the videos of him dancing prior to Jhalak but if he could dance like that before and after Jhalak (see his very good dance performance for Yash's birthday/Zee TV celebration in Punar Vivah on October 2nd) then why was that dance ability not shown on Jhalak in his performances - his performances on Jhalak made him appear to be a "non-dancer", that's all.
He has won and that has been accepted - but why should some of you get to write and keep writing that Gurmeet is a non-dancer and won and why can some of us not be able to rebut that. Why have you and other fans not moved on from this - the moment you move on, the rest will do so but if you guys continue making false statements then the rest of us have a right to rebut that. Freedom of speech for you and freedom of speech for us.
There would be no rebuttal if Jhalak and you and other fans would have said that Gurmeet went from an average dancer to a better dancer instead of saying he was a non-dancer.
I don't know about other celebrities because I only started watching Jhalak because of Gurmeet but soon got disillusioned by all the hate and negativity towards other contestants from some of his fans.