Sur Kshetra Discussion Thread (Page 9)

Originally posted by April2007

Originally posted by Niki_cool

Originally posted by -Alina-

Originally posted by Niki_cool

Highly dissapointed from Asha Jee's comments, Really even i as an Indian can feel she is biassed :-/ Its transparently reflecting from her comments
And next Atif and Himesh, both have their own flaws but Asha jee is at the top!

We can expect such behavior from Atif and Himesh but not from Asha jee !! isn't she supposed to the most mature one present on the show? she is a legend, but its sad to see the way she is being their...people are saying this show is scripted and its just the acting we see...For me its just a horrible piece of act I have ever seen !! Whether its Atif, Himesh, Ayesha Takkia or Asha jee...even for the sake of money I dont think anyone could be part of such a thing !!

Tbh, after watching Indian Idol, I didn't like Asha Jee as a Judge, because when she judges she thinks she is the only Great Judge, Why are there Three jury members? All are equally capable and great..Its pathetic to see that Asha Jee who was expected to be the most mature of all seems like to be the most biassed.
If this is a drama, its even more terrible, It shows people crave nothing except money, They don't understand its high time we get some peace and they are just worsening the situation.
And the saddest part is the judges represent their countries, I felt so upset and sad bcoz due to just some people, existing peace b/w rest of Indians & Pakistanis will vanish, bcoz people have already started arguing about this and comparing with past fights.!!

I think Ashaji is a very good judge..Atif has a problem..Ashaji doesn't have to appease Pakistani and lie to herself..

The hate Atif has in his heart for Indians and Indian singers is coming through..

Their is no love for Pakistanis for India or Indians, it is only that Pakistan finds itself in very dire state that they want peace. If they were okay they will be waging war and sending terrorists to India..

Well i just presented my own opinion and Asha Jee was truly harsh in her comments in the first two episodes, thats what i felt.. well yesterday's & today's epi i had no complains from her:)

I didn't say she has to LIE to herself, a judges opinion is her OWN, i totally agree and m not saying abt marks, i had problem with asha jee when she said, "HINDUSTAAN KA DIL BADA HAI crap" & "AAJKAL KOI URDU NAHI GAATA HAI"pronunciation doesn't matter ...to Runa jee and similar stuff...

 Well i never said Atif is an angel either...i m a atif fan ,but that doesn't means i support him if he's wrong in comments

 And hey its strictly a DISCUSSION FORUM where we discuss about songs & the show not about  PRESENT ISSUES b/w India & Pakistan or whatever is going on...I AM AN INDIAN TOO...so if u are disgusted by Pakistanis then express ur disgust somewhere else, if u are disgusted abt singers u can do so here...:)

Coz we are a family here in this forum:)

PS: No intention to hurt anyone's feelings