Posted: 23 September 2012 at 12:13pm | IP Logged
Originally posted by Niki_cool
Originally posted by ~Saraa~
@Red: I'm not sure what you mean but from what I understand, you are not serious right? Atif is being forced to give such crude comments. And for Indraani it was totally unfair. Team Pakistan got REALLY bad marks yesterday and for no reason whereas, Indraani did not give a performance worth 30 marks at all.
No dear, m totally serious From yesterday's episode i felt, he was just trying to fight...
I liked Indraani's performance and i guess thats why 3 of the judges each gave her 10. But what I am trying to say is if Atif didn't like a performance thats his personal view, so why did he say Indraani that SHE IS NOT SELF-SATISFIED?? like how did he know?
Also, it's funny when you say that Himesh is being so nice and fair. Really? He gets hyper at something that Atif says for no reason. I'm actually glad Atif is being rude because he is being sidelined by EVERYONE including the judges.I totally agree he gets hyper, but mostly that happens because of ironical comments by atif
Well i appreciate himesh that he tries to supress fights. Well i also agree with you that atif does get sidelined , but that absolutely doesn't means he expresses his frustration on a contestant? like Indraani!!!
And on an ending note, I'll just say that Asha is VERY bias. She needs to not be judgmental and be fair. So does the Bangladeshi Judge. I don't remember her name keep forgetting. But if she can say that "Aapka sur hila" for Team Pakistan and not give them a 10 then she should be fair and do the same for Team India too. She just told one of the contestants from Team India that his sur was way out and then gave him a 10. So, how can one expect Atif to remain nice and polite when this unfair judgement is happening?
YES Asha jee is bias, i felt that in the first two epis, but not with todays's or yesterday's
U mean runa, sorry but i feel she's the most fair judge of all:P
yeah but she said, "AAPKE BAHT JAGAH SUR HILE" to that pak contestant, and i think the judges gave unecessary 10s to both Indian and Pak contestants.. Its happening with both not only pakistanis...
I'm not trying to be offensive. Sorry in advance if you mind. Same here hehehe
I would disagree with you but everyone has their own views.
Only Team Pakistan's contestants get side-lined and so is Atif.
You tell me how is it fair that after saying that to the Indian Contestant as well, she still gave him a 10. And both the judges had given the same Pakistani contestant 10, giving him a grand total of 20/30?
The judges are not good enough. I don't know who could have sat in their position but these judges are not fair at all.
Asha was not fair today either. She was a little better than the last 3 episodes but she was still bias towards Team India.
Also, I really think that Ayesha should ask the opinion of the Captains once the judges have given their comments and marks. The contestants somewhat don't respect the Captains and their views since they give their opinion first and later the judges disagree and give them a 30/30 when the contestant actually deserves a 10/30.