Originally posted by shellily
Atif is a really bad singer, its his looks,songs and personality which has made him what he is. The way he sang with Ashaji I was totally cringing, he was sooo off key.
Mia I agree lots of people have voiced their opinions...but then I
think the opinions should go for anyone who sings regardless of whose
side is singing. What I saw in the last show was everyone went against the Pak singers even when at so many times they sounded better than their Indian counterparts. The Indians were just given the wow you are so good speil even when they werent. I dont know everyone's names yet it will take me 3-4 watches to know who everyone is
Im very bad with names that way !
But I hope everyone gets fair judgement. I see Atif bashing for no reason and despite what a jerk he may be on the show atleast he has shown restraint. The points he was giving just reflected his frustration at the ONLY negative comments his team was receiving even though they were not all that bad. But lets see how it shapes out. At least in the last episode I thought it was all very unfair.
Finally Someone else who understands Music
I honestly was shocked and annoyed seeing atif sing off pitch in front of Asha ji .. and she tried so hard to divert her mind and keep a smile on her face and started waving her hands.. He really trashed the song. and It was one of my All times favs so i was very upset.
I think the fact Atif is a mentor is a joke. He has no knowledge about music , sur , taal , N he is sooo monotone. At least Himesh has Musical Knowledge and understands the MUSIC 101 .
And as i said before , the Pakistani Side has better Voice and voice quality but not on pitch . which becomes a problem . and Indian not good voices. except Diljaan . I honestly only like 2 singers Diljaan and Nabeel . they both should win the show .
Atif attitude Sucks on this show .. from episode 2 he has been making smart remarks towards Indian singers n especially with the janbaz Crap .. and the comment on Indrani not having a good voice ( sooo not necessary) . And beginning of Episode 3 . Himesh spoke about team india and his contestants while atif was hell bent on proving his contestants have more himmat and jaanbaz to win over india .Lmao nice way of Introducing team pakistan .
HImesh and Atif need to be thrown out of the show . and replaces wiht rahat fateh ali khan and suresh wadkar . these two are a joke. But at least Himesh has Knowledge and is a awesome Music Director .
Fair judgement - well regardless there are 3 judges . Parveen ji and Runa Ji . Runa Ji is giving her comments . Even if Asha is more pro India . Diljaan comments are universal, therefore Good pitch prefect singing will be noticed and given a good score . and from team india only one person got a standing ovation . Indrani. Praveen was too lazy to get up for diljaan .
Even runa ji didn't give Extremely positive comments for team Pakistan . and that guy on team india who is sick .. so idk .. Asha is more vocal but she is not the only one speaking .
Edited by Mia1love - 17 September 2012 at 9:40am